This Module provides the requirements and procedures for the calculation of net carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e) removal from the atmosphere through improved forest management (IFM) practices that protect forests from planned logging operations. This Module addresses scenarios where forests with active timber concessions or legal harvest allocations would undergo logging under baseline conditions but are instead maintained as intact, protected forests under the Project.
Commercial timber harvest encompasses a range of silvicultural systems employed globally to extract merchantable wood products from forests. Harvest practices include selective logging, clear-cutting, keyhole rotation, shelterwood systems, seed tree systems, group selection, and various hybrid approaches adapted to site-specific conditions, market demands, and regulatory frameworks1,2.
While timber harvest systems vary substantially in their ecological outcomes, all forms of commercial harvest result in short-term carbon stock reductions relative to undisturbed forest conditions. Clear-cutting operations remove nearly all aboveground biomass from harvest areas, creating temporary non-forest conditions before regeneration3 on rotation cycles of 25-120 years4. Selective logging, while it maintains continuous forest cover through rotation cycles5, generates carbon emissions through direct extraction of merchantable timber, collateral damage to residual stands6,7, the establishment of forestry infrastructure (e.g., roads, skid trails, landing areas), and altered forest structure that impacts the regeneration dynamics and future carbon accumulation rates of the forest8,9. Shelterwood and seed tree systems cumulatively remove the majority of original stand biomass while managing for specific regeneration outcomes10, often requiring additional maintenance which increases GHG emissions10,11.
Forest protection from commercial timber harvest — regardless of the specific silvicultural practice(s) employed — delivers multiple climate, community, and ecological benefits. Protected forests maintain their capacity for continued carbon sequestration and storage, maintain soil carbon pools otherwise degraded by harvest operations, and sustain the forest structural integrity and biodiversity that enhance ecosystem resilience to climate change12,3,8,9. Research demonstrates that forest-based natural climate solutions can provide over two-thirds of the 11.3 gigatons CO2e per year of cost-effective mitigation needed by 2030 to stabilize warming below 2°C, with forest conservation and improved management representing pathways with additional co-benefits13,14.
However, forest protection projects have traditionally faced substantial methodological challenges in credibly quantifying carbon benefits. Legacy standards and methodologies have relied on static baselines of projected harvest schedules over multi-decadal time periods, introducing considerable uncertainty around harvest timing and intensity, operational efficiency, and collateral impacts. These uncertainties have led to systematic concerns about baseline accuracy and over-crediting in past improved forest management carbon projects15,16.
This Module addresses these methodological challenges by taking a scientifically rigorous approach that combines legal and operational validation of baseline harvest scenarios with a dynamic baseline approach that compares project forests to similar reference forests within the same region undergoing commercial timber harvest operations, accounting for variations in forest type, forest structure, species composition, operational accessibility, regulatory environment, economic context, management history, and site conditions. The Module employs advanced remote sensing technology, including LiDAR-enhanced forest inventories, to monitor carbon accumulation with high precision across The Project while maintaining rigorous standards for measurement, reporting, and verification. This Module thus ensures accurate quantification of additional carbon benefits while easing the technical burden on Project Proponents through continuous change detection owned jointly by Isometric and The Project Proponent. This Module is not geographically-limited in application, and can be used in any location where all the requirements therein can be met.
To ensure high ecological fidelity, project crediting durations are established based on the expected maturity of the specific forest types, with a required ongoing monitoring period to ensure meaningful carbon storage duration.
This Module accounts for the quantification of the gross amount of CO2e removed via enhanced carbon storage in forest biomass, as well as all cradle-to-grave life-cycle Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions associated with the implementation process. This Module is developed to adhere to the requirements of ISO 14064-2: 2019 – Greenhouse Gasses – Part 2: Specification with guidance at the project level for quantification, monitoring, and reporting of greenhouse gas emission reductions or removal enhancements.
The Module ensures:
Throughout this Module, obligation language follows the Isometric convention: "must" indicates a requirement, "should" indicates a recommendation, and "may" indicates an option or permission.
This Module relies on and is intended to be compliant with the following standards and protocols:
Additional reference standards that inform the requirements and overall practices incorporated in this Module include:
Additional principles that were considered in the development of this Module and aligned with, where feasible, include:
This Module was developed based on the current state of the art, publicly available science regarding IFM activities and long-term monitoring of forest carbon projects. This Module aims to be scientifically stringent and robust. We recognize that some requirements may exceed the status quo in the market and that there are numerous opportunities to improve the rigor of this Module as new approaches and techniques enter the Voluntary Carbon Market.
Additionally, this Module will be reviewed when there is an update to published scientific literature, government policies, or legal requirements which would affect net CO2e removal quantification or the monitoring guidelines outlined in this Module, or at a minimum of every 2 years.
In addition to the requirements outlined in Section 4 of the Improved Forest Management Protocol, Projects are subject to the following applicability requirements, which must be demonstrated in the Project Design Document (PDD).
In order to maintain ecological integrity and ecosystem function, demonstrate additionality, and ensure trust and transparency, Project Proponents must adhere to the requirements below, which must be demonstrated and reported in the Project Design Document.
To ensure accurate carbon sequestration claims and facilitate Validation and Verification, each Project registered under this Module is organised as a single Site or a group of Sites, where a Site is a set of parcels subject to similar bioclimatic, regulatory, and geographic conditions. Carbon quantification is conducted at the Site level (see Section 9).
Project Proponents must register each Project as a single Site or group of Sites, and must enroll all eligible areas of each parcel within each Site.
[/R-PN4V-0]Grouping rules
Conditional Requirement — Access exception
Where a parcel does not have road or navigable waterway access, Project Proponents may include it only after consultation with Isometric, supported by documented extenuating circumstances such as a legal easement or a prior commercial harvest history, with the justification recorded in the PDD.
[/R-AA0G-0]To ensure the credibility of the climate impact of project activities, non-additional areas of The Project must be excluded, as set out by various requirements in Section 4.1 of the Improved Forest Management Protocol and Section 4.1.2 of this Module.
Selective enrollment — i.e., enrolling only the less-desirable-to-harvest areas of a parcel while continuing to harvest the more desirable areas — would compromise Project integrity. Project Proponents must therefore enroll all eligible areas of each parcel. Exclusions are permitted only for reasons explicitly allowed by this Module or the Improved Forest Management Protocol, and each excluded area must be documented and mapped in the PDD, with sufficient justification of the legal, financial, or operational restriction on harvest, to fulfil the cumulative-impact-assessment requirements of the IFM Protocol (see Section 4.1.2).
Areas where ecological or operational conditions make baseline harvesting unlikely cannot be claimed as additional and must therefore be excluded from the Project Boundary. Soil saturation, permanent water bodies, slope, proximity to dwellings and structures, and market accessibility each create natural or regulatory limits on where harvesting would occur under baseline management.
Project Proponents must identify and exclude from Crediting (see Section 4.1.1.1) any area within the Project Boundary where the economic, physical, or regulatory constraints described in Sections 4.1.2.1–4.1.2.5 make baseline harvesting highly unlikely.
Historically, harvesting in waterlogged soils has depended on prolonged freezing periods to provide ground stability for heavy timber equipment. Climate change has reduced the predictability and duration of those freezing windows, particularly in temperate and polar regions, making winter harvesting increasingly unreliable. Harvest avoidance in such soils therefore typically does not represent additional management beyond what would occur under baseline conditions.
Project Proponents must identify and exclude from Crediting any area within the Project Boundary with soils classified as "very poorly drained" or "inundated" under the U.S. Soil Taxonomy classification system, or similarly classified soils in an equivalent authoritative source for Projects outside the United States.
[/R-XYW5-0]Conditional Requirement — Operability Exception
A Project Proponent may include areas with soils classified as "very poorly drained" or "inundated" within the Project Boundary where it demonstrates that baseline harvesting operations remain economically viable despite drainage limitations. To do so, the Project Proponent must evidence all of the following:
[/R-HKQT-0]Project Proponents must identify and exclude from Crediting any area within the Project Boundary that falls within a management buffer around a permanent water body as defined by applicable governmental regulations or voluntary Best Management Practices (BMPs) (see Appendix B of the Improved Forest Management Protocol).
[/R-58KF-0]Steep terrain limits the economic and operational feasibility of harvest. The U.S. Forest Service has found that conventional harvest equipment encounters significant limitations on slopes of 25–35%, with severe constraints above 35%17. Changes in carbon stocks on areas too steep to reasonably harvest do not meet the additionality condition.
Project Proponents must exclude from Crediting any area with sustained slopes exceeding 30% over 30 metres in regions where specialized steep-slope harvesting equipment is not commonly deployed18.
[/R-RXF4-0]Project Proponents must evidence the above with:
Regulations and BMPs commonly prohibit harvesting within a specified proximity of built structures.
Project Proponents must exclude from Crediting any area within 15 metres of a permanent structure, or within a larger buffer if required by applicable regulations or BMPs (see Appendix B of the Improved Forest Management Protocol).
[/R-076E-0]Project Proponents must demonstrate that each Site contains sufficient merchantable stocking in a market where harvests would be economically viable in the baseline scenario. This has two components: a Site-level economic viability test, and a regional market-capacity test. Both must be satisfied for a Site to be eligible.
Economic viability of each Site
Project Proponents must conduct, for each Site, a Site-specific financial analysis of timber harvest under baseline management. The analysis must include revenues, costs, and a discount rate selected by landowner classification (see Table 1).
[/R-KW23-0]A Site is classified as economically viable for baseline harvest where either of the following holds:
[/G-JA59-0]Project Proponents must exclude any Site failing both tests.
[/G-5Z0Y-0]Revenue inputs. Site-level financial analysis should include gross timber revenues calculated using (a) stumpage values taken from regional market pricing and/or forest-type pricing from Isometric's implementation of the Global Timber Model (GTM), and (b) merchantable volumes by product class (where feasible) at enrolment.
Cost inputs. Project Proponents should enumerate — to best approximation — costs for (a) logging and processing; (b) access infrastructure; (c) transportation from parcel to processing facility; (d) equipment mobilisation; (e) post-harvest obligations; (f) administrative and regulatory costs; and (g) property-carrying costs during harvest. Costs may be taken from Isometric's implementation of the GTM (see Section 8.2).
Reporting. For each Site, Project Proponents must report: (a) merchantable volumes, ideally by species and product class; (b) revenue calculations with price sources and dates, and/or GTM-derived revenue; (c) complete cost enumeration with supporting data, and/or GTM-derived costs; (d) NPV or IRR worksheets showing discount-rate application; and (e) a sensitivity analysis demonstrating the impact of ±20% parameter variations on viability.
[/G-SKWK-0]Table 1 — Discount rates by landowner classification
Landowner classification | Discount rate | Typical indicators |
|---|---|---|
Commercial Orientation | 6% | Commercial timber operations as primary business |
Smallholder — Commercial Orientation | 5% | Landowner ≤ 2,000 ha of harvestable forest, primarily commercial use |
Smallholder — Subsistence / Mixed Objectives | 4.5% | Landowner ≤ 2,000 ha of harvestable forest, mixed subsistence and commercial use |
Community Forest | 4% | Collectively owned and managed forest |
Indigenous Land(s) | 3% | Indigenous-held forest, recognised through customary or formal title |
The rate in Table 1 for the Site's landowner classification is used both as the discount rate in the NPV test and as the minimum acceptable rate in the IRR test. Isometric will verify the applicable rate at Site enrollment based on documented ownership characteristics, management objectives, and regional economic conditions. Higher rates indicate greater commercial orientation. For the purposes of this Module, smallholders are landowners owning up to 2,000 hectares of harvestable forest land.
Re-enrolment requirements (economic viability)
Project Proponents must re-evaluate economic viability at each re-enrolment of the Site(s). At re-evaluation, Project Proponents must update economic parameters, recalculate parcel viability, and adjust classifications. Re-evaluation is prospective: changes affect current and future baseline projections without retroactive adjustment to historical CreditCertificate issuance.
Market capacity assessment
In addition to Site-level economic analysis, Project Proponents must evaluate whether sufficient regional market capacity exists to absorb the timber volumes from enrolled Sites under baseline harvest scenarios.
[/R-ETN2-0]For each Site classified as economically viable, Project Proponents must identify and/or confirm:
[/G-D8R8-0]For each Site classified as economically viable, Project Proponents should identify and/or confirm:
Project Proponents must assess whether aggregate baseline harvest volumes from all economically viable project Sites would exceed regional processing capacity by:
[/G-MJFJ-0]Project Proponents must account for existing non-Project timber supply as part of this analysis.
[/G-87B7-0]Where appropriate, Project Proponents may consider temporal market dynamics to justify the additionality of The Project, such as:
Where significant market changes are documented or reasonably anticipated, Project Proponents should adjust merchantability classifications or apply appropriate discount factors to baseline projections.
Where market capacity is exceeded by The Project, Project Proponents must remove Site(s) until the aggregate baseline harvest volumes from all economically viable project Sites fall below the regional processing capacity.
[/G-VW6W-0]Re-enrollment requirements (market capacity)
Project Proponents must re-evaluate market capacity determinations at each re-enrolment of the Site(s). At re-evaluation, Project Proponents must update market capacity assessments, recalculate regional absorption capacity, and adjust Site merchantability classifications as warranted. Re-evaluation is prospective: changes affect current and future baseline projections without retroactive adjustment to historical CreditCertificate issuance.
Crediting under The Project can be manipulated by inflating recent harvests ahead of enrollment. To prevent this, Project Proponents must demonstrate that harvest intensity by the Project Proponent and any prior landowner(s) did not increase above historical rates after consideration of enrollment in a carbon project, under this Standard or another.
[/R-P4CC-0]Project Proponents must demonstrate, for each Site, that the harvested carbon stocks at the most recent harvest event were not greater than the historical average by more than one standard deviation.
[/G-S8CH-0]Acceptable evidence for either identification or estimation is one or a combination of the following:
Where a forest growth curve is used, Project Proponents must provide the data and code used to generate the curve, along with justification for the selected approach (e.g., FVS, Chapman-Richards, etc.).
Conditional Requirement — Regional deviation
A Site where the most recent harvest removal exceeds the historical average by more than one standard deviation is ineligible, unless Project Proponents can demonstrate comparable regional deviations over the same timeframe, indicating a broader driving dynamic.
[/R-9S81-0]Isometric reserves the right to audit submitted harvest data using earth-observation remote sensing systems and to compare those results against submitted harvest claims.
The purpose of this Module is to transition commercially logged forests into mature forests that durably store carbon. That transition depends on enforceable forest protection at the end of the Crediting Period. For the purposes of this Module, "protection" follows the IUCN definition of a protected area:
"A clearly defined geographical space, recognised, dedicated and managed, through legal or other effective means, to achieve the long-term conservation of nature with associated ecosystem services and cultural values".19
Governance of protected areas may be private, governmental, or by Indigenous peoples and local communities. Eligible forms of protection include, but are not limited to: wildlife management areas, forest reserves, conservation easements, and community conservancies.
Project Proponents must demonstrate an intent to protect the project area at Validation, and must ensure that formal protection status commences at the end of the Crediting Period.
[/R-XE3P-0]Formal protection must not commence before the end of the Crediting Period, to avoid conflicts with regulatory additionality (see IFM Protocol Section 7.7.2).
Conditional Requirement — No formal protection agreement in place at Validation
Where formal agreements to place the project area into protection by the end of the Crediting Period are not in place at Validation, Project Proponents must describe in their PDD how they intend to protect the forest after Crediting. At each Verification where no formal agreement is in place, an additional 5% contribution to the Buffer Pool must be made (see IFM Protocol Section 10 and Appendix C of this Module for how this combines with the base buffer contribution).
[/R-H2ZB-0]This Module is intended to transition commercially logged forests to protected mature forests, not to establish new forest. Accordingly, new planting cannot be the primary method of achieving forest cover.
Project Proponents must limit new planting to small areas — each less than 1 hectare — and to any of the following purposes:
[/R-4QV0-0]Project Proponents must:
The timeline for Projects crediting under this Module is described by a Project Commitment Period. The Project Commitment Period encompasses two distinct periods, the Crediting Period plus a minimum 40-year Ongoing Monitoring Period which commences after the end of the Crediting Period.
[/R-RCPN-0]For grouped Projects or Projects where there is a mixture of initial stand ages within the project area such that there is variation in the timing of individual Crediting Periods and Ongoing Monitoring Periods, the overall Project Commitment Period must reflect the collective start and end dates for all areas within The Project (i.e., the start of the first Crediting Period through the end of the last Ongoing Monitoring Period).
[/G-HSCT-0]The length of the Crediting Period under this Module must reflect the anticipated time to forest maturity within the project area. The underlying data and/or modeling for these estimates must be provided in the PDD and demonstrate that they are informed by harvesting history/stand age, forest growth factors, and tree biology within the project area.
[/G-5E8F-0]For project areas where there is a mixture of initial stand ages (e.g., as a result of staggered harvesting history), this may result in distinct Crediting Period durations across the project area. In this scenario, the PDD must report how the project area will be divided into areas with distinct Crediting Periods and provide evidence for the length for each individual area.
[/G-S344-0]The Project Proponent must then set the overall Crediting Period length for The Project to the maximum of these Site-specific Crediting Periods.
[/G-CQZS-0]The Crediting Period consists of successive Reporting Periods. Project Proponents must set the length of each Reporting Period to between 1 and 5 years (inclusive), consistent with Section 5.2 of the IFM Protocol.
The Ongoing Monitoring Period commences at the end of the Crediting Period. The Ongoing Monitoring period must be a minimum of 40 years and a maximum of 100 years. The durability of CreditsCertificates are determined by the duration of the Ongoing Monitoring Period. Throughout the Ongoing Monitoring Period, Isometric will conduct monitoring for Reversals. If a Reversal is detected, the Project Proponent is responsible for conducting Reversal Reporting (see IFM Protocol Section 10.5.2). Reversals during the Ongoing Monitoring Period are compensated by the Buffer Pool (see IFM Protocol Section 10.4).
A project has a Project Commitment Period of 100 years composed of a 40 year Crediting Period followed by 60 year Ongoing Monitoring Period. CreditsCertificates issued have a 60+ year durability. Monitoring for quantification is conducted by the Project Proponent through the Crediting Period, and the reported activities are verified by a Validation and Verification Body (VVB) for each Reporting Period. At the end of the Crediting Period, maintenance of carbon stocks and monitoring for Reversals occurs for the remaining 60 years of the Project Commitment Period.
Project Proponents must develop and report a forest management plan (FMP) for each Site.
[/R-ZPDZ-0]Additionally, certain forest management activities must also be disclosed by the Project Proponent, such as Stand Improvement Activities, subject to the requirements set forth by Isometric in this Module, the IFM Protocol (Section 6.5), and the Isometric Standard.
Project Proponents may engage in Isometric-approved stand-improvement activities. These activities must be approved by Isometric to ensure that the volume of harvested wood does not exceed the volume of issued CreditsCertificates.
Validation requirements
Reporting requirements
Permitted activities
CreditCertificate issuance following stand improvement
CreditsCertificates must not be issued until the forest biomass within the Site recovers above the Site's most recent pre-stand-improvement carbon stock baseline.
Project emissions associated with stand-improvement activities must be reported according to the IFM Protocol (see IFM Protocol Section 9.5).
Project Proponents must disclose all pre-existing forest management plans, and any traditional stewardship plans, for any enrolled Site(s).
[/R-TN0Y-0]Pre-existing plans must specify likely or planned harvest(s), or traditional forest stewardship activity, during the Crediting Period.
[/G-PA1C-0]Conditional Requirement — Indigenous landowners practising traditional stewardship
Where principles of traditional land use are not documented in a formal plan, Project Proponents may satisfy the disclosure requirement through oral histories, cultural practices documentation, or traditional ecological knowledge (TEK) assessments that evidence ongoing forest engagement and resource-use patterns informed by traditional practices.
[/R-E9WK-0]Given the inherent economic nature of forest management activities, the impacts of The Project extend beyond landowner(s) to local economies. Giving these stakeholders early notice of planned changes in timber harvest enables market adaptation and prevents job losses in any local timber-based economy.
In addition to stakeholder engagement requirements specified in the IFM Protocol (see IFM Protocol Section 6.6.1) the Project Proponent must notify local authorities and loggers, mills, or other parties with existing formal or informal offtake agreements of the contracted change in harvest volume and/or schedule of timber upon enrollment into The Project.
[/R-1YR8-0]Logging operations often provide direct financial benefits or material goods to local communities (for example, employment income, infrastructure, or direct payments). Where those direct benefits cease because of project activities, Project Proponents must replace them through revenue sharing with the affected communities.
[/R-NKKX-0]For the purposes of this Module, a community beneficiary is a local community, group, or individual that received direct financial benefits or material goods from the timber operations now ceased by the Project. While there may be other more indirect benefits for communities not captured here, these should be addressed through the broader stakeholder engagement and social safeguards within the IFM Protocol.
Validation requirements
Revenue-sharing requirements
In addition to the requirements set out in the IFM Protocol (see IFM Protocol Section 6.6.2), Project Proponents must disburse to community beneficiaries revenues generated from CreditsCertificates issued to The Project that match or exceed the historical direct financial benefits or material goods.
Eligible forms of revenue sharing include:
Project Proponents must set out, in the PDD, the system for disbursement of Credit-generated revenue to community beneficiaries, including a mechanism for raising and resolving grievances relating to revenue sharing, and for tracking responses and resolutions.
[/G-4XG0-0]Project Proponents must provide an anticipated timeline of revenue-sharing disbursement over the duration of each contract.
[/G-RJBN-0]Revenue-sharing percentages should be made public, including the percent of revenue or CreditsCertificates allocated to each party (e.g., Project Proponent, community beneficiaries, insurance provider(s), and any other parties documented in the PDD).
Verification requirements
At each Verification, Project Proponents must provide evidence of progress against the revenue-sharing plan, including proof of revenue disbursement, and must report any grievances raised by community beneficiaries together with the response and resolution.
[/G-C77A-0]Conditional Requirement — Shortfall in cumulative revenue disbursement
If at any Verification the cumulative revenue disbursement has fallen more than 20% below the original projected level for that timepoint, Project Proponents must submit an updated revenue-disbursement plan and timeline demonstrating how The Project will meet the revenue-sharing requirement of this Module. The new plan is used for benchmarking at future Verifications.
[/R-WXB7-0]In addition to the eligibility and applicability requirements set out in Section 4, Project Proponents must meet the following requirements to ensure all claimed environmental impacts demonstrate the four pillars of additionality described in the relevant section of the Isometric Standard.
To ensure additionality, Project Proponents must demonstrate a pre-existing intent to harvest trees within the Project Boundary and a demonstrable history of commercial harvesting and/or traditional forest stewardship within each enrolled Site.
Project Proponents must evidence this with both of the following:
[/R-GJ6W-0]Project Proponents must complete the common practice analysis set out in Section 7.8 of the IFM Protocol as follows:
The carbon poolpools within the scope of this Module isare aboveground woody biomass, asand thisharvested wood products (HWP). Aboveground woody biomass is the main additional carbon pool affected by converting logged areas to protected areas, and is the only pool included in CO2eStored,RP. HWP are included in the counterfactual scenario, because commercial harvest occurs in the baseline and part of the harvested carbon would remain stored in wood products and in harvest and milling residues. HWP are accounted for through the counterfactual harvested wood storage factor, fHWP (Section 9.3.4.1), applied in Equations 9 and 18. No HWP storage is credited in the project scenario. Soil carbon is also conservatively excluded from CO2eStored,RP. Belowground biomass is also excluded as a conservative measure since evidence indicates that the removal of carbon through the growth of new belowground biomass does not exceed the degradation of pre-logged belowground biomass21,22. For the remainder of the Module, the use of AGB refers to only the living aboveground woody biomass, unless otherwise noted.
This Module requires Projects to account for leakage through the Global Timber Model (GTM), which captures both direct landowner behavioral responses (activity-shifting) and broader market-mediated effects (market leakage) within a unified economic modeling approach. This integration reflects the reality that in improved forest management, activity-shifting behaviors are often driven by the same market signals and economic incentives that drive broader market leakage in response to timber supply restrictions. In this Module, leakage is calculated for distinct species groups for each regional wood basket, which vary by geographic location and forest composition.
Recent scientific literature has highlighted significant challenges in accurately quantifying leakage from forest carbon projects. Studies by Badgley et al. (2021)23, Haya et al. (2023)24, and others have found systematic over-crediting in forest carbon offset programs, largely due to inadequate accounting for leakage impacts25. This research indicates that traditional approaches to leakage assessment for forest carbon offset programs often underestimate both the magnitude and geographic scope of displacement effects.
The complexity of global timber markets means that reduced harvest in one location can trigger responses across multiple regions and through various economic pathways. Market-mediated leakage can occur through price signals that incentivize increased harvesting in distant locations, while activity-shifting often occurs through landowner responses that extend to other land owned by the Project Proponent or enrolled landowners, but not included in The Project.
This methodology adopts a modeling approach with a minimum 10% leakage deduction, using the Global Timber Model (GTM) to prevent well-documented over-crediting that has resulted from other improved forest management methodologies.
The Project Proponent or previous landowner(s) who own or manage forested land outside of the enrolled Site(s) of The Project are prohibited from altering forest management on these lands outside of regular harvests and stand improvement activities such as pre-commercial thinnings. The Project Proponent must provide an attestation that they will not alter forest management on this land outside of the enrolled Site(s) as a result of project activities.
[/R-472H-0]Projects under this Module are subject to a minimum leakage deduction of 10% of [math: CO_2e_CO\_2e\_{Stored,RP}], regardless of the computed leakage rate. Subject to this floor, Isometric calculates the applicable leakage deduction using the Global Timber Model (GTM) per the procedure and equations below.
The Global Timber Model (GTM) was conceptualized by Sohngen et al. (1999)26, and it seeks to re-balance supply and demand in response to market shocks over decadal time periods for forest-type regions.
The GTM has been adopted for carbon projects through an update led by the University of Maine, in collaboration with The Nature Conservancy and the Global Forest Lab at The Ohio State University, as discussed in Daigneault et al. (2025)27. This updated GTM estimates how forest carbon projects in aggregate change trade balances regionally and globally, as a result of both direct and indirect leakage.
Isometric will quantify the leakage deduction for each Reporting Period for Projects based on global runs of leakage rates (Equation 1) for the forest-type using the Global Timber Model (GTM), annualized and weighted by The Project’s basal area. As changes to timber harvest through project activities directly and indirectly impact the balance of supply and demand for decades, and the GTM initiates this predicted response within the same decadal time period as the start of the Crediting Period, the leakage deduction schedule for the percent deduction of a Reporting Period, Lproject,RP, will be set at project initiation, and updated as needed by Isometric with the inclusion of any new site(s).
Further information on how Isometric implements the GTM and determines leakage is set forth in Appendix D, which contains additional information on the technical requirements of model implementation and the data sources used for modeling.
The average leakage rate, [math: LR], for each forest type-region (see Appendix D3) in 10-year time periods is calculated as:
[math: LR_{f,r,t} = \rho \left[ \frac{(PCS_{Project,f,r,t} - PCS_{Counterfactual,f,r,t}) - (GCS_{Project,f,r,t} - GCS_{Counterfactual,f,r,t})}{(PCS_{Project,f,r,t} - PCS_{Counterfactual,f,r,t})} \right]]
(Equation 1)
Where:
The Project’s leakage for each Reporting Period, CO2eLeakage,RP is then calculated using the following equation:
[math: L_{Project,t} = \frac{\sum B_{f,r,t} \times LR_{f,r,t}}{B_{Project,t}}]
(Equation 2)
Where:
And, [math: B_{Project,t}] must equal [math: B_{f,r,t}]
As the GTM outputs leakage estimates on decadal timesteps, Isometric will then annualize the project leakage, applying a linear interpolation between decadal estimates to derive the leakage deduction for each year within a decade:
[math: L_{Project,RP} = L_{Project,0} + \frac{t}{10} \left( L_{10} - L_0 \right)]
(Equation 3)
Where:
The final leakage deduction for each Reporting Period, CO2eLeakage,RP can then be calculated as a percentage of the sequestered carbon in a Reporting Period, CO2eStored,RP (see Section 9.1).
[math: CO_2e_{Leakage,RP} = L_{Project,RP} \times CO_2e_{Stored,RP}]
(Equation 4)
If the leakage rate, [math: L_{Project,RP}], is < 10%, the minimum annual leakage deduction of 10% will be applied by Isometric. When positive leakage is predicted by a negative leakage rate ([math: L_{Project,RP}] < 0%), it will be subject to the minimum annual leakage deduction of 10%. Positive leakage indicates a model which predicts that restricting supply in the region could increase timber prices, and incentivize more considered forest management or land to be converted to forest.
Project Proponents may elect to apply an alternative leakage deduction in place of the GTM-derived value, provided the alternative method is more conservative than the GTM output and meets the supply-chain assessment, data, and activity-shifting conditions set out below. The "more conservative than GTM" test is applied separately for each Reporting Period, using the current GTM output for that Reporting Period.
[/R-QVY6-0]Validation requirements
At Validation, Project Proponents electing the alternative deduction must develop and report in the PDD, for approval by Isometric and the VVB, an alternative supply-chain leakage assessment meeting all of the conditions in Section 8.3.1 (conservative leakage assumptions and data requirements).
[/G-KGYM-0]Reporting Period requirements
For each Reporting Period in which the alternative deduction is applied:
Re-submission requirements
The supply-chain assessment must be updated and resubmitted at each Verification. Updated assessments must incorporate any material changes to substitute supply markets, trade flows, or carbon-intensity data that have occurred since the prior assessment. Where region-specific data for substitute species become available that were not available at the prior assessment, the new data must be incorporated.
Isometric reserves the right to require the Project Proponent to revert to the GTM-derived leakage deduction if the supply-chain assessment is found to rely on incomplete, outdated, or insufficiently conservative data.
Where a Project Proponent elects to apply an alternative leakage deduction, the assessment must meet all of the following requirements.
Project Proponents must develop and report in the PDD, for approval by Isometric and the VVB, an alternative approach assessment that demonstrates the following:
[/G-75T9-0]The Project Proponent must provide the following for each Reporting Period in which the alternative deduction is applied:
Under this Module, the difference in storage between the project scenario and the counterfactual scenario are assessed cumulatively over the course of The Project. For a given Reporting Period, the incremental change is assessed as the difference between the total additional carbon storage at the end of the current Reporting Period and the same value at the end of the prior Reporting Period. As such, change in the net difference between the project and counterfactual storage over a Reporting Period is calculated as a net storage term (CO2enet, storage,RP):
[math: CO_2e_{net,storage,RP} = (CO_2e_{stored,RPtotal} - CO_2e_{counterfactual,total})_{t=RP}=- (CO_2e_{stored,total} - CO_2e_{counterfactual,total})- CO_2e__{net,storage,t=RP-1}]
(Equation 5)
Where:
The CO_2e_{net,storage,RP-1}]prior isperiod values are those that were calculated at the net storage term for the prior Reporting Periodtime, innot tonnesupdated ofestimates CO2e;with Ifnew thisdata. is the first Reporting Period this term is set to 0
This net storage for the Reporting Period can then be used for the difference between [math: CO_2e_{stored,RP}] and [math: CO_2e_{counterfactual,RP}] for the calculation of net removals using Equation 1 in the IFM Protocol.
Under this Module, the primary storage pool is aboveground woody biomass. In formerly logged areas, evidence indicates that the removal of carbon through the growth of new belowground biomass (BGB) does not exceed carbon loss from the degradation of pre-logged belowground biomass28,29. This indicates that there is limited net removal of carbon through belowground biomass and, as a conservative measure, Project Proponents must set CO2eBGB to 0.
With this, the stored carbon in the project area at time t can be described by the following equation:
[math: CO_2e_{stored}(t)=CO_2e_{AGB}(t)]
(Equation 6)
Where:
The total carbon stored in The Project up to the end of the current Reporting Period can be calculated as:
[math: CO_2e_{stored,total} = CO_2e_{stored,t=RP} - CO_2e_{stored,t=0}]
(Equation 7)
Where:
Project Proponents must quantify the total above-ground biomass, MAGB, in the project area through one of the Capture & Conversion Modules listed in the IFM Protocol (see IFM Protocol Section 9.3.3).
[/R-BGSV-0]Isometric performs the calculation of CO2ecounterfactual,RP via the dynamic baseline approach described in this section. Project Proponents are not responsible for carrying out the steps Isometric performs. Project Proponents may, based on expert knowledge of their system, suggest areas that could serve as suitable control pixels or features for matching; however, the final determination of control pixels is made by Isometric in accordance with the procedure and criteria below.
[/R-Z5NG-0]Where Project Proponents do have obligations in this section (e.g., providing evidence for [math: f_HWPf\_HWP] parameters at Validation — see Section 9.3.4.1), those obligations are stated explicitly using "Project Proponents must …" language.
At Validation, the control plot zone must meet the following eligibility criteria:
Where possible, other features should also be matched between the control plot zone and project area to the best extent possible following the matching procedure in Section 9.3.3. Examples, and potential data sources, are presented in Table 2.
Table 2. Potential variables and data sources for informing the matching procedure between project and control areas.
Category | Variable | Potential Datasets |
Forest Structure | Carbon Proxy | LiDAR-derived biomass estimates; Forest inventory carbon models; Remote sensing carbon proxies (see Section 9.3.2) |
Stem Density | LiDAR point cloud analysis; Forest inventory plot data; Airborne laser scanning metrics | |
Species composition | Forest type classification maps; Vegetation surveys; Hyperspectral imagery analysis | |
Years since last disturbance/harvest | Forest management records; Disturbance history databases; Landsat time series analysis | |
Historical harvest cycles | Forest management records; Disturbance history databases; Landsat time series analysis | |
Environmental | Elevation (≤30m resolution) | SRTM 30m DEM; ASTER Global DEM; National elevation datasets |
Slope (≤30m resolution) | DEM-derived slope calculations; USGS National Elevation Dataset; Terrain analysis products | |
Bioclimatic variables (e.g., temperature, precipitation) | WorldClim data; Regional climate records | |
Site Productivity | USGS SSURGO soil classification; Forest site index databases; Soil productivity indices | |
Socioeconomic | Land value estimates | Nolte, 202030; Property tax assessments; Real estate valuation models |
Distance to timber mills | Forest industry facility databases; Mill location registries; Economic facility datasets | |
Distance from roads and/or navigable waterways | OpenStreetMap road networks; National transportation databases; Road density maps | |
Distance from urban development | Urban boundary datasets; Land use/land cover maps; Census urbanized area files | |
Geographic distance | Coordinate-based distance calculations; Spatial proximity analysis; GIS distance tools | |
Parcel size | Cadastral boundary datasets; Property parcel databases; Land registry records | |
State/Province Boundaries | World Administrative Boundaries |
Initially, the zone for eligible control plots should be limited to the same state or province, or a 100 km band around the project area — whichever is smaller. However, if suitable matches (see Section 9.3.3) are not found in this zone, additional step-outs in 10 km increments may occur to find appropriate control plots, assuming they meet the criteria above. The final area determined for suitable control plots is hereafter referred to as the Donor Zone.
If after, including geographic expansion of the boundary up, the Donor Zone is less than ten times the size of the project area, the donor pool may be further expanded by using the Time for Space Substitution procedure described in Section 9.3.1.1.
Conditional applicability. Isometric applies Time for Space Substitution (TFSS) only where, after masking the Donor Zone for required variables and applying geographic step-outs, the eligible Donor Zone is less than five times the project area.
In some scenarios, constraining the zone for eligible control pixels based on the criteria above may severely limit the size of the Donor Zone. Although further control pixels can be selected by expanding the potential Donor Zone area in 10-kilometer increments, doing so may only marginally increase the area of the Donor Zone or improve the performance benchmark accuracy.
Environmental criteria such as bioclimatic variables, productivity, and biogeography used for control pixel matching tend to exhibit high variation — especially in areas of high topographic relief. Therefore, control pixels selected even short distances from the project area can have fundamentally different ecological conditions that can lead to biased control pixel selection and forest carbon stocks and/or proxies. Land use history can similarly constrain the Donor Zone. To ensure accurate matching, the Donor Zone should account for legacy effects—such as prior management regimes, levels of degradation, and priority effects—that influence long-term carbon storage capacity. However, controlling for land use history does further limit eligible Donor Zone pixels due to the asynchronous timing of land-use changes across the landscape. In any given year, areas with similar land use may vary in the time elapsed since active management (e.g., harvesting, cultivation, grazing, or disturbance), potentially biasing control pixel selection and forest carbon stocks and/or proxies.
One consequence of a small Donor Zone is small control pixel sample sizes, which can reduce performance benchmark accuracy through sampling bias. If the eligible Donor Zone after masking for the initial set of variables (see Section 9.3.1) is less than five times the size of the project area, Isometric may temporally expand the pool of potential control pixels using a time-for-space substitution (TFSS) sampling strategy. TFSS relaxes the requirement to match the Donor Zone and project area from identical calendar years, thereby expanding the n-dimensional area available for valid control pixel selection. Instead of aligning control pixel and project forest carbon stocks and/or proxies by the same calendar year, TFSS compares changes in forest carbon stocks and/or proxies relative to the time elapsed since pre-project conditions, enabling more robust estimates of additionality.
In this approach, historical data for control pixels can be matched to current data for The Project. The same criteria as listed above must apply across the time points (i.e., current regulations which apply to The Project must have also been applicable at the historical time point for the control pixel). If TFSS is required based on the initial Donor Zone size, Isometric will include the justification for the approach as well as the specific methodological approach and data included in the TFSS in its documentation of the baseline procedure.
When the TFSS is used, the temporal range considered for eligible control pixels will be expanded in 5-year increments, up to 15 years maximum. In addition to the features and criteria above, eligibility for the use of time substituted control pixels also includes:
When temporal substitution is used for control pixels, their eligibility will be re-evaluated at each Reporting Period according to the guidance set out in Section 9.3.4.
Once the boundaries of the Donor Zone are determined, Isometric will generate high-resolution (≤30 m pixels) maps representing forest carbon stocks or a suitable proxy for forest carbon stocks. These layers must cover the entire project area and Donor Zone at the same resolution for at least five historical time points relative to the start of The Project. Each historical time point must be separated by at least 1 year.
Isometric will select a suitable proxy that meets the following criteria:
Project and control plot pixels will be matched by Isometric at Validation, and these matches will be retained and tracked over the Crediting Period. In this procedure a representative random sample of project pixels are matched to control plot pixels based on a mix of current and historical time series of environmental, socioeconomic, management, and forest structure data — including the selected forest carbon proxy, Cproxy, of each pixel — using k-nearest neighbors without replacement, or an alternative justified algorithm.
This matching will use, at a minimum, five historical time points of Cproxy capturing at least the five years prior to project initiation. Isometric will use, where possible and relevant, additional datasets from Table 2 for matching. Other than the historical time series of Cproxy, all dynamic remotely sensed variables must be captured within the past 18 months. Each selected project pixel must be matched to a minimum of 5 different control pixels, and the mean of each dataset over the group of control pixels is used — with the mean forest carbon proxy over the group of control pixels derived from the map product created using the procedure described in Section 9.3.2.
To evaluate the carbon stored in the counterfactual scenario, the change in the stocking index in the project pixels is compared to the change in the control pixels. Specifically, linear regressions are fit through both the project and control pixels proxy values, and the relative ratio is then used to calculate the counterfactual storage:
[math: CO_2e_{Counterfactual,Total} = CO_2e_{Stored,total} \left( \frac{Control_{proxy,slope}}{Project_{proxy,slope}} \right)]
(Equation 8)
Where:
To meet the additionality condition, the change in proxy value in the project area represented by the slope of the project pixels, must be statistically greater ([math: p] < 0.05, inclusive of uncertainty) than that of the matched control pixels.
The counterfactual is not quantified as a separate carbon stock. Equations 8 and 9 apply a ratio of proxy values to The Project's measured CO2eStored. The proxy values for project and control pixels are taken from the same map product (Section 9.3.2), with the same data sources, spatial resolution, time points and processing, so the same quantification of MAGB underlies both CO2eStored,total and CO2eCounterfactual,Total.
Counterfactual floor at zero. Where the slope of the control pixels' proxy change is negative such that Equation 8 would yield a negative counterfactual, Isometric sets [math: CO_2e_{counterfactual}] to 0 for that Reporting Period. This floor ensures that carbon accounting is limited to removals above the harvest counterfactual.
At each Verification, the control pixels are reviewed to determine continued eligibility around similar regulatory regimes within control plots as outlined in Section 9.3.1. In the event that control pixel matches are no longer suitable, replacements will be selected for the impacted project pixels. For example, a change in regulations around IFM projects which leads to variance in the legality of such projects between control and project pixels would lead to rematching of control and project pixels.
The counterfactual will be calculated using Equation 8 for each Reporting Period, unless:
If either of the above conditions is met in a given Reporting Period, the counterfactual is then calculated as the temporal mean for that Reporting Period and all remaining Reporting Periods in the Crediting Period:
[math: CO_2e_{counterfactual,total} = CO_2e_{stored,totalt=RP} \left( \frac{Control_{proxy,mean}}{Project_{proxy,RP}} \right) x \, f_{HWP} - CO_2e_{stored,t=0}]
(Equation 9)
Where:
The counterfactual harvested wood storage factor reflects the relative ratio of the long-term mean of harvested wood carbon relative to the long-term mean of standing carbon in counterfactual. This term is calculated based on information about historical harvesting activities and wood products within the project area:
[math: f_{HWP} = 1 + \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{n} \frac{f_i}{\lambda_i}}{T(\gamma - \beta)}]
(Equation 10)
Where:
Project Proponents must provide their assessment and corresponding evidence for the calculation of fHWP at Validation. Further details on the calculation and required evidence for these terms are provided in Section 9.3.4.1 and the full derivation is in Appendix E.
[/R-JTH5-0]The calculation of fHWP must be included in the uncertainty assessment for the calculation of removals. As such, uncertainty information for the parameters must be reported, or evidence that the value is a conservative estimate provided.
[/G-R1K6-0]The fraction of biomass in different pools post-harvest ([math: f_i]) is assessed by considering how the initial pre-harvest standing AGB volume gets divided into harvest residues, mill residues, and wood products.
First, a biomass expansion factor (BEF) is used to determine how the standing pre-harvest total AGB volume (K) is partitioned into between merchantable volume of biomass (MV) which goes to the mill and harvest residues (RH):
[math: K = MV + R_H = \frac{1}{BEF}K + (1 - \frac{1}{BEF})K]
(Equation 11)
Where available, species-specific biomass expansion factors should be used. If none is available, then default IPCC values for the region and system may be used33.
The merchantable volume is then further partitioned as part of the milling process into the commercial volume (CV) of wood products and waste residues produced in the milling process. This partitioning is described by the efficiency of the processing of harvested wood products (WHWP). The efficiency of the processing of harvested wood products is well documented. Project Proponents must assign WHWP to each harvested wood product according to sawmill location using the values in Table 3, derived from Winjum et al. 199834.
[/G-BPEV-0]Table 3. WHWP values by country classification
Sawmill location | WHWP |
|---|---|
Developed country | 0.19 |
Developing country | 0.24 |
[math: MV = CV +R_HR_M = (1-W_{HWP})MV + W_{HWP}MV]
(Equation 12)
Note that the above expression represents a single type of wood product and associated wastes, but the merchantable volume may be partitioned into multiple milling processes and wood products as applicable.
The above equations can then be combined and normalized by [math: K] to express the fractional pools:
[math: 1 = f_{RH} + f_{RM} + f_{CV} = (1 - \frac{1}{BEF}) + \frac{W_{HWP}}{BEF} + \frac{1- W_{HWP}}{BEF}]
(Equation 13)
Where:
The decay rate ([math: \lambda_i]) is derived from the half-life of the pool:
[math: \lambda_i= \frac{ln(2)}{t_{1/2,i}}]
(Equation 14)
Where:
The half-life values applied for harvested wood products must be specific to the product type, end use, and regional practices associated with The Project and harvested wood product. Residue pools (e.g., harvest residues and milling residues) will be subject to an assessment of decay kinetics to account for biogenic carbon that would remain durably stored in the counterfactual. Half-life values must be selected from independently published sources, in the following order of preference:
[/G-ZBAG-0]The harvest cycle length ([math: T]) should be derived from historical harvest data from the site. Evidence could include records from the harvesting operations or remote sensing data.
The harvest intensity ([math: \gamma]) describes how much of the standing biomass in the forest is subject to harvest during harvesting:
[math: \gamma = \frac{B}{K}]
(Equation 15)
Where:
In scenarios of clear-cutting, [math: \gamma] is equal to its minimum value of one. Where there is selection harvesting, [math: \gamma] is greater than one. This should be estimated based on historical practice within the project site and can be evidenced by documentation from the harvesting operations or remote sensing.
Conditional Requirement — γ evidence unavailable. Where suitable evidence for γ is not available, Project Proponents must assume clear-cutting (γ = 1) as a conservative default.
[/G-K065-0]The normalized regrowth symmetry ([math: \beta]) describes non-linearity in the regrowth dynamics of the standing forest post-harvest (harvest occurs at t=0):
[math: \beta = 1 - \frac{1}{T}\int_{0}^{T} \frac{B(t) - B_{min}}{K} \, dt]
(Equation 16)
Where:
The integral term in this equation is equivalent to the temporal mean value of standing biomass over the course of a harvest cycle normalized to the harvest volume. Values of [math: \beta] range from 0 to 1. A value of 0.5 represents perfectly linear regrowth in the forest. Values less than 0.5 indicate more rapid regrowth rates in early years that then decrease in latter years. Values greater than 0.5 indicate slower growth in initial years with acceleration of the growth rate in latter years.
The value of [math: \beta] should be estimated from growth models which are ecologically suitable for the represented species or from historical remote sensing data of regrowth within the project area.
Isometric will account for uncertainty in the dynamic baseline to ensure a conservative estimate of CO2ecounterfactual,Total in Equation 5. This will include an evaluation of at least the following sources of uncertainty:
Situations may arise where The Project operates within an ecologically unique ecosystem, employs uncommon management techniques, or is located in a region where comparable concession-level spatial data are unavailable — thereby limiting the donor pool of spatial or temporal matches for dynamic baselining.
Under such conditions, Projects may derive the counterfactual scenario using a modeled dynamic baseline, constructed from The Project’s own historical harvesting record, supply-side operational capacity, and demand-side market conditions — subject to the constraints and dynamic evaluation requirements specified below. The modeled baseline must be conservative, evidence-based, and subject to upward-only (decreased harvest, increased counterfactual biomass) adjustments in harvest activity over time.
[/R-6FCT-0]Conditional applicability. Project Proponents may apply the modeled dynamic baseline described in this subsection only where Isometric has determined, at Validation, that the eligible Donor Zone after masking for required variables and applying Time for Space Substitution is still less than five times the project area.
Isometric documents the limited-donor-zone determination in the Validation Report.
Lock-in. Once a Project applies the modeled dynamic baseline, The Project must continue to use the modeled approach for the remainder of the Crediting Period, unless Isometric determines that a sufficient donor pool has become available. In that case, The Project transitions to the standard dynamic baseline on a forward-moving basis.
[/G-T9XF-0]Project Proponents must derive modeled baseline harvest scenarios from the following inputs, which will be approved for use at the first Verification:
[/G-DYS4-0]The modeled baseline harvest area must be set to the minimum of the long-term average of the historical harvest rate, demonstrated supply-side capacity, demonstrated demand-side market absorption, and the regulatory allowable harvest. This ensures the baseline is conservative across all relevant dimensions and reflects factor(s) which most greatly constrain the harvest rate.
[/G-CX86-0]The model must predict the standing aboveground counterfactual biomass as a function of time (CO2ecounterfactual,AGB). This should be done at a minimum of annual resolution.
[/G-QGTQ-0]The modeled output must then be used in the equivalent calculations to Equations 8 and 119 to yield the counterfactual deduction. From project initiation up until any harvest is predicted by the model, the counterfactual will be calculated as:
[math: CO_2e_{Counterfactual,Total} = CO_2e_{Counterfactual,AGB,t=RP} - CO_2e_{Counterfactual,AGB,t=0}]
(Equation 17)
Where:
Once any harvest occurs within the counterfactual, the counterfactual is calculated as:
[math: CO_2e_{Counterfactual,Total} = f_{HWP} \frac{\int_{0}^{RP} CO_2e_{Counterfactual,AGB}(t) \, dt}{RP} - CO_2e_{counterfactual, AGB, t=0}]
(Equation 18)
Where:
Note that this equation is equivalent to Equation 9, and [math: f_{HWP}] should be calculated following the parameters and procedure in Section 9.3.4.1.
At each Reporting Period, the modeled baseline assumptions must be tested against observed conditions using the Modeled Baseline Evaluation Framework (Table 4). When any category undergoes a material change in the conditions which underpin the modeled baseline, Project Proponents must adjust the baseline harvest area and associated carbon stock projections accordingly.
[/R-DS44-0]Where this evaluation identifies a material change, The Project must:
Adjustments are applied on a forward-moving basis from the start of the Reporting Period in which the change is identified. Adjustments cannot be applied retroactively to previously verified Reporting Periods. All adjustments are subject to approval by Isometric and the VVB.
[/G-649B-0]Table 4. Modeled Baseline Evaluation Framework
Category | Test | Required Evidence | Recourse (if test fails) |
Regulatory & Concession Status | Are the legal and regulatory conditions under which the concession operates unchanged such that the baseline harvest is still legally permissible? This includes concession license terms, allowable annual cut quotas, harvest moratoria, land tenure changes, and environmental regulations. | Review of current concession license, relevant legislation, and regulatory instruments. Documentation of any new restrictions, quota reductions, or moratoria affecting the project area. | Reduce the baseline harvest area to reflect the new legally allowable maximum. If logging is fully prohibited, the baseline harvest area is set to zero and no further Recalculate counterfactual carbon stocks for the current and all subsequent Reporting Periods. |
Accessibility & Operability | Has there been a material change in broader regional accessibility to the concession that is independent of project activities and that would have prevented the baseline harvest from continuing to occur? | Assessment following guidance set forth in Section 4.1.2. Documentation of regional accessibility infrastructure under counterfactual conditions, including: status of public road and waterway networks serving the concession; condition of bridges, culverts, and ferry crossings on the access route; status of right-of-way easements and access permissions across third-party land; and any natural disaster, terrain change, or regulatory restriction affecting access. Identification of specific areas with reduced or eliminated access, with estimated area (ha) affected. Project-attributable infrastructure deterioration — including disuse, decommissioning, or non-maintenance of logging roads, skid trails, or landings within the project area following cessation of logging —should not induce a reduction in baseline harvest area. Such deterioration is presumed and is consistent with the objective of forest protection. | Where exogenous accessibility has materially declined such that the baseline harvest could not have been executed even by an alternative operator, reduce the baseline harvest area in proportion to the area no longer accessible. Recalculate counterfactual carbon stocks for the current and all subsequent Reporting Periods. Project-attributable infrastructure deterioration does not constitute a failed test. |
Supply-Side Operational Capacity | Has there been a material change in the regional capacity to harvest the concession that is independent of project activities? | Documentation of regional harvesting capability under counterfactual conditions, including: availability of harvesting contractors and equipment-rental markets within the relevant wood basket; status of skilled workforce in the region; and condition of extraction infrastructure (roads, landings, river access, bridges) serving the concession. Capacity reductions attributable to project activities — including the proponent's own divestment of equipment, reassignment of workforce, or non-renewal of contractor relationships — are presumed and should not trigger a reduction in baseline harvest area. | Where exogenous regional capacity has materially declined such that the baseline harvest could not have been executed even by a hypothetical alternative operator, Projects must: Reduce the baseline harvest area to reflect the current demonstrated operational capacity; and Recalculate counterfactual carbon stocks for the current and all subsequent Reporting Periods. Reductions in capacity attributable to project activities do not constitute a failed test. |
Demand-Side Market Conditions | Could regional and accessible markets absorb the timber output assumed in the baseline? This includes closures of mills, ports, or processing facilities; reductions in buyer purchasing volumes; and shifts in market demand for the relevant timber products. Demand is evaluated over a rolling period of at least one-half of the rotation length, with a minimum of 10 years. Consistent reductions in regional demand of more than 5% annually over this period constitute a material change. | Regional timber trade data, buyer records, or national export statistics for the relevant product class. Where The Project uses the Global Timber Model (Section 8.2), updated GTM outputs for the relevant product and region may be used. The assessment of regional demand reductions, presented as changes in purchases for relevant product classes, should control for historical levels of purchases from the enrolled Project in evaluating regional trends. | Reduce the baseline harvest area to reflect the current demonstrated market absorption capacity. Recalculate counterfactual carbon stocks for the current and all subsequent Reporting Periods. |
Carbon Recovery Curve Assumptions | Do the carbon recovery curve parameters (regrowth rate, maximum carbon stock, regrowth symmetry) remain valid based on the best available evidence? This includes new field data, updated allometric equations, or revised growth models for the project ecosystem. | Review of any new field measurements, published literature, or growth model updates applicable to the project area’s species and ecosystem. Where new evidence shows the counterfactual recovery curve under-estimated counterfactual carbon accumulation, the curve must be revised toward faster recovery. | Revise the carbon recovery curve to reflect the most conservative interpretation of available evidence. Recalculate counterfactual carbon stocks for the current and all subsequent Reporting Periods using the revised curve. |
Each Monitoring Report must include a detailed summary of the modeled baseline evaluation applied for the Reporting Period, covering all categories in Table 4 and their results. Any baseline parameters identified as requiring adjustment and the reasoning for such a determination must be clearly reported. All adjustments must be fully described, including their quantitative impact on the counterfactual carbon stock projections and the volume of CreditsCertificates requested for the current Reporting Period.
The following must be reported at each Reporting Period:
[/G-SS50-0]Verification of the modeled baseline evaluation must assess:
[/G-12WA-0]Where the verifier identifies evidence of a material change in baseline conditions that The Project has not accounted for, the verifier must require The Project to apply the appropriate adjustment before CreditsCertificates may be issued for the Reporting Period.
Uncertainty in the counterfactual must be characterized and propagated following to obtain a conservative estimate of Ccounterfactual. This includes assessment of all relevant sources of uncertainty described in Section 9.3.5. Additionally, Projects using this approach must characterize and account for uncertainty in all the parameters informing the model.
[/R-YMX1-0]CO2eemissions,RP is the total GHG emissions associated with a given Reporting Period, RP.
Equations and emissions calculation requirements for CO2eemissions,RP are set out in the relevant Protocol and are not repeated in this Module.
As part of CO2eemissions,RP, CO2eLeakage,RP must be quantified for the Reporting Period. CO2eLeakage,RP is quantified following the approach described in Section 8.2, and in accordance with the IFM Protocol Section 9.5.
Any models used under this Protocol which contribute to the quantification of net CDR must be well-validated and relevant for the purpose that they were used for. Proof of model suitability can be achieved through either:
[/R-J9RP-0]The storage reservoir or the CO2 removed through the IFM interventions in this Module is live aboveground woody biomass. The durability of a CDR process refers to the length of time for which CO2 is removed from the Earth’s atmosphere and cannot contribute to further climate change. This Section details the durability and reversal monitoring requirements for storage of removed atmospheric CO2 as aboveground woody biomass under this Module.
The durability of a CreditCertificate is equal to the length of the Ongoing Monitoring Period as outlined in Section 5.4. The minimum duration of the Ongoing Monitoring Period, and therefore minimum durability of CreditsCertificates issued under this Module, is 40 years.
The Ongoing Monitoring Period is constrained by the following:
[/G-Y9SJ-0]For the duration of the Ongoing Monitoring Period, Isometric will conduct monitoring for Reversals in the project area following the procedures described in IFM Protocol Section 10.5. Project Proponents will be responsible for reporting and quantification in response to any detected Reversals for the duration of the Ongoing Monitoring Period.
We would like to thank the participants of the private and public consultations for this Module who provided extensive feedback.
The Risk Assessment is used to assess the overall delivery and storage risk associated with improved forest management through transition to protected status and may inform the Buffer Pool contribution during CreditCertificate delivery (see IFM Protocol Section 10.4). The assessment must first be filled in by the Project Proponent and must be validated by a VVB. During project Validation, discrepancies between the Project Proponent’s self reported score and VVB may result in monitoring or risk mitigation activities, or project ineligibility. Eligible projects must have an initial risk score ≤ 16 and initial risk category scores at or below the following thresholds:
All risk categories have a minimum score of 0, regardless of the outcome of the Risk Assessment.
If Project Proponents choose to forgo a flat 20% Buffer Pool contribution, this Risk Assessment will inform Buffer Pool contributions for The Project according to the process outlined in Appendix C for each Reporting Period and in accordance with the requirements in the IFM Protocol (see Section 10.4.1).
[/G-5KGW-0]Table A1. Risk Assessment for Improved Forest Management projects involving transition to protected status of previously logged lands, with the score to be filled out for each question.
Risk Category | Risk Indicator | Evidence | Scoring Guidelines | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Project Proponent Capacity Risk | Does the Project Proponent maintain staff with domain expertise relevant for forest carbon projects? (e.g., forest ecology, forest measurement, carbon accounting) | Project's team structure | If no, describe how gaps in relevant expertise will be filled, +1. | |
Does the Project Proponent maintain a staff presence in the local vicinity (within one day of travel) of the project site? | Project's team structure | If no, +2. | ||
Was the Project Proponent established more than 12 months ago? | Project Proponent declaration | If no, +1. | ||
Does the Project Proponent have prior experience in improved forest management, carbon projects or planting? | Review of Project Proponent provided evidence and independent research | If yes, -1. | ||
Has the Project Proponent abandoned or failed previous projects? | Review of projects on other registries | If yes, +3. | ||
What proportion of the project area requires active enforcement against external threats (e.g., illegal logging, agricultural encroachment, unauthorized grazing) to protect carbon stocks? | Peer-reviewed publications, local or national government databases, NGO reports and assessments, site security assessment, satellite data, data on enforcement from other reforestation projects in the same region, local or national reports on environmental crimes or violations | If > 50% of project area, +2. If 25 to 50% of project area, +1. If no active enforcement required, -1. | ||
Has the Project obtained non-delivery risk insurance | Project Proponent declaration | If yes, -1. | ||
Financial Viability Risk | Has The Project secured funding to cover all activities required before carbon revenue accrues? | Project financial plan | If > 90%, -2. If > 80%, -1. If < 50%, +1. If < 30%, +2. If < 10%, fail. | |
What is the projected time to reach financial breakeven? | Project financial plan | If > 20 years, fail. If 15 to 20 years, +3. If 10 to 15 years, +2. If 5 to 10 years, +1. | ||
Is the budget reasonable given the proposed project activities and ex-ante estimates for forest growth? Budget should at minimum include: personnel, equipment and supplies, infrastructure, travel and certification fees. | Project financial plan | If no, +2. | ||
Does the project financial plan rely on future increases in market price for Carbon | Project financial plan | If yes, +1. | ||
Has The Project obtained non-delivery risk insurance | Project Proponent declaration | If yes, -2. | ||
Social Governance Risk | Are there currently or have there been disputes over land ownership over the last 20 years? | Jurisdictional history | If yes, + 2. | |
Does the government have a history of revoking legal agreements regarding land ownership, access, and usage? | Jurisdictional history | If yes, + 2. | ||
Does the project host country score below the 40th percentile on 3+ of the Worldwide Governance Indicators over the last 10 years? |
| If yes, +2. | ||
Does the government have an NDC in place that addresses corresponding adjustments/prevents of project | National registries | If no, +1. | ||
Does The Project have a detailed benefit-sharing plan that includes: clear distribution mechanisms, transparent criteria for beneficiary selection, a grievance resolution process, monitoring and reporting procedures? | Project financial plan | If no, +2. If missing elements, +1. If legally binding with all elements, -1. If audited by 3rd party with all elements, -1 | ||
Does the Project Proponent have a presence on human rights, environmental or labor infraction lists? | National registries | If yes, fail. | ||
Does the Project Proponent have ongoing legal disputes? | National registries | If yes, +1. | ||
Have projects on Indigenous or Community Lands been identified? | Cross reference project documentation with | If no, fail. | ||
Has the Project Proponent developed and/or procured a forest management plan for enrolled landowners | Project Design Document and/or Project Proponent Declaration | If no, +1. | ||
Are opportunity cost risk mitigations in place? | Legal agreements protecting carbon stocks, Non-profit status documentation, grant/funding agreements | Legally protected for Crediting Period, -1. Legally protected for ≥ 100 years, -2. Non-profit status or secured additional funding, -1. | ||
Disturbance Risk | Fire risk | Mean daily | If > 10, +1. If > 30, +2. If > 50, +3. If > 75, fail. | |
Pest and disease outbreak risk | Regional third-party maps, if available. | If high, +2. If medium, +1. If low, 0. | ||
Extreme weather (temperature - heat and cold) | IPCC AR637 - See Appendix B for scoring | If high, +2. If medium, +1. If low, 0. | ||
Extreme weather (hydrologic - flood and drought) | IPCC AR637 - See Appendix B for scoring | If high, +2. If medium, +1. If low, 0. | ||
Windfall risk | Regional third-party maps, if available. | If high, +2. If medium, +1. If low, 0. | ||
Icestorm risk | Regional third-party maps, if available. | If high, +2. If medium, +1. If low, 0. | ||
Coastal risks (sea level rise, storm surge, tropical cyclones, salinity intrusion) | Regional third-party maps, if available. | If high, +2. If medium, +1. If low, 0. | ||
Geologic risks (earthquakes, tsunami, volcanoes) |
| If historical hazards in area, +1. | ||
Illegal timber risk |
| If high, +2. If medium, +1. If low, 0. | ||
Surrounding anthropogenic activities pose environmental risk (e.g., toxic pollution, industrial farming, new developments etc.) | Satellite imagery, site visit | If yes, +1. | ||
Ecological Resilience | Project Design Document | If > 80% of trees heat/drought tolerant, -1. |
The following section outlines how Isometric calculates the indicator scores for climate-related extreme weather disturbance risks to carbon permanence within a project’s region (Figure B1). Project Proponents should use Table B1 to lookup the Isometric-calculated values for their project's region and include those scores in their Risk Assessment (see Appendix A).
Extreme weather risks are assessed via two indicators: a temperature indicator (extreme heat and/or cold) and a hydrologic indicator (flooding and/or drought). Each indicator includes both historical data (1961-2015) and projected future extreme events. Historical data indicate the likelihood of extreme events based on past climate patterns, e.g., projects in regions with extended dry periods are expected to experience increased water stress as part of their typical climate. Climate model projections describe how changing climate conditions, relative to historical patterns, might present an increased risk of disturbances. Areas where there is a larger shift towards extreme conditions under future climate relative to their historical baseline have a greater disturbance risk (e.g., drier conditions relative to historical averages increases risk for drought-driven mortality).
To calculate the scores in Table B1, Isometric uses values from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change AR6 report37. The temperature indicator is calculated using data describing the annual number of frost days (FD, minimum temperature below 0°C) and annual number of days with a maximum temperature above 40°C ([math: TX_{40}]) to capture extreme cold and extreme heat risks, respectively. The hydrologic indicator is calculated using data describing the maximum 5-day precipitation ([math: RX_{5Day}]) and annual maximum number of consecutive dry days (CDD) to capture risks of flooding and drought, respectively. All values come from the CMIP6 climate models. Future projections use the SSP2-4.5 medium term (2041-2060) scenario and are assessed as the change in value relative to a historical baseline (1961-1990).
For each indicator subcomponent, the region’s terrestrial median value is compared with the global terrestrial distribution of the same variable (Table B2). To convert the regional value into a subscore, regional values below the global 50thth percentile are considered Low Risk, regional values equal to or greater than the global 50th percentile but below the 75th percentile are Medium Risk, and any regional values equal to or greater than the global 75th percentile are High Risk. Low Risks are given a subscore of 0, Medium Risks are 0.25, and High Risks are 0.5. The overall score for each of the indicators is calculated by summing the corresponding subscores, as described below:
[math: Indicator_{Temperature} = Historical_{TX_{40}} + Future_{TX_{40}} + Historical_{FD}]
[math: Indicator_{Hydrological} = Historical_{CDD} + Future_{CDD} + Historical_{RX_{5Day}} + Future_{RX_{5Day}}]
Projected change in the number of frost days is not included as a subcomponent since it is projected that they will decline under future climate across the globe, representing a low risk of future extreme cold events.
Figure B1. Map and lookup table for IPCC regional codes
[Image: image]
Table B1. Regional Lookup Table of Disturbance Risk
Region | Indicator | Variable | Time | Value | Risk | Score | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
NW North America (NWN) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 224.2 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 23.5 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -1.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 54.4 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 11.9 | High | 0.5 | ||||
NE North America (NEN) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 242.9 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 25.1 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -2.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 50.6 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 11.8 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Western North America (WNA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 128.4 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.9 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 2 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 40.6 | Low | 0 | 0 | |
Change (Days) | -0.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 67.3 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 5.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
Central North America (CNA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 104.9 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 4.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 8.9 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 23.7 | Low | 0 | 0.25 | |
Change (Days) | -0.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 84.3 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (%) | 6.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Eastern North America (ENA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 116 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.6 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 15.5 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | -0.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 89.4 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 9 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Northern Central America (NCA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 15.9 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 4.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 8.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 51.6 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -0.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 92.9 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 6 | Low | 0 | ||||
Southern Central America (SCA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 1.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 39.7 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -1.6 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 134.3 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 4.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
Caribbean (CAR) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 24.3 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | 0.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 99.9 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 0.8 | Low | 0 | ||||
NW South America (NWS) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0.6 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.8 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 28.6 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -0.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 133 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 7.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
Northern South America (NSA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 9.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 46.7 | Low | 0 | 1 | |
Change (Days) | 9.7 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 111.6 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 5.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
NE South America (NES) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.3 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 4.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 95 | High | 0.5 | 1.5 | |
Change (Days) | 6.3 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 144.3 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 5.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
South America-Monsoon (SAM) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 7.5 | Low | 0 | 0.25 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 2.2 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 11.5 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 64.8 | Medium | 0.25 | 1.25 | |
Change (Days) | 13.7 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 133.7 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 6 | Low | 0 | ||||
SW South America (SWS) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 35.8 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 65.9 | Medium | 0.25 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -4.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 83 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (%) | -0.9 | Low | 0 | ||||
SE South America (SES) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 16.6 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 2.8 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 5.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 36.3 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | 0.4 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 105.1 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 8.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
Southern South America (SSA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 75.4 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 20.5 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | 1.6 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 57.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 3.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
Northern Europe (NEU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 150.3 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 18.5 | Low | 0 | 0.25 | |
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 52.8 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 10 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Western & Central Europe (WCE) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 109.7 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 22.8 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | 1.3 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 55 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 8.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
Eastern Europe (EEU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 171.4 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 2.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 27.6 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | 1.1 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 42.9 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 10 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Mediterranean (MED) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 27.6 | Low | 0 | 0.25 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 6 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 11.8 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 75 | High | 0.5 | 1 | |
Change (Days) | 6.7 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 49.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 3.9 | Low | 0 | ||||
Western Africa (WAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 1 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 24 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (Days) | 26.4 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 83.5 | High | 0.5 | 1.25 | |
Change (Days) | -0.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 85.2 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (%) | 19.6 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Central Africa (CAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0.25 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 11.1 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (Days) | 9.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 61.8 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | -0.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 84.4 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (%) | 14.9 | High | 0.5 | ||||
North Eastern Africa (NEAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 1 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 16.1 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (Days) | 15.4 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 80.4 | High | 0.5 | 1 | |
Change (Days) | -2.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 64.6 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 15.4 | High | 0.5 | ||||
South Eastern Africa (SEAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 78.5 | High | 0.5 | 1.5 | |
Change (Days) | 0.4 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 91.9 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 9.7 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
West Southern Africa (WSAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 1.2 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 3 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 108.7 | High | 0.5 | 1.5 | |
Change (Days) | 10.5 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 87.6 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 2 | Low | 0 | ||||
East Southern Africa (ESAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 2.7 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 2.8 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 68.7 | Medium | 0.25 | 1.25 | |
Change (Days) | 4.3 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 127.5 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 6 | Low | 0 | ||||
Madagascar (MDG) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 46.7 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -1.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 175.7 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 5.8 | Low | 0 | ||||
Russian-Arctic (RAR) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 271.3 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 31.5 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -4.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 39.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 16.7 | High | 0.5 | ||||
West Siberia (WSB) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 203.1 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 2 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 31.4 | Low | 0 | 0.25 | |
Change (Days) | -0.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 37.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 10.8 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
East Siberia (ESB) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 233.9 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 34.1 | Low | 0 | 0.25 | |
Change (Days) | -3.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 54.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 11.5 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Russian-Far-East (RFE) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 238.1 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 28.8 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -3.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 65.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 14.4 | High | 0.5 | ||||
West Central Asia (WCA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 95.8 | High | 0.5 | 1.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 22 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (Days) | 17.5 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 113.6 | High | 0.5 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | -0.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 42.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 10 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
East Central Asia (ECA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 195.6 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 2.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 75.1 | High | 0.5 | 1 | |
Change (Days) | -6.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 30.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 12.9 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Tibetan-Plateau (TIB) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 258.6 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 1.6 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 42.3 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | -2.6 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 80.9 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (%) | 11.6 | High | 0.5 | ||||
East Asia (EAS) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 91.7 | Medium | 0.25 | 0.25 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.3 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 29.1 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | 0.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 132 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 9.6 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
South Asia (SAS) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 7.9 | Low | 0 | 1 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 33.1 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (Days) | 14.5 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 93.9 | High | 0.5 | 1.5 | |
Change (Days) | -3.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 132.2 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 12 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Southeast Asia (SEA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.3 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 1.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 26.8 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | 0.8 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 168.4 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 7.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
Northern Australia (NAU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0.75 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 11.8 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (Days) | 20.4 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 95.7 | High | 0.5 | 1.25 | |
Change (Days) | 0.7 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 163.7 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 7.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Central Australia (CAU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | 1 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 27.8 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (Days) | 75.8 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 27.3 | Low | 0 | 1 | |
Change (Days) | 3.5 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 86.5 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 4.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Eastern Australia (AU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 1.4 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 2.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 4.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 35.8 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -0.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 120.6 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 5.6 | Low | 0 | ||||
Southern Australia (SAU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 1.3 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 7.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 6.9 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 40.2 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | 2 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 60.3 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 2.8 | Low | 0 | ||||
New Zealand (NZ) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 5.9 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 13.8 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | 0.5 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 92.3 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 5.6 | Low | 0 | ||||
South Pacific Ocean (SPO) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 19.4 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -0.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 183.3 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 3.8 | Low | 0 |
Table B2. Global Benchmark Values for Extreme Weather Risks.
Time Frame | Variable | Median | 75th % | 90th % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Historical | Frost Days | 89.8 | 94.1 | 97.5 |
Days Max Temp > 40°C | 9.9 | 15.1 | 21.9 | |
Consecutive Dry Days | 63.7 | 71 | 76.2 | |
Maximum 5-day Precipitation (mm) | 79.5 | 86 | 90.4 | |
Projected Future | Frost Days | |||
Days Max Temp > 40°C | 9.9 | 11.8 | 14.6 | |
Consecutive Dry Days | 0.3 | 1.1 | 1.8 | |
Maximum 5-day Precipitation (%) | 8.9 | 11.5 | 14.1 |
By default, Projects are subject to a flat 20% Buffer Pool contribution as outlined in the IFM Protocol (see Section 10.4.1) of the Improved Forest Management Protocol. Project Proponents may opt to calculate a project-specific Buffer Pool contribution based on the outputs of their Risk Assessment (Appendix A) for each Reporting Period.
[/R-SKG0-0]The 5% additional Buffer Pool contribution applied when formal protection documentation is not in place is defined in Section 4.3 Intent to Protect. It is added on top of the base Buffer Pool contribution computed in this Appendix, at each Verification where the relevant documentation is not in place.
The following steps are used to convert the outputs of the Risk Assessment into a Buffer Pool contribution:
Table C1. Risk score to Buffer Pool contribution conversion for each risk category.
Risk Category | Cumulative Risk Score | Buffer Pool Contribution |
|---|---|---|
Project Proponent Capacity Risk | 0 | 2.0 |
1 | 2.2 | |
2 | 2.7 | |
3 | 4.0 | |
4 | 6.0 | |
5 | 7.3 | |
6 | 7.8 | |
7 | 8.0 | |
Financial Viability Risk | 0 | 2.0 |
1 | 2.2 | |
2 | 2.7 | |
3 | 4.0 | |
4 | 6.0 | |
5 | 7.3 | |
6 | 7.8 | |
7 | 8.0 | |
Social Governance Risk | 0 | 2.0 |
1 | 2.2 | |
2 | 2.5 | |
3 | 3.1 | |
4 | 4.3 | |
5 | 5.7 | |
6 | 6.9 | |
7 | 7.5 | |
8 | 7.8 | |
9 | 8.0 | |
Disturbance Risk | 0 | 2.0 |
1 | 2.1 | |
2 | 2.3 | |
3 | 2.5 | |
4 | 2.8 | |
5 | 3.4 | |
6 | 4.1 | |
7 | 5.0 | |
8 | 5.9 | |
9 | 6.6 | |
10 | 7.2 | |
11 | 7.5 | |
12 | 7.7 | |
13 | 7.9 | |
14 | 8.0 |
The Buffer Pool contribution for each risk category is determined using a sigmoid function described by Equation C1. The Buffer Pool contribution for each risk category ranges from 2% to 8%.
[math: BP_{risk}=\frac{L}{1+e^{-k(x-x_0)}}+2]
(Equation C1)
Where:
The sigmoid function, Equation C1, applied to each risk category can also be visualized in Figure C1.
[Image: image]
Figure C1. Buffer Pool contribution based on risk score for each risk category.
The Project has completed the Risk Assessment and obtained the following risk scores in a Reporting Period:
Mapping these risk scores to Table C1, the total Buffer Pool contribution for the Project is:
2.7% + 6.0% + 3.1% + 2.5% = 14.3%
If The Project did not have evidence of protected status commencing at the end of the Crediting Period, the total would be 19.3%.
This appendix provides detailed information on how Isometric implements the Global Timber Model (GTM) for leakage assessment in this Module, including technical requirements, scalar values, and forest type-regional classifications used in the modeling process.
Isometric implements the Global Timber Model (GTM) to quantify leakage deductions for each Reporting Period based on global runs of leakage rates for forest-type regions, annualized and weighted by The Project's basal area (see Section 8.2). Currently, Isometric uses a 2025 version of the GTM published by Dr. Adam Daigneault at the University of Maine, Dr. Brent Sohngen at Ohio State University, and collaborators from The Nature Conservancy.
Isometric currently applies the scalar values and parameters found below in Table D1 in its GTM implementation.
Table D1. Summary Table of Key Scalars in GTM for Protocol Leakage Assessment
Scalar | Value | Same as used in Daigneault et al 2025 | Explanation |
|---|---|---|---|
Annual discount rate | 5.00% | Yes | Commonly assumed to represent the average expected rate of return in the global forest sector |
Global carbon project implementation rate | 4.00% | No | A conservative accounting of forest area unavailable for commercial harvest due to carbon projects; see detailed explanation below |
Elasticity of management intensity to timber price | Variable | Yes | Set for each region |
Elasticity of timber demand to timber price | -1.0 | Yes | Substitutions occur over decade-long timesteps in GTM, and in aggregate are more likely than single substitutions in single years. See |
Elasticity of land area in forest to timber price | 0.3 | Yes |
To date, the GTM uses a global implementation rate representing the proportion of all forest land globally available for harvest that is enrolled in forest carbon projects. Isometric determines harvest eligibility by accessibility, i.e., all accessible forests are eligible. However, Isometric has excluded forest area reported in the FAO Forest Resources Assessment as "protected".
At publication of this Module, the total global area of land enrolled in forest carbon projects is 77.599 Mha, based on an analysis of all forest-based carbon projects recorded by Renoster as of June 3, 2024. This represents approximately 8% of the total available forest area, which is 982.5 Mha as of the publication of this Module.
Research by Haya et al. (2023)24, 23, Stapp et al. (2023)39, and others suggests that the majority of forest carbon projects greatly overestimate emission reductions and that enrollment in carbon projects has historically been unlikely to result in near-term reductions in harvesting or deforestation. Thus, Isometric applies a conservative estimate that the actual amount of carbon project land on which all harvest is prevented is 50% of the calculated implementation rate of 8%. Thus, Isometric applies a global carbon project implementation rate of 4% (Table D1).
Isometric will match the species present in the project area to a GTM forest type and region (Tables D2, D3). The forest types are based on the 2010 United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (UN FAO) Global Ecological Zones (GEZs), with enhanced resolution for United States forest types based on USFS FIA Regional Groupings. If species or genus are not explicitly listed in the GTM forest types, consult authoritative sources including local foresters and Wood Database to determine similar commercial use and ecological characteristics for matching.
Table D2. Forest type and region classification table for the United States
Forest Type | Region | Forest Type Description | Region Description |
|---|---|---|---|
Pine | Southeast | Pine species grown naturally or commercially, including loblolly pine ( | Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana |
EHW | Eastern non-oak hardwood species grown naturally or commercially, including sweetgum ( | ||
Oak | Oak species ( | ||
Pine | South-Central | Pine species including shortleaf pine ( | Kentucky, Tennessee, Arkansas, Oklahoma |
EHW | Eastern non-oak hardwood species including tulip tree ( | ||
Oak | Oak species including white oak ( | ||
SF | Northeast | Spruce-fir forest types including red spruce ( | Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, New York, Pennsylvania |
Pine | Northern pine species including eastern white pine ( | ||
EHW | Eastern hardwood species including sugar maple ( | ||
Oak | Oak species including northern red oak ( | ||
SF | North-Central | Spruce-fir complexes including white spruce ( | Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan, Iowa, Missouri, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio |
Pine | Northern pine species including red pine ( | ||
EHW | Hardwood species including sugar maple ( | ||
Oak | Oak species including bur oak ( | ||
DF | West | Douglas-fir ( | California, Oregon, Washington |
Pine | Western pine species including ponderosa pine ( | ||
HW | Western hardwood species including red alder ( | ||
SW | Softwood species other than Douglas-fir and pine, including western redcedar ( | ||
HW | Southwest | Southwestern hardwood species including Fremont cottonwood ( | Texas, New Mexico, Arizona |
DF | Douglas-fir ( | ||
Pine | Mountain | Mountain pine species including ponderosa pine ( | Montana, Wyoming, Colorado, Idaho, Nevada, Utah |
HW | Mountain hardwood species including quaking aspen ( |
Table D3. Forest type and region classification table for Countries and regions excluding the United States.
Forest Type | Region | Forest Type Description | Region Description |
|---|---|---|---|
Plantation | China | Fast-growing plantation species including eucalyptus ( | All administrative regions with forest plantation development |
Natural | Natural forest ecosystems including mixed temperate forests, boreal forests, and subtropical forests with native species composition | ||
S. Plt. | Brazil | Short-rotation plantation forestry focused on eucalyptus ( | All states with plantation forestry operations |
Trop. Evergreen | Tropical evergreen rainforest including Amazon rainforest with diverse hardwood species | Primarily Amazon Basin states | |
Trop. Mixed | Tropical mixed forests including Atlantic Forest remnants and Cerrado formations | Atlantic coast regions and central Cerrado | |
Atlantic/MW HW | Canada | Atlantic and Maritime hardwood forests including sugar maple ( | Atlantic Maritime provinces |
Atlantic/MW SW | Atlantic and Maritime softwood forests dominated by red spruce ( | ||
Atlantic/MW Mx | Atlantic and Maritime mixed forests combining hardwood and softwood species | ||
Boreal/Hudson HW | Boreal hardwood forests including paper birch ( | Hudson Bay lowlands region | |
Boreal/Hudson SW | Boreal softwood forests including black spruce ( | ||
Boreal/Hudson MX | Boreal mixed forests combining deciduous and coniferous species in the Hudson Bay region | ||
Taiga HW | Northern taiga hardwood species including paper birch ( | Northern territories and provinces | |
Taiga SW | Taiga softwood forests dominated by black spruce ( | ||
Taiga Mx | Taiga mixed forests combining hardwood and softwood species in extreme northern climates | ||
Boreal West HW | Western boreal hardwood forests including trembling aspen ( | Western boreal regions | |
Boreal West SW | Western boreal softwood forests including white spruce ( | ||
Boreal West MX | Western boreal mixed forests representing transitions between hardwood and softwood stands | ||
Boreal Montane HW | Montane boreal hardwood forests including trembling aspen ( | Rocky Mountain and cordilleran regions | |
Boreal Montane SW | Montane boreal softwood forests including subalpine fir ( | ||
Boreal Montane Mx | Mixed montane boreal forests combining elevation-adapted hardwood and softwood species | ||
Pacific HW | Pacific coast hardwood forests including red alder ( | British Columbia coastal regions | |
Pacific SW | Pacific coast softwood forests dominated by western hemlock ( | ||
Pacific Mx | Pacific coast mixed forests combining coastal hardwood and softwood species | ||
Conifer | Russia | Russian coniferous forests including Siberian pine ( | Siberian and Far East regions |
Temp HW | Temperate hardwood forests including birch ( | European Russia and southern regions | |
Bor HW | Boreal hardwood forests dominated by birch ( | Northern boreal zone | |
HW | General hardwood forest classification for mixed deciduous species | Various regions with hardwood forest presence | |
Nord. Plt. | European Union | Nordic plantation forestry including Norway spruce ( | Scandinavia and northern European countries |
Ce.S. Plt. | Central European softwood plantations including Norway spruce ( | Germany, Austria, Czech Republic, and surrounding regions | |
Ce.H.Plt. | Central European hardwood plantations including European beech ( | ||
So.S.Plt. | Southern European softwood plantations including maritime pine ( | Mediterranean countries | |
So.H.Plt. | Southern European hardwood plantations including cork oak ( | ||
E. SW | Eastern European softwood forests including Norway spruce ( | Eastern European member states | |
E. HW | Eastern European hardwood forests including European beech ( | ||
Temp HW | Europe (Non-EU) | Temperate hardwood forests in non-EU European countries including beech ( | Non-EU European countries including Switzerland, Norway, and Balkans |
Temp SW | Temperate softwood forests including Norway spruce ( | ||
Temperate Mixed | Mixed temperate forests combining hardwood and softwood species | ||
LR PLT | South Asia | Large-rotation plantation forestry including teak ( | India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, and surrounding countries |
Tropical | Tropical forests including monsoon forests, dry deciduous forests, and wet evergreen forests | ||
S PLT | Central America | Small-scale plantation forestry including coffee shade trees and mahogany ( | Mexico, Guatemala, Belize, Honduras, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, Panama |
TMP EVER | Temperate evergreen forests including cloud forests and pine-oak forests | ||
TMP MX | Temperate mixed forests combining coniferous and deciduous species | ||
TMP DC | Temperate deciduous forests including oak forests and mixed deciduous formations | ||
S PLT | Rest of South America | Short-rotation plantation forestry including eucalyptus ( | Countries other than Brazil |
TR EVER | Tropical evergreen rainforests including Amazon basin forests | ||
TR MIX | Tropical mixed forests including seasonal dry forests and forest-savanna mosaics | ||
TEMP MX | Temperate mixed forests including Valdivian rainforest and Andean mixed forests | ||
S PLT | Sub-Saharan Africa | Short-rotation plantation forestry including eucalyptus ( | African countries south of the Sahara Desert |
TR EV | Tropical evergreen forests including Congo Basin rainforests and East African montane forests | ||
TR MIX | Tropical mixed forests including miombo woodlands and moist forests | ||
Dipt | Southeast Asia | Dipterocarp forests dominated by Dipterocarpaceae family species characteristic of Southeast Asian rainforests | Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, Philippines, Vietnam, and surrounding countries |
Trop. Dry | Tropical dry forests including monsoon forests and deciduous forests | ||
Trop. Moist | Tropical moist forests including lowland rainforests and wet evergreen formations | ||
S. Plt. | Short-rotation plantation forestry including oil palm ( | ||
Temp | Oceania | Temperate forests including sclerophyll forests and wet temperate rainforests | Australia, New Zealand, and Pacific Islands |
Trop. Dry | Tropical dry forests and woodlands adapted to seasonal rainfall | ||
Trop. Moist | Tropical moist forests including wet tropical rainforests | ||
S. Plt. | Short-rotation plantation forestry including eucalyptus ( | ||
Temperate | Japan | Temperate forests including deciduous broad-leaved forests and mixed forests | All prefectures |
S PLT | Short-rotation plantation forestry including Japanese cedar ( | ||
TR EVER | Africa and Middle East | Tropical evergreen forests in limited areas with suitable tropical climate | Limited tropical forest areas |
TR MIX | Tropical mixed forests and woodlands including dry forests and savanna-forest transitions | Various countries in Africa and Middle East |
For a total standing AGB mass of [math: K] at the pre-harvest, we can consider how it is broken up into [math: n] pools (e.g., harvest residue, milling residue, product 1, product 2, etc.). As such, the remaining amount at any given time point of a single harvest can be described as the sum of what is remaining in all the individual pools:
[math: H_s(t) = \sum_{i=1}^{n} H_{s,i}(t)]
(Equation E1)
Where:
[math: H_{s,i}(t)] can be described by:
[math: H_{s,i}(t) = f_i K e^{-\lambda_i t}]
(Equation E2)
Where:
The decay rate is defined exponentially as:
[math: \lambda_i = \frac{\ln 2}{t_{1/2, i}}]
(EquationEquation E3)
Where:
For longer-lived pools, we also need to consider potential remaining biomass from prior harvests; e.g.
[math: H_i(t) = f_i K e^{-\lambda_i t} + f_i K e^{-\lambda_i(t+T)} + f_i K e^{-\lambda_i(t+2T)} + \dots = f_i K e^{-\lambda_i t} \sum_{n=0}^{\infty} e^{-\lambda_i n T}]
(Equation E4)
Where:
The summation term is a geometric series and thus the equation can be simplified as:
[math: H_i(t) = f_i K e^{-\lambda_i t} \left( \frac{1}{1 - e^{-\lambda_i T}} \right) = \frac{f_i K e^{-\lambda_i t}}{1 - e^{-\lambda_i T}}]
(Equation E5)
To find the temporal mean over a single rotation cycle, we can integrate and divide by the length, [math: T]:
[math: \bar{H}_i = \frac{1}{T} \int_{0}^{T} H_i(t) dt]
(Equation E6)
Substituting in the expression for [math: H_i(t)]:
[math: \bar{H}_i = \frac{f_i K}{T(1 - e^{-\lambda_i T})} \int_{0}^{T} e^{-\lambda_i t} dt]
(Equation E7)
Integrating:
[math: \bar{H}_i = \frac{f_i K}{T(1 - e^{-\lambda_i T})} \cdot \left( \frac{1}{\lambda_i} (1 - e^{-\lambda_i T}) \right)]
(Equation E8)
And simplifying yields:
[math: \bar{H}_i = \frac{f_i K}{T \lambda_i}]
(Equation E9)
For multiple pools, the total harvest product mean would then be the sum of all the individual pools for harvested wood:
[math: \bar{H} = \sum_{i=1}^{n} \frac{f_i K}{T \lambda_i} = \frac{K}{T} \left( \frac{f_1}{\lambda_1} + \frac{f_2}{\lambda_2} + \dots \right)]
(Equation E10)
From here we want to define the mean standing stock [math: \bar{B}] in the counterfactual, which will be measured as part of the dynamic baseline, in terms of the same variables so that we can express [math: \bar{H}] relative to [math: \bar{B}]
We can define the harvest amount ([math: K]), inclusive of all residues, in terms of the standing biomass as:
[math: K = B_{\max} - B_{\min}]
(Equation E11)
Where:
The mean forest biomass is then:
[math: \bar{B} = \frac{1}{T} \int_{0}^{T} B(t) dt]
(Equation E12)
After a harvest, we can define [math: B(t)] as:
[math: B(t) = \underbrace{B_{\min}}_{\text{starting point}} + \underbrace{B(t) - B_{\min}}_{\text{regrowth}}]
(Equation E13)
Where:
We can normalize the regrowth portion of the equation to be relative to the harvest amount ([math: K]):
[math: g(t) = \frac{B(t) - B_{\min}}{K}]
(Equation E14)
Where:
We can rearrange Equation E14 to be:
[math: B(t) = B_{\min} + K g(t)]
(Equation E15)
Substituting this back into the integral mean expression for [math: \bar{B}] (Equation E12) we get:
[math: \bar{B} = \frac{1}{T} \int_{0}^{T} (B_{\min} + K g(t)) dt]
(Equation E16)
Integrating yields:
[math: \bar{B}= \frac{1}{T} \int_{0}^{T} B_{\min} dt + \frac{1}{T} \int_{0}^{T} K g(t) dt = B_{\min} + \underbrace{\frac{K}{T}\int_{0}^{T} g(t) dt}_{\substack{\text{Time averaged} \text{normalized regrowth, } \bar{g}}}]
(Equation E17)
The final integral term over [math: T] is equivalent to the time average normalized regrowth ([math: \bar{g}]), such that:
[math: \bar{B} = B_{\min} + K \bar{g}]
(Equation E18)
We can then substitute [math: B_{\min} = B_{\max} - K] (from Equation B11E11) to get:
[math: \bar{B} = B_{\max} - K + K \bar{g} = B_{\max} - K(1 - \bar{g})]
(Equation E19)
We can then define [math: \gamma = B_{\max}/K] which describes the harvest intensity and rewrite the Equation E19 as:
[math: \bar{B} = \gamma K - K(1 - \bar{g})]
(Equation E20)
We can now define [math: \beta = 1-\bar{g}], which describes the temporal asymmetry in regrowth.
We can substitute in this term for [math: \beta] into the derivation of [math: \bar{B}]:
[math: \bar{B} = \gamma K - \beta K = K(\gamma - \beta)]
(Equation E21)
We can then define the ratio of the full counterfactual (standing + harvested pools) relative to the standing mean only by combining Equations E10 and E21:
[math: \frac{\bar{B} + \bar{H}}{\bar{B}} = \frac{K(\gamma - \beta) + \frac{K}{T} \sum_{i=1}^{n} \frac{f_i}{\lambda_i}}{K(\gamma - \beta)} = 1 + \frac{\frac{K}{T} \sum_{i=1}^{n} \frac{f_i}{\lambda_i}}{K(\gamma - \beta)}= 1 + \frac{\frac{1}{T} \sum_{i=1}^{n} \frac{f_i}{\lambda_i}}{(\gamma - \beta)}]
(Equation E22)
This term is equal to [math: f_{HWP}], and acts as a correction factor that can be used as a multiplier of the time averaged standing counterfactual stock which comes from the dynamic baseline ([math: C_{DB,counterfactual}]) to yield the full counterfactual (Ccounterfactual) which includes both the standing stock and the harvested pools:
[math: C_{\text{counterfactual}} = \left( 1 + \frac{\frac{1}{T} \sum_{i=1}^{n} \frac{f_i}{\lambda_i}}{(\gamma - \beta)} \right) C_{DB,\text{counterfactual}}]
(Equation E23)
For example, if [math: f_{HWP}] was equal to 1.2, this means that adding in the harvested pools raises the standing-only baseline by 20%. As such, we implement this method by measuring [math: C_{DB,counterfactual}] from the dynamic baseline, and then calculating the project-specific [math: f_{HWP}] to add in the harvested pools.
Nyland, R. D. (2016). Silviculture: concepts and applications. Waveland Press. ↩
Todd W. Bowersox, The Practice of Silviculture—Applied Forest Ecology, Ninth Edition, Forest Science, Volume 43, Issue 3, August 1997, Pages 455–456, https://doi.org/10.1093/forestscience/43.3.455↩
Harmon, M.E., Ferrell, W.K., & Franklin, J.F. (1990). Effects on carbon storage of conversion of old-growth forests to young forests. Science, 247(4943), 699-702. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.247.4943.699↩↩2
Franklin, J.F., Mitchell, R.J., & Palik, B.J. (2007). Natural disturbance and stand development principles for ecological forestry. Gen. Tech. Rep. NRS-19. USDA Forest Service, Northern Research Station. https://doi.org/10.2737/NRS-GTR-19↩
Burivalova, Z., Şekercioğlu, Ç.H., & Koh, L.P. (2014). Thresholds of logging intensity to maintain tropical forest biodiversity. Current Biology, 24(16), 1893-1898. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2014.06.065↩
Feldpausch, T.R., Jirka, S., Passos, C.A.M., Jasper, F., & Riha, S.J. (2005). When big trees fall: Damage and carbon export by reduced impact logging in southern Amazonia. Forest Ecology and Management, 219(2-3), 199-215. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foreco.2005.09.003↩
Brown, S., Pearson, T., Moore, T., Parveen, A., Ambagis, S., & Shoch, D. (2005). Impact of selective logging on the carbon stocks of tropical forests: Republic of Congo as a case study. Report submitted to the United States Agency for International Development. ↩
Pearson, T.R.H., Brown, S., Murray, L., & Sidman, G. (2017). Greenhouse gas emissions from tropical forest degradation: an underestimated source. Carbon Balance and Management, 12(1), 3. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13021-017-0072-2↩↩2
Piponiot, C., Cabon, A., Descroix, L., Dourdain, A., Mazzei, L., Ouliac, B., Rutishauser, E., Sist, P., & Hérault, B. (2022). Optimal strategies for ecosystem services provisioning in Amazonian production forests. Environmental Research Letters, 17(2), 024026. ↩↩2
Raymond, P., Bédard, S., Roy, V., Larouche, C., & Tremblay, S. (2009). The irregular shelterwood system: Review, classification, and potential application to forests affected by partial disturbances. Journal of Forestry, 107(8), 405-413. ↩↩2
Matthews, J.D. (1989). Silvicultural Systems. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK. ↩
Fang, Y., Chen, Y., Wang, D., & Li, B. V. (2025). The potential of abandoned tree plantations to support the recovery of the mammal community. Biological Conservation, 308, 111245 ↩
Buotte, P.C., Law, B.E., Ripple, W.J., & Berner, L.T. (2020). Carbon sequestration and biodiversity co-benefits of preserving forests in the western United States. Ecological Applications, 30(2), e02039. https://doi.org/10.1002/eap.2039↩
Griscom, B.W., Adams, J., Ellis, P.W., Houghton, R.A., Lomax, G., Miteva, D.A., … & Fargione, J. (2017). Natural climate solutions. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 114(44), 11645-11650. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1710465114↩
Badgley, G., Freeman, J., Hamman, J.J., Haya, B., Trugman, A.T., Anderegg, W.R., & Cullenward, D. (2022). Systematic over-crediting in California’s forest carbon offsets program. Global Change Biology, 28(4), 1433-1445. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.15943↩
Haya, B.K., Farber-DeAnda, M., Makower, E., & Stapp, L. (2023). Comprehensive review of carbon quantification by improved forest management offset protocols. Frontiers in Forests and Global Change, 6, 958879. https://doi.org/10.3389/ffgc.2023.958879↩
Nash, M., Page-Dumroese, D., Archer, V., Napper, C., Etter, T., & Chavez, J. (2022). Identifying soils trafficability: Soils operability conditions for machine traffic. 2125-1815-NTDP. Washington, DC: US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, National Technology and Development Program. 37 p. https://www.fs.usda.gov/rm/pubsjournals/2022/rmrs2022nashm001.pdf↩
Cavalli, R., & Amishev, D. (2019). Steep terrain forest operations–challenges, technology development, current implementation, and future opportunities. International Journal of Forest Engineering, 30(3), 175-181. https://doi.org/10.1080/14942119.2019.1603030↩
Dudley, N. (Editor) (2008). Guidelines for Applying Protected Area Management Categories. Gland, Switzerland:IUCN. x 86pp. WITH Stolton, S., P. Shadie and N. Dudley (2013). IUCN WCPA Best Practice Guidance on Recognising Protected Areas and Assigning Management Categories and Governance Types, Best Practice Protected Area Guidelines Series No. 21, Gland, Switzerland: IUCN. ↩
Philipson, C. D., Cutler, M. E., Brodrick, P. G., Asner, G. P., Boyd, D. S., Moura Costa, P., ... & Burslem, D. F. (2020). Active restoration accelerates the carbon recovery of human-modified tropical forests. Science, 369(6505), 838-841. ↩
Miyamoto, K., Aiba, S. I., Aoyagi, R., & Nilus, R. (2024). Logging impacts on above-and belowground forest biomass and production in Bornean lowland forests. Tropics, 33(1), 9-26. ↩
M.B. Mills, et al., Tropical forests post-logging are a persistent net carbon source to the atmosphere, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 120 (3) e2214462120, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2214462120 (2023). ↩
Badgley, G., Freeman, J., Hamman, J. J., Haya, B., Trugman, A. T., Anderegg, W. R., & Cullenward, D. (2022). Systematic over‐crediting in California's forest carbon offsets program. Global Change Biology, 28(4), 1433-1445. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.15943↩↩2
Haya, B. K., Evans, S., Brown, L., Bukoski, J., Butsic, V., Cabiyo, B., ... & Sanchez, D. L. (2023). Comprehensive review of carbon quantification by improved forest management offset protocols. Frontiers in Forests and Global Change, 6, 958879 https://doi.org/10.3389/ffgc.2023.958879↩↩2
Haya, B. (2019). The California Air Resources Board's U.S. Forest Offset Protocol Underestimates Leakage. University of California, Berkeley. Available online at: https://gspp.berkeley.edu/assets/uploads/research/pdf/PolicyBrief-USForestProjects-Leakage-Haya4.pdf (accessed September 15, 2025 ↩
Sohngen, B., Mendelsohn, R., & Sedjo, R. (1999). Forest management, conservation, and global timber markets. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 81(1), 1-13. https://doi.org/10.2307/1244446↩↩2
Daignault, A., Sohngen, B., Belair, E, Ellis, P.W. (2025). A globally relevant data-driven assessment of carbon leakage from forestry. Environmental Research Letters, 20, 114022 https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ae0ce2↩
Miyamoto, K., Aiba, S. I., Aoyagi, R., & Nilus, R. (2024). Logging impacts on above-and belowground forest biomass and production in Bornean lowland forests. Tropics, 33(1), 9-26. ↩
M.B. Mills, et al., Tropical forests post-logging are a persistent net carbon source to the atmosphere, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 120 (3) e2214462120, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2214462120 (2023). ↩
Nolte, C. (2020). High-resolution land value maps reveal underestimation of conservation costs in the United States. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 117(47), 29577-29583. ↩
Gao, S., Zhong, R., Yan, K., Ma, X., Chen, X., Pu, J., ... & Myneni, R. B. (2023). Evaluating the saturation effect of vegetation indices in forests using 3D radiative transfer simulations and satellite observations. Remote Sensing of Environment, 295, 113665 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2023.113665↩
An initial evaluation of carbon proxies for dynamic reforestation baselines. Pachama. Retrieved October 16, 2024, from https://pachama.com/blog/dynamic-reforestation-baselines/↩
Rüter, S., Matthews, R. W., Lundblad, M., Sato, A., & Hassan, R. A. (2019). Chapter 12: harvested wood products 2019 Refinement to the 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories. IPCC: Geneva, Switzerland, 49 ↩↩2
Winjum, J. K., Brown, S., & Schlamadinger, B. (1998). Forest harvests and wood products: sources and sinks of atmospheric carbon dioxide. Forest Science, 44(2), 272-284. ↩
Skog, K. E. (2008). Sequestration of carbon in harvested wood products for the United States. Forest products journal. Vol. 58, no. 6 (June 2008): Pages 56-72. ↩
Wilkinson, M. D., Dumontier, M., Aalbersberg, I. J., Appleton, G., Axton, M., Baak, A., ... & Mons, B. (2016). The FAIR Guiding Principles for scientific data management and stewardship. Scientific Data, 3(1), 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1038/sdata.2016.18↩
IPCC, 2023: Climate Change 2023: Synthesis Report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Core Writing Team, H. Lee and J. Romero (eds.)]. IPCC, Geneva, Switzerland, pp. 35-115. https://doi.org/10.59327/IPCC/AR6-9789291691647↩↩2↩3
Lubowski, R. N., Vesterby, M., Bucholtz, S., Baez, A., & Roberts, M. J. (2006). Major uses of land in the United States, 2002. ↩
Stapp, J., Nolte, C., Potts, M., Baumann, M., Haya, B. K., & Butsic, V. (2023). Little evidence of management change in California’s forest offset program. Communications Earth & Environment, 4(1), 331. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43247-023-00984-2↩