This Protocol provides the requirements and procedures for the calculation of net carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e) removal from the atmosphere via reforestation. Reforestation refers to activities that lead to an increase in forest cover on land that was previously covered by forest, restoring the native forest ecosystem1.
Earth’s forests store approximately 861 gigatonnes of carbon2. Forests can act as a source or sink of carbon, and are estimated to absorb a net 7.6 gigatonnes of CO2 per year3 by converting atmospheric CO2 into biomass through photosynthesis. Carbon is also steadily released from forest biomass through respiration and oxidation, or as a result of disturbances such as timber harvesting, fires, and deforestation.
Reforestation activities include, but are not limited to, planting tree seedlings, facilitating natural regeneration, and/or ongoing management of the forest to maximize and preserve the carbon removed from the atmosphere that is stored in tree biomass. Restoration of forested lands globally could represent an additional storage of 200 gigatonnes of carbon at forest maturity4, making it a useful tool in reaching the projected IPCC Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) storage needs of the mid-century. In addition to carbon sequestration potential, reforestation has several co-benefits such as restoration of forest habitat, creation of wildlife corridors, and enhancement of biodiversity on previously degraded lands.
This Protocol accounts for the quantification of the gross amount of CO2 removed via growth and regeneration of forest vegetation, as well as all cradle-to-grave life-cycle Greenhouse Gas (GHG)emissions associated with the process. This Protocol is developed to adhere to the requirements of ISO 14064-2: 2019 – Greenhouse Gasses – Part 2: Specification with guidance at the Project level for quantification, monitoring, and reporting of greenhouse gas emission reductions or removal enhancements.
The Protocol ensures:
This Protocol and all standardized approaches therein — including but not limited to the dynamic baseline (Section 9.45) — are informed by the best available scientific knowledge and undergo external review by subject matter experts and relevant stakeholders. All comments received during consultation are publicly addressed, with revisions incorporated as appropriate, to ensure the certified version of the Protocol will yield high quality Carbon Certificates via rigorous, conservative, and appropriate methodologies.
Throughout this Protocol, the use of “must” indicates a requirement, whereas “should” indicates a recommendation.
This Protocol relies on and is intended to be compliant with the following standards and protocols:
Additional reference standards that inform the requirements and overall practices incorporated in this Protocol include:
Additional principles that were considered in the development of this Protocol and aligned with, where feasible, include:
Protocols and Methodologies that were assessed as part of a literature review during the development of this Protocol include:
This Protocol was developed based on the current state of the art, publicly available science regarding reforestation activities and long-term monitoring of forest carbon projects. This Protocol aims to be scientifically stringent and robust. We recognize that some requirements may exceed the status quo in the market and that there are numerous opportunities to improve the rigor of this Protocol. Key future improvements to the Protocol are outlined in Appendix D.
Additionally, this Protocol will be reviewed when there is an update to published scientific literature, government policies, or legal requirements which would affect net CO₂e removal quantification or the monitoring guidelines outlined in this Protocol, or at a minimum of every 2 years.
This Protocol aimsapplies to guide Projects that aim to restore inland forests to a state of ecological integrity5 in areas where they have historically existed and are resilient to future climate scenarios. Projects should emphasize protection and restoration of ecosystem function, biodiversity, and social livelihoods.
This protocol supports the restoration of native forest ecosystems. Projects should notthat resemble commercial plantation forestry, andor that plan for or implement clear-cutting at any point in the fateProject Commitment Period, fall outside of forestsits scope; the corresponding requirements are set out in Section 4.2. Forests restored in accordance withunder this Protocol shouldare notintended to remain standing beyond the Project Commitment Period rather than be clear-cuttingcut for timber sale (see Section 5.6).
The geographic Project Boundary must encompass all geographic areas where the Project Proponent is conducting reforestation activities for crediting purposes. This can consist of a single continuous area, or a collection of discrete planting areas. In the context of this Protocol, a discrete planting area is considered to be the largest contiguous land area which is subject to the same Project and management activities (e.g., a smallholder farm, land parcel) and can be no smaller than 0.5 ha. This Protocol applies across the temporal (Seesee Section 5) and spatial scope of the Project. The Project Boundary must be set at the time of project initiation and cannot be modified beyond the addition of new areasProject Areas to the Project once the crediting period begins.
Any adjacent planting activities or land management by the Project Proponent must be disclosed with justification and evidence that they do not pose any risks to the reforestation activities within the Project Boundary.
[/G-501K-0]Where this Protocol requires an action to be taken:
In order to restore ecological integrity and ecosystem function, demonstrate additionality, and ensure trust and transparency, it is incumbent upon Projects to adhere to the following requirements, which must be demonstrated in the Project Design Document:
[R-NPXT-01, Projects must providestate, evidencefor each Project Area, whether it is (a) land that the activities are occurring on degraded lands or lands that dodoes not currently meet the definition of a forest and whose natural ecosystem is forest, or (b) degraded land, and provide evidence of current land cover.]Project activities must include reforestation, management for enhanced carbon stocks, and/or assisted natural regeneration on degraded lands, or either: [/R-NPXT-1]
[G-RMX8-01, IfConditional: Where a Project activitiesArea are occurring withinis degraded forestsland, Projectsprojects must provide (1) evidence that the biomass in the area is lessbelow thanthat expected for a healthy mature forest and(e.g., hasbiomass beendata, stagnantdegrading factors, or decliningcomparison overwith thenearby priornon-degraded tenareas), years,(2) evidence that this is not as athe result of harvesting in the 10 years before project initiation or of ongoing harvesting, and (3) a description of how project activities will address the degrading factors. ]In the context of this Protocol, degraded lands are considered to be areas which currently hold less than the expected biomass of a healthy mature forest biomass and, where forest growth has been stagnant or declined over the prior 10 years --- and this decline is not a result of harvesting within the 10 years prior to project initiation or of ongoing harvesting. For demonstrating eligibility of degraded areaslands, Project Proponents must provide evidence demonstrating the deficit between current and expected biomass in the Project Boundary that will be addressed via project activities. :[/G-RMX8-01]
[G-C9RX-0, Projects must provide an acceptable form of evidence to demonstrate the current land cover, including, but not limited to, (1) field surveys, (2) peer-reviewed scientific studies, (3) remote sensing data products, and (4) peer-reviewed scientific models.]Additional removals are quantified through the dynamic baseline (Section 9.5). Acceptable forms of evidence include, but are not limited to, field surveys, peer-reviewed scientific studies, remote sensing data products, and peer-reviewed scientific models (e.g., Walker et al., 20227, Roebroek et al., 20258). [/G-C9RX-0][R-73F6-0, Projects must provide evidence that the Project activities occur in lands that have historically supported and can ecologically support forests. ]
Project activities must reforest lands that have historically supported forest ecosystems, and where reforestation would restore landscape-level ecological integrity. In the context of this Protocol, this means that reforestation must restore the natural forest ecosystem of the area.
[R-ED6G-01, Projects must demonstrateconfirm, with soil maps or land cover classification, that no Projectproject activities will occur in wetlands (e.g. peatlands, marshes, mangroves). ]Project activities must not occur on natural terrestrial or tidal wetlands (e.g., non-forested peatlands, marshes, mangroves), and identify any seasonally flooded forest, peat forest or human-managed wetland in the project area.]Project activities must not occur on natural terrestrial or tidal wetlands (e.g., non-forested peatlands, marshes, mangroves), evidenced by soil maps or land cover classification[/R-ED6G-0] (see Section 4.1.1). For the purposes of this Protocol, natural wetlands are areas that would be wetlands in the absence of human water management (e.g., pumping, levees, impoundments or drainage), including natural wetlands that have been drained or degraded. [/R-ED6G-1]
Seasonally flooded forests, where the natural ecosystem of the project area is forest subject to periodic flooding (e.g., bottomland hardwood floodplain forests), are eligible under this Protocol.
[G-KTWB-0, Conditional: Where the project area includes peat forest, projects must provide (1) a risk assessment of emissions and losses from the peat that project activities could cause, (2) the measures that will prevent them, and (3) evidence that the Project will not reduce the peat carbon stock over the Project Commitment Period.]Peat forests, where the natural ecosystem of the project area is forest on peat soils (e.g., peat swamp forests), are eligible where the Project Proponent:[/G-KTWB-0]
Tidal wetlands (e.g., mangroves) remain excluded.
Land cover dataclassification sourcesis derivedone fromof remoteseveral sensingforms of evidence that may be used to demonstrate eligibility under Section 4.1, and usedis fornot required where other acceptable evidence is provided. Where land cover classificationdata inare Sectionused, 4.1they shouldmust meetbe the following criteria:
This Protocol uses the following spatial units:
Strata are subdivisions used for sampling, which may span discrete planting areas within a Project Area, and are defined in the applicable quantification Module.
Projects must not occur in regions where significant reforestation activities are driven by market demand, local and/or national incentives, or forestry policies that would lead to forest restoration without Carbon Finance.
Projects shouldmust not resemble commercial plantation forestry.
Violation of this principle would include monoculture plantations, or plantations limited to several high-value timber species whose composition does not resemble native community assemblages (see Section 64.43), planted in regions where timber is common practice and thus the infrastructure exists to support wood harvesting.
Selection thatharvesting. selectiveThe following requirements apply to any harvesting of a subset ofwithin the forest and harvesting of non-timber forest products is permissible under this Protocol, in accordance with any applicable Module(s) and in consultation with Isometric.
Additionally, this Protocol applies to projects and associated operationsconfirm that meetno allclear-cutting or complete removal of theforest followingcover projectis conditions:
Land tenure and contractual obligation. [R-FG9S-0, Projects must demonstrate that they have proper authorization which covers the length of the Project Commitment Periodresulting from the true property ownership by providing evidence of the landowner's signatory consent. ]To ensure the Project Proponent has proper authorization from the true property ownership, this Protocol explicitly prohibits Project Proponents from enrolling land for Certificates without the landowner's signatory consent, which must be provided in the PDD. [/R-FG9S-0][G-EJ36-0, If the Project will have direct tenure, the Project Proponent must have legal, documented land tenure for the duration of the Crediting Period and access to the project area throughout the Ongoing Monitoring Period]Thus, the Project Proponent must have legal, documented land tenure for the duration of the Crediting Period and access to the project area throughout the Ongoing Monitoring Period for the purposes of meeting the Reversal reporting requirements under Section 10.5.2[/G-EJ36-0]; [G-26YV-0, If the Project will contract with land owned by another party, the landowners must have legal, documented land tenure for the duration of the Crediting Period and the Project Proponent must have access to the land throughout the Ongoing Monitoring Period.]or, if the Project Proponent is contracting on land owned by another party, the landowners must have legal, documented land tenure for the duration of the Crediting Period and the Project Proponent must have access to the land throughout the Ongoing Monitoring Period to perform all requirements set forth by this Protocol and Module(s) the Project Proponent is crediting against.[/G-26YV-0]
Financial plan. Certificate issuances will decrease over time, and continued financial payments are needed to incentivize maintenance of carbon stocks. [R-355E-0, Projects must provide a financial model and cash flow statement to demonstrate continued financial viability of the Project for the full Project Commitment Period. ]To evidence the continued financial viability of the Project over the full Project Commitment Period, Project Proponents must provide a financial model and cash flow statement which demonstrates a clear payment structure for the duration of the Ongoing Monitoring Period.[/R-355E-0] Methods to maintain continued financial incentives may include, but are not limited to:
[G-R44S-0, If operational, legal, or regulatory constraints preclude the development of a financial model or negate its efficacy, Projects must provide justification for the absence of a financial plan and describe what alternative mechanisms will be in place to support maintenance of carbon stocks. ] If operational, legal, or regulatory constraints preclude the development of a financial model or negate its efficacy for supporting long-term maintenance, the Project Proponent must provide justification for the absence of a financially-based plan for long-term maintenance, as well as details of what alternative mechanisms will be in place to support maintenance of the Project carbon stocks over the full Project Commitment Period. Such mechanisms may include, but are not limited to, conservation easements, governmental protections, or land trusts.[/G-R44S-0]
[Image: Figure 1 Project timelines]
Figure 1 Summary of project periods. Colors represent actions owned by different stakeholders. Blue = Project Proponent. Green = VVB. Pink = Isometric.
A project starting in 2025 has a Project Commitment Period of 100 years composed of a 40 year Crediting Period followed by 60 year Ongoing Monitoring Period. Certificates issued have a 60+ year durability. Monitoring for quantification is conducted by the Project Proponent through the Crediting Period, and the reported activities are verified by a Validation and Verification Body (VVB) for each Reporting Period. At the end of the Crediting Period, maintenance of carbon stocks and monitoring for Reversals occurs for the remaining 60 years of the Project Commitment Period.
The Project must consider environmental and social impacts at all project locations. Appropriate measures must be implemented to identify and eliminate potential risks to terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems and biodiversity. Where risks cannot be eliminated, the Project Proponent must identify measures to monitor ecosystem health and mitigate adverse effects through a site-specific mitigation plan. Mitigation plans must be prepared by subject matter experts, in consultation with Isometric, the VVB, and relevant local authorities, if applicable. Refer to the Isometric Standard for further guidelines on environmental and social impacts.
Following the Isometric Standard, Certificates issued under this Protocol are contingent on the implementation, transparent reporting, and independent Verification of comprehensive safeguards. These safeguards encompass a wide range of considerations, including environmental protection, social equity, community engagement, and respect for cultural values. The process mandates that safeguard plans be incorporated into all major project phases, with detailed reports made accessible to stakeholders. Adherence to and verification of environmental and social safeguards is a condition for all Crediting Projects.
An environmental and social risk assessment in compliance with the Isometric Standard must be completed to identify potential risks, followed by the development of tailored mitigation plans. These plans must encompass specific actions to avoid, minimize or rectify identified impacts. Effective implementation of these measures must also be accompanied by a robust monitoring plan to detect adverse effects and pause project activities if necessary, using the principles of adaptive management described below.
Environmental and social risk identification, assessment, avoidance, and mitigation planning will be unique to the technical, environmental, and social contexts of the Project. To accommodate this variation, the requirements outlined in this section serve as a minimum to which the Project Proponent and Isometric can add risks on a case by case basis, to be included in the PDD, if applicable.
Project Proponents must comply with all national and local laws, regulations and policies, and receive any necessary permits for project activities, if applicable. Where relevant, projects must comply with international conventions and standards governing human rights and uses of the environment.
Project Proponents must document activities that trigger environmental permitting requirements.
Adaptive management incorporates learnings and takeawaysEmissions from project monitoring into project development13. Regular data collection and sharing is necessary to implement adaptive management. Results from data collection at the end of each Reporting Period must be shared with local stakeholders, as described in Section 6.5.1 of this Protocol, and be used to inform future iterations of project management and development.
Project Proponents are required to predict and plan for potential unintended outcomes of project activities and construct mitigation plans for such instances.
Foreseeable risks identified during the preparation of the environmental and social risk assessmentharvesting must be included in theproject PDD and the following must be detailed for each potential risk:
The Project should not hinder the ability of the community or local ecosystem to adapt to climate change as a result of the CDR activity.
The High Conservation Values (HCV) Approach, developed by the HCV Network, identifies regionally specific facets of local communities and ecologies that must be considered during project developments resulting in land use change. The HCV Network has identified six values that may be at risk as a result of land use change projects. The values, along with corresponding requirements for Project Proponents to uphold them, are listed below:
Species Diversity: Rare, threatened, endangered, or endemic species, at populations significant to regional, national, or global levels.
Landscape-level ecosystems, ecosystem mosaics and intact forest landscapes: Broad-scale regions of interacting ecosystems which contain species in their natural patterns or distributions at populations significant on regional, national, or global scales.
Ecosystems and habitats: Rare, threatened, or endangered ecosystems or habitats.
Ecosystem services: Fundamental ecosystem functions critical to ecological integrity and life, e.g., oxygen production, water filtration and protection of catchments, soil formation and erosion prevention, temperature regulation, nutrient cycling, habitat formation, provisioning of food and forage for fauna, etc.
Community needs: Commodities, resources, and community functions that are necessary for the livelihoods of local communities and Indigenous Peoples. This may include food, water, and infrastructure sources.
Cultural values: Sites, landscapes, and habitats of significant cultural, historical, religious, economic, or archaeological value to local communities, Indigenous Peoples, or other groups identified to engage in those locations.
For each value above, the Project Proponent must identify in the PDD if the value is present or absent in the project area. This list must be constructed in consultation with relevant stakeholder groups, as identified in Section 6.5.1 and carried out in accordance with the Isometric Standard. The Stakeholder Engagement Plan for HCV identification must also be included in the PDD.
If a value is absent from the project area, the Project Proponent must provide an explanation or justification such as survey results or recent publications. If a value is present in the project area, the Project Proponent must include a plan to monitor and protect it throughout the Project Commitment Period in the PDD. We encourage Project Proponents to review the Common Guidance for the Management and Monitoring of HCV in developing this plan.
If protection is not feasible during the project activities and an HCV is damaged as a result of project activities, the Project Proponent must provide a restoration plan to return the area to its prior condition and quality.
If an HCV is threatened or damaged by forces or parties outside of the Project Proponent’s jurisdiction and not as a result of or response to project activities, the Project Proponent must report such instances to Isometric, but may not be responsible for enacting a restoration plan. Failure to properly identify, monitor, and protect an HCV may result in the cessation of Certificates.
The Project Proponent must provide due diligence to ensure that the population density of rareplanted, threatenedmaintained or expected through assisted natural regeneration, and endangered species in the project area does not decrease, nor are new species added to this list, as a result of project activities. If either of these adverse impacts do occur, the Project Proponent must work with Isometric and the VVB to identify sources and explanations for these impacts in order to rule out project activities as the primary cause.
It is recommendedconfirm that Projecteach Proponentshas strive to increase the population of rare, threatened, and endangered species. Endangered species are defined as species under threat of extinction from alltwo or amore significant amount of their natural habitat. Threatened species are defined as those that are at risk of becoming endangered. Rare species are defined as those uncommongenera and found in isolated geographical locations. Project Proponents must consult local authorities for further regulations on these or similar groups. If local regulations exist, the Project Proponent must state them in the PDD.
The Project Proponent must consult reputable and current sources on rare, threatened, and endangered species to develop a list of these species, in the following order of priority:
The results of the rare, threatened, and endangered species list review must be included and referenced in the PDD.
For each rare, threatened, or endangered species identified, the Project Proponent must list the following in the PDD:
The Project Proponent must handle data and information related to rare, threatened, and endangered species with discretion for the protection of these species, especially regarding species and/or regions that have histories of poaching, over-harvesting, or other elevated threats to population density and livelihoods.
As stated in Section 4.1, reforestation projects must occur on degraded lands or lands that were historically classified as forests where forest cover was lost to be eligible for crediting under this Protocol.
Because of this applicability requirement and the nature of reforestation projects to plant and maintain species in the project area, reforestation projects are well placed to increase biodiversity in the region. To benchmark increased biodiversity, the minimum number of species is applied at the level of discrete planting areas within the Project Proponents(see Section 4), and depends on the size of the discrete planting area. If a Project is composed of a single continuous area, these thresholds apply to the total project area. Each discrete planting area must include species from two or more genera, and at least the following number of species:
For example, a Project consisting of a single continuous area of 200 ha must have at least five species from two or more genera throughout the project area. A Project consisting of a collection of farms, each ranging from 5 to 30 ha in theirsize, must have at least three species in each farm under 25 ha and at least four species in each farm of 25 ha or more, in each case from two or more genera. Discrete planting planareas may have different species compositions, provided each meets its minimum.
Species counts include species that are being directly planted or maintained as part of the project interventions, and species where regeneration is anticipated when project interventions include assisted natural regeneration.
Projectspeer-reviewed shouldliterature prioritizeor field studies at or near the plantingProject of endemicsite, rare,that threatened,the andregion endangerednaturally nativesupports fewer species or genera.
Species should be planted at ecologically appropriate richness and evenness1711. There may be some regions that naturally support a limited number of species that fulfill ecosystem services and other functions or indicators of healthy ecosystems. Project Proponents in these regions may deviate from the minimum requirednumber of species and genera includedfor ina discrete planting plans, in consultationarea with Isometric approval. Such deviations must be accompanied by appropriate documentation, based in scientific literature and/or ongoing field studies, in the PDD. Where planting of a single dominant species is justified by its dominance during natural succession, the succession plan requirements below also apply. For projects where activities include facilitation of natural regeneration and/or ongoing management for enhanced sequestration in lieu of or in addition to direct planting, the above provisions regarding species composition are also applicable to the species which will be the subject of the regeneration and/or management activities.
Where a portion of the minimum species number is expected to materialize via assisted natural regeneration, the Project Proponents must include details of how monitoring will be done to determine if the contributions of assisted natural regeneration to species diversity are being realized. This plan must include provisions for additional interventions (e.g., supplemental planting) if the assisted natural regeneration is insufficient for creating a diverse species mixture. Results of this monitoring must be reported at each Verification.
Where planting of a single dominant species is justified by scientific evidence for its dominance during natural succession (see Section 4.2), the Project Proponent must include a succession plan in the PDD describing:
Progress against the succession plan must be reported at each Verification.
[/G-RBGX-0]The tree species used for reforestation must follow the principles outlined below and see the Safeguarding of Biodiversity for additional requirements on planting.
The Project Proponent must list the species planted, maintained, and/or maintainedregenerated in the project area via project activities in the PDD.
These species may include native, naturalized, or non-native range-expanding species.
Project Proponents must not introduce species invasive to the region or similar climates, geographies, or ecosystems of the project area1812,1913. The definition of 'invasive species' in this Protocol is consistent with the Convention on Biological Diversity's definition of Invasive Alien Species, being a "species whose introduction and/or spread threaten[s] biological diversity"2014. Projects that plant invasive species will not be eligible for crediting under this Protocol.
Additionally, Project Proponents must not introduce any species that harm rare, threatened, or endangered species as defined in Section 6.3.1 or adversely impact the integrity of rare, threatened, or endangered ecosystems and habitats (see Section 6.3). Project Proponents are highly encouraged to consult with Isometric, the VVB, and/or external subject matter experts to ensure that species included in the reforestation plan meet these requirements and the criteria described below.
[/G-9NYJ-0]For the purposes of this Protocol, native species are defined as:
Naturalized species are defined as:
Reforestation with native species should be the first course of action. If reforestation with only native and naturalized species is not feasible, non-native range-expanding species may be included in the reforestation planting plan. Any non-native species not considered range-expanding for the purposes of this Protocol must not be planted. Non-native range-expanding species are defined as:
[/G-C0CJ-0]In such instances, the majority of species planted must be native and/or naturalized, and the plurality must be native species.
[/G-XAT7-Additionally, the following due diligence must be taken when planting non-native range-expanding species for a Project to be eligible for crediting. The Project Proponent must demonstrate:
Alternative burdens of proof may be sufficient, in consultationaccepted with Isometric approval.
The following due diligence must be conducted and included in the PDD if non-native range-expanding species are to be planted during project activities. The Project Proponent must demonstrate:
[/G-GZNW-1]The use of genetically-modified species for planting will be reviewed by Isometric on a case-by-case basis. Genetically-modified species are defined as:
If genetically-modified species are included in the reforestation planting plan, Project Proponents must submit a justification explaining their use. This should cover why alternative non-genetically-modified species are not used and how biodiversity is safeguarded from the use of genetically-modified species.
[/G-R9D6-1]The Project must not harm Indigenous People and local, underserved, or marginalized communities, in compliance with the Isometric Standard and Section 6 of this Protocol.
Projects should aim to improve ecosystem function and integrity, enhancing biodiversity, through increasing wildlife corridors, avoiding negative impacts on existing ecological functions, and increasing habitat for native flora, fauna, and funga.
Additionally, this Protocol applies to projects and associated operations that meet all of the following project conditions:
The Project must provide a net-negative CO2e impact (net CO2e removal) as calculated in the GHG Statement, in compliance with Section 9.
Requirements. Projects must provide the following to evidence the length of the Project Commitment Period (see Section 11: Pre-deployment Requirements).
[G-NVTG-1, Projects must provide, for the enrolled land, evidence of (1) the identity of the landowner or rights-holder (government ID, or recognition by the traditional authority for customary rights-holders), (2) the right to the land (title, registry, property tax or other government record; or, for customary tenure, documentation from traditional authorities corroborated by community members, neighboring rights-holders or local government records), and (3) a signed contract or documented agreement with the Project Proponent. A landowner's own statement alone is not sufficient.]The Project Proponent and/or landowner(s) must provide evidence of each of the following for the enrolled land: [/G-NVTG-1]
A statement or declaration by the landowner alone is not sufficient evidence of the right to the land.
[R-355E-0, Projects must provide a financial model and cash flow statement to demonstrate continued financial viability of the Project for the full Project Commitment Period.]Financial plan. Certificate issuances will decrease over time, and continued financial payments are needed to incentivize maintenance of carbon stocks. To evidence the continued financial viability of the Project over the full Project Commitment Period, Project Proponents must provide a financial model and cash flow statement which demonstrates a clear payment structure for the duration of the Project Commitment Period. Methods to maintain continued financial incentives may include, but are not limited to: [/R-355E-0]
[G-R44S-0, If operational, legal, or regulatory constraints preclude the development of a financial model or negate its efficacy, Projects must provide justification for the absence of a financial plan and describe what alternative mechanisms will be in place to support maintenance of carbon stocks.]If operational, legal, or regulatory constraints preclude the development of a financial model or negate its efficacy for supporting long-term maintenance, the Project Proponent must provide justification for the absence of a financially-based plan for long-term maintenance, as well as details of what alternative mechanisms will be in place to support maintenance of the Project carbon stocks over the full Project Commitment Period. Such mechanisms may include, but are not limited to, conservation easements, governmental protections, or land trusts.[/G-R44S-0]
Project expansion is the addition of Project Areas (see Section 4) to a Project over time. The following applies to project expansion:
Vintage. The vintage of a Certificate is the calendar year in which the corresponding removal occurred. Where the interval between the end of the previous Reporting Period and the end of the current Reporting Period (being the dates at which carbon stocks were quantified) spans more than one calendar year, Certificates issued for the current Reporting Period may be allocated to calendar-year vintages by linear apportionment over that interval, weighted by planting date. For a Project Area’s first Reporting Period, the interval begins at the start of its Crediting Period. Under project expansion, the interval for each Project Area runs from its previous Verification, or the start of its Crediting Period, to its current Verification.
The share of Certificates allocated to calendar year [math: y] is:
[math: V_y = \frac{\sum_i A_i \, d_{i,y}}{\sum_i \sum_y A_i \, d_{i,y}}]
(Equation 1)
Where:
For areas where project activities consist of assisted natural regeneration rather than planting, the date project activities began is used in place of the planting date. Planting dates and areas must be evidenced in the monitoring report and are reviewed by the VVB. No Certificates may be allocated to a calendar year before planting in the relevant area. Where no allocation is made, Certificates take the vintage of the calendar year in which the Reporting Period ends.
[/R-6T9S-0]Projects must select one of the following approaches to Durability at the time of PDD submission. The selected approach applies for the life of the Project.
[/G-TKV6-0]Durability based on the Project Commitment Period. The Durability of Certificates is set to one half the length of the Project Commitment Period, which must be set at the time of PDD submission and is fixed. If the initial Crediting Period is less than the Project Commitment Period, the Crediting Period may be extended up to, but not beyond, the end of the Project Commitment Period. Any part of the Project Commitment Period not covered by the Crediting Period must consist of an Ongoing Monitoring Period. Project Proponents remain liable for all issued Certificates for the full Project Commitment Period (see Section 5.1).
Durability based on the Ongoing Monitoring Period. This approach is available only where the Ongoing Monitoring Period is equal to or longer than the initial Crediting Period. Under this approach, the Durability of Certificates equals the length of the Ongoing Monitoring Period. That length must be set at PDD submission and cannot be changed afterwards. The Crediting Period may be extended later; if it is, the Project Commitment Period is extended by the same amount, and the Ongoing Monitoring Period starts at the end of the extended Crediting Period, with its length unchanged. Project Proponents are liable for Reversals of each Certificate for the length of its Durability, starting from that Certificate’s issuance (see Section 5.1.1).
For Projects under project expansion, the duration that determines Durability must be the same for all Project Areas: the Project Commitment Period where Durability is based on the Project Commitment Period, or the Ongoing Monitoring Period where Durability is based on the Ongoing Monitoring Period. Crediting Period durations may vary between Project Areas (see Section 5.1.1).
[/G-E8PV-0]The durability of a Certificate is determined relative to the length of the Project Commitment Period as outlined in Section 5.1. The minimum duration of the Project Commitment Period is 40 years, and therefore minimum durability of Certificates issued under this Protocol is 20 years.
The durability must not exceed any of the following:
Reversal risks which may threaten the durability of forest carbon and project-level risk assessment and mitigation requirements are discussed in Section 10.1 and Section 10.2, respectively.
A forestry-wide Buffer Pool managed by Isometric is used to insure Certificates against Reversals. Throughout any Ongoing Monitoring Period, Isometric will monitor for Reversals to ensure Certificates achieve their stated durability. Upon detection and quantification of carbon losses, Certificates issued to the Buffer Pool will be canceled in equal proportion to the loss for which the Project Proponent is liable at the time of Reversal (see Section 5.5.1, Sections 10.3, and 10.4).
Project Proponents must design the Project in a manner that is aligned with long-term durability and sustainability. Well-designed projects should mitigate risk of timber harvest or Reversal after the Project ends (see Section 5.6). Support for long-term durability may consist of evidence of the following, and ideally a combination of factors:
For Projects which derive their Durability as being one-half the Project Commitment Period, Project Proponents remain liable for the all issued Certificates for the full Project Commitment Period. At any given point in time, the liable volume of Certificates is the cumulative sum of all Certificates issued up to that point.
For Projects which derive their Durability from the duration of the Ongoing Monitoring Period, there is a rolling window of liability for Certificates. This window sets the time period for which reversal of stored carbon is subject to reversal compensation via the Buffer Pool. Project Proponents are liable for issued Certificates for the duration of the durability label, starting from the time of issuance. For example, for a project with a 40 year durability label under this approach, the Project Proponent would be liable for potential reversals in Certificates issued in Year 1 of The Project for Years 2 through 41 of the Project. At any given point in the Project Commitment Period, the liable volume of Certificates is the sum of all Certificates for which the durability window is active. This liable volume represents the upper limit for the compensation accounting via the Buffer Pool. Certificates for which the durability window has expired are considered to have already met their stated durability commitment and are no longer subject to treatment as a Reversal. When a Reversal occurs, the accounting conservatively follows a "first in first out" approach wherein the Reversal is applied first to the oldest Certificates within the liable volume.
Project A uses project expansion. It sets a Project Commitment Period of 40 years for each Project Area, with an initial Crediting Period of 20 years for all Project Areas. At the end of the initial Crediting Period, most of the Project Areas renew their enrollment for another 20 years and continue to accumulate Certificates for the remainder of the Project Commitment Period. The remaining Project Areas which did not renew their enrollment enter an Ongoing Monitoring Period to monitor for Reversals for the remaining 20 years of the Project Commitment Period. Monitoring for quantification is conducted by the Project Proponent through the Crediting Period for each Project Area, and the reported activities are verified by a Validation and Verification Body (VVB) for each Reporting Period. For Project Areas under an Ongoing Monitoring Period, Isometric conducts monitoring, and, if a Reversal is detected, the Project Proponent is required to complete reporting (see Section 10.4.2). All Certificates from Project A have a durability of 20 years, equivalent to half of the 40 year Project Commitment Period.
Project B is a reforestation project that commits to an initial Crediting Period of 30 years and an Ongoing Monitoring Period of 40 years at the time of PDD submission. The Project Proponent elects to use the Ongoing Monitoring Period as the basis for Durability, equating to 40 years for all Certificates. Crediting activities proceed as in the prior example during the initial Crediting Period. At the end of the initial Crediting Period, the Project Proponent may extend the Crediting Period, but this is done via extension of the Project Commitment Period and the duration of the Ongoing Monitoring Period is maintained. The Ongoing Monitoring Period commences at the end of the Crediting Period.
The Project must consider environmental and social impacts at all project locations. Appropriate measures must be implemented to identify and eliminate potential risks to terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems and biodiversity. Where risks cannot be eliminated, the Project Proponent must identify measures to monitor ecosystem health and mitigate adverse effects through a site-specific mitigation plan. Mitigation plans must be prepared by subject matter experts, after notifying Isometric and in consultation with relevant local authorities, if applicable, and are reviewed by the VVB. Refer to the Isometric Standard for further guidelines on environmental and social impacts.
[/G-979T-0]Following the Isometric Standard, Certificates issued under this Protocol are contingent on the implementation, transparent reporting, and independent Verification of comprehensive safeguards. These safeguards encompass a wide range of considerations, including environmental protection, social equity, community engagement, and respect for cultural values. The process mandates that safeguard plans be incorporated into all major project phases, with detailed reports made accessible to stakeholders. Adherence to and verification of environmental and social safeguards is a condition for all Crediting Projects.
An environmental and social risk assessment in compliance with the Isometric Standard must be completed to identify potential risks, followed by the development of tailored mitigation plans. These plans must encompass specific actions to avoid, minimize or rectify identified impacts. Effective implementation of these measures must also be accompanied by a robust monitoring plan to detect adverse effects and pause project activities if necessary, using the principles of adaptive management described below.
Environmental and social risk identification, assessment, avoidance, and mitigation planning will be unique to the technical, environmental, and social contexts of the Project. To accommodate this variation, the requirements outlined in this section serve as a minimum to which the Project Proponent and Isometric can add risks on a case by case basis, to be included in the PDD, if applicable.
As part of the environmental and social risk assessment, the Project Proponent must identify local communities and assess whether project activities may result in potential negative impacts on them, or require their physical or economic displacement. For the purposes of this Protocol, local communities are communities living in or near the project area that hold or use rights to land or resources in the project area, whether formal, customary or informal, or whose livelihoods or cultural heritage could be affected by project activities. A potential negative impact is any adverse effect that would leave an individual or community worse off, such that they would prefer the situation before the Project. Potential negative impacts may include, but are not limited to:
Forced eviction, and forced physical or economic displacement, are not permitted. Where potential negative impacts or displacement are identified, the Free, Prior and Informed Consent of the affected local communities is required in accordance with Section 6.5.1.
[/G-GH14-0]Project Proponents must comply with all national and local laws, regulations and policies, and receive any necessary permits for project activities, if applicable. Where relevant, projects must comply with international conventions and standards governing human rights and uses of the environment.
Project Proponents must document activities that trigger environmental permitting requirements.
[/G-QTRE-0]Adaptive management incorporates learnings and takeaways from project monitoring into project development17. Regular data collection, sharing and consultation are necessary to implement adaptive management.
At the end of each Reporting Period, the Project Proponent must share the following with local stakeholders, in an accessible format and language (see Section 6.5.1):
The Project Proponent must offer at least one consultation to each affected community in each Reporting Period, at which stakeholders can comment on these results, and must make reasonable efforts to enable each community to take part (for example, through the timing, location, language and format of the consultation). Where a community declines or does not take part, the Project Proponent must record the efforts made Stakeholder feedback, and the Project Proponent’s response (including any action taken, or the reasons no action was taken), must be recorded and reported at Verification. Non-participation in a consultation must not be treated as consent to, or acceptance of, any planned change. Where a planned change requires Free, Prior and Informed Consent under Section 6.5.1, that consent must be obtained as set out in that section. Project Proponents should involve community members in project monitoring where practical.
[/G-45WS-0]Project Proponents are required to predict and plan for potential unintended outcomes of project activities and construct mitigation plans for such instances.
Mitigation plans must be implemented when their trigger is observed. The adaptive management plan must be updated when a mitigation plan is implemented, or when monitoring results, stakeholder feedback or grievances identify a new or changed risk, and any updates must be reported at the next Verification.
Foreseeable risks identified during the preparation of the environmental and social risk assessment must be included in the PDD and the following must be detailed for each potential risk:
The Project should not hinder the ability of the community or local ecosystem to adapt to climate change as a result of the CDR activity.
The High Conservation Values (HCV) Approach, developed by the HCV Network, identifies regionally specific facets of local communities and ecologies that must be considered during project developments resulting in land use change. The HCV Network has identified six values that may be at risk as a result of land use change projects. The values, along with corresponding requirements for Project Proponents to uphold them, are listed below:
Species Diversity: Rare, threatened, endangered, or endemic species, at populations significant to regional, national, or global levels.
Landscape-level ecosystems, ecosystem mosaics and intact forest landscapes: Broad-scale regions of interacting ecosystems which contain species in their natural patterns or distributions at populations significant on regional, national, or global scales.
Ecosystems and habitats: Rare, threatened, or endangered ecosystems or habitats.
Requirements.
[G-G9N0-1, Projects must confirm that rare, threatened or endangered ecosystems and habitats are excluded from reforestation and not subject to land use change, and give a justified estimate of the area that project activities may degrade, which must not exceed 30% (target ≤ 10%).]These ecosystems and habitats within the project area must be excluded from reforestation activities. The Project Proponent must provide in the PDD a justified estimate of the area of these ecosystems and habitats that other project activities may degrade. Degradation should be minimized and should not exceed 10% of their total area within the project area. Under no circumstances may it exceed 30%18,19. [/G-G9N0-1]
Ecosystem services: Fundamental ecosystem functions critical to ecological integrity and life, e.g., oxygen production, water filtration and protection of catchments, soil formation and erosion prevention, temperature regulation, nutrient cycling, habitat formation, provisioning of food and forage for fauna, etc.
Community needs: Commodities, resources, and community functions that are necessary for the livelihoods of local communities and Indigenous Peoples. This may include food, water, and infrastructure sources.
Cultural values: Sites, landscapes, and habitats of significant cultural, historical, religious, economic, or archaeological value to local communities, Indigenous Peoples, or other groups identified to engage in those locations.
Sites of spiritual, ceremonial or ancestral significance (sacred sites). Sacred sites are places that affected communities identify, through the participatory identification above, as holding spiritual, religious, ceremonial or ancestral significance. They include burial grounds, sacred natural sites (such as groves, springs, trees or rocks), ceremonial and ritual sites, and places associated with ancestors. Their significance is determined by the affected communities and does not depend on legal designation.
For each value above, the Project Proponent must identify in the PDD if the value is present or absent in the project area. This list must be constructed in consultation with relevant stakeholder groups, as identified in Section 6.5.1 and carried out in accordance with the Isometric Standard.
The Stakeholder Engagement Plan for HCV identification must also be included in the PDD. We encourage Project Proponents to review the Common Guidance for the Management and Monitoring of HCV in developing this plan.
[/R-E413-0]If an HCV is threatened or damaged by forces or parties outside of the Project Proponent’s jurisdiction and not as a result of or response to project activities, the Project Proponent must report such instances to Isometric, but may not be responsible for enacting a restoration plan. Failure to properly identify, monitor, and protect an HCV may result in the cessation of Certificates.
[/G-N1NP-0]If a biodiversity HCV, including rare, threatened, or endangered species, ecosystems or habitats, is damaged as a result of project activities, the Project Proponent must provide a restoration plan to return the area to its prior condition and quality, and report its implementation at each Verification.
[/G-8PHB-0]The Project Proponent must provide due diligence to ensure that the population density of rare, threatened, endangered and endemic species in the project area does not decrease, nor are new species added to this list, as a result of project activities, except as permitted under “Declines from reforestation of non-forested or degraded habitat” below.
[/R-HRM2-0]If either of these adverse impacts do occur, the Project Proponent must work with Isometric and the VVB to identify sources and explanations for these impacts in order to rule out project activities as the primary cause.
[/G-G08N-0]It is recommended that Project Proponents strive to increase the population of rare, threatened, and endangered species. Endangered species are defined as species under threat of extinction from all or a significant amount of their natural habitat. Threatened species are defined as those that are at risk of becoming endangered. Rare species are defined as those uncommon and found in isolated geographical locations.
To identify species protected under national or subnational law, and any legal obligations that apply to them (e.g., permits, restrictions on activities, or required mitigation), the Project Proponent must review the applicable legislation and official lists of protected species for the project area. Where this information is not publicly available or is unclear, the Project Proponent must contact the relevant authorities to confirm it. Any legally protected species and associated legal obligations identified must be stated in the PDD.
[/G-3N4A-0]The Project Proponent must consult reputable and current sources on rare, threatened, and endangered species to develop a list of these species, in the following order of priority:
[/G-6QKD-1]The results of the rare, threatened, and endangered species list review must be included and referenced in the PDD.
For each rare, threatened, or endangered species identified, the Project Proponent must list the following in the PDD:
[/G-TCF2-0]Where reforestation can reasonably be expected to decrease the population of a rare, threatened, endangered or endemic species that occupies non-forested or degraded lands in the project area, the Project may proceed only where:
[/G-E1AQ-1]a mitigation plan to minimise the decrease is developed with Isometric approval and included in the PDD. Mitigation plans should include measures such as, but not limited to:
Where monitoring shows a decrease greater than anticipated in the mitigation plan, the Project Proponent must update the plan in accordance with the adaptive management requirements of Section 6.2.
The Project Proponent must handle data and information related to rare, threatened, and endangered species with discretion for the protection of these species, especially regarding species and/or regions that have histories of poaching, over-harvesting, or other elevated threats to population density and livelihoods.
[/G-Q9ZZ-0]As stated in Section 4.21, reforestation projects must occur on lands whose natural ecosystem is forest, either where forest cover has been lost or where the forest is degraded, to be eligible for crediting under this Protocol.
Projects should prioritize the planting of endemic, rare, threatened, and endangered native species.
A robust seedling and germplasm pipeline is central to the ecological, socioeconomic, and cultural success of a reforestation project. A diverse, local, and sustainable pipeline ensures that project activities contribute to the restoration of ecosystem function and integrity, restore and protect biodiversity, safeguard community livelihoods, and uphold cultural values.
Project Proponents must procure and maintain their seedling and germplasm pipeline in alignment with the environmental and social safeguards outlined in Section 6 of this Protocol and the Isometric Standard.
[/G-BY8V-0]The pipeline must be described in the PDD and the Project Proponent should:
[/R-4WQ8-0]In accordance with the Isometric Standard, Project Proponents must demonstrate active stakeholder engagement throughout project planning and operation, ensuring that all risk mitigation strategies contribute to sustainable project outcomes. Local stakeholders may contribute an in-depth understanding of the project area and operations, and provide invaluable insights and recommendations on potential risks, necessary safeguards and specific monitoring needs. Engaging local stakeholders in reforestation projects creates community buy-in, providing long term commitment and investment in the success of reforestation projects21,1317. Furthermore, lack of community support, stakeholder engagement, and perceived community benefits has been identified as a primary source of project failure in previous forestry projects22.
The Project Proponent must develop a Stakeholder Engagement Plan in accordance with the requirements outlined in the Isometric Standard. The plan and supporting documentation, including evidence of meetings or other forms of engagement, must be submitted in the PDD.
[/G-YKQ9-0]Prior to the commencement of project activities, Project Proponents are required to assess if Indigenous Peoples will be impacted by project activities, and state when it was completed relative to the start of project activities. Impacts may include, but are not limited to:
[/R-7NT0-Identifying Indigenous Peoples. For the purposes of this Protocol, Indigenous Peoples are distinct social and cultural groups possessing the following characteristics in varying degrees:
Self-identification is a fundamental criterion, and recognition by the state is not required. This includes groups that have lost collective attachment to distinct habitats or ancestral territories within the lifetime of their members as a result of forced severance, conflict, resettlement or dispossession23,24.
Assessor. The assessment must be carried out by a party with demonstrated expertise in the rights of Indigenous Peoples or in social safeguards, approved by Isometric before the assessment begins. The assessor must provide a signed declaration that they have no current conflict of interest with the Project Proponent or its affiliates, including employment, contracts, financial interests or organizational relationships.
[/G-MT9J-1]Method. The assessment must include a reputabledesk thirdreview partyof whether Indigenous Peoples are present in, or subjectuse matterlands, expertterritories toor assessresources ifin or near, the project area. Sources may include national and regional data on Indigenous Peoples, land claims and demarcations, ethnographic literature, and information from Indigenous Peoples’ organizations. Where the desk review indicates that Indigenous Peoples may be present or affected, the assessor must verify this in the field, including through engagement with the potentially affected groups and their representative institutions. The assessment report must set out the method, sources and reasoning, and must be included in the PDD. A finding that Indigenous Peoples will not be impacted must be supported by the same standard of evidence as a finding that they will.
Where the assessment was completed after project activities began, projects must disclose the dates on which activities began and the assessment was completed, show that the assessment was completed before Validation (or before first Verification for a Project Area added after Validation), and, where it finds that Indigenous Peoples are affected, meet the requirements for Projects that initiated activities without FPIC.
Timing. The assessment must be completed before project activities begin. Where project activities began before the assessment was completed, it must be completed before Validation or, for a Project Area added after Validation, before its first Verification, and the PDD must disclose the dates on which activities began and the assessment was completed. If the assessment finds that Indigenous Peoples are affected, the requirements for Projects that initiated activities without FPIC (Section 6.5.1.2) apply.
[/G-GP9H-0]Validation. At Validation, the VVB must review the assessment, including its method and findings, and check its findings in the field.
Project Proponents must consult a reputable third party or subject matter expert to assess if Indigenous Peoples will be impacted by project activities.
The results of this report must be included in the PDD. If the report identifies potentialthat impactsproject toactivities may affect the lands, territories or resources of Indigenous Peoples, the Project Proponent must enact a Stakeholder Engagement Plan consistent with the principles of Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC) as outlined by the United Nations (UN) Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples2325 in 2007 and expanded upon by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations in 20162426.
[/G-FRWHSJA8-0, Projects must confirm that no payments, gifts or benefits were offered conditional on support for the Project or before disclosure and deliberation began, that benefits are available regardless of individual positions, and that access to independent (including legal) advice was not restricted.]
[G-8F57-1, Projects must provide a timeline showing that engagement began early enough to influence project design, that the schedule was circulated with enough notice, and that consent was obtained before (1) any commitment of land, (2) any physical activity affecting land use, and (3) finalisation of project boundaries and the planting plan.]Prior: Engagement ismust soughtbegin early enough in project development for stakeholder input to influence project design, and the earlystakeholder stagesengagement schedule must be circulated with enough notice for stakeholders to take part. Where FPIC is required, consent must be obtained before any of the following that affect the lands, territories or resources of the affected Indigenous Peoples or local communities:[/G-8F57-1]
Desk-based scoping and feasibility studies, the engagement process itself, and non-intrusive surveys carried out with the community’s permission (e.g., soil sampling or biomass plots) may take place before commencement of project activities. Consent must be sought as part of project development, regardless of local requirementsconsent. The timelinetime for the decision making and deliberation periods is set inby consultationthe withaffected all stakeholder groups and iscommunities, informed by customary, local, and/or traditional practices.
[G-D75X-0, Projects must provide copies of the information disclosed to each group whose FPIC is required, covering (1) modeled issuance and an indicative Certificate value, (2) the group's share of revenue or benefits and its basis, (3) project income and expenditure by category, (4) alternative land-use scenarios and trade-offs, (5) effects on production, resource access and livelihoods, and (6) commitment duration, obligations, main risks and the consequences of withdrawing consent.]Informed: Information ismust be presented in a mannerlanguage, thatformat isand setting accessible to alleach stakeholder groups. Accessible content may differ across stakeholder groups. The Project Proponentgroup, must consider in the information sharing process the language and medium of communication. For example, if information is presented electronically, stakeholders must have access to and familiarity with the necessary technology to review the information. If information is presented during in-person meetings, the meetings must be held at a time and in a location that is conducive to stakeholder attendance. Information presented to stakeholders must be objective and present trade-offs fairly and accurately. Finally, informationand must be provided on an ongoing basis. The following duemust diligencebe disclosed to each group whose FPIC is strongly recommended to ensure stakeholder groups are well informed of project development and outcomesrequired:
[/G-D75X-0]
Groups onengaged through informed participation must be told about the Project once the Crediting Period nears an end, soits thatmain they can better commitrisks to conservation and upholding the contract.]Stakeholders should be aware of the value of the timber on the Project once the Crediting Period nears an endthem, soany thatbenefits theyproposed canfor better commit to conservation and upholding the contract.[/G-YCB5-0]
Consent: Must be freely given through the community’s own representative institutions and maydecision-making beprocesses, withdrawn. Consentand may be conditional upon milestones in project development or the emergence of new information. Stakeholder consentConsent is not guaranteed as a result of the Stakeholder Input Process.
If required, the stakeholder engagement process must be enacted early in the Project development process, prior to the initiation of project activities. The stakeholder engagement schedule must be circulated prior to project initiation, and with enough notice to engage stakeholders in the planning processes.
In some instances, Project Proponents that initiated project activities prior to engaging with Isometric and did not engage Indigenous Peoples stakeholders under the principles of FPIC may still be eligible for crediting under this Protocol, in consultation with Isometric, by demonstrating how stakeholder engagement will be incorporated into future project planning.
The following may serve as burdens of proof that the Stakeholder Input Process conforms with the principlesEvidence of FPIC. The Project Proponent must indicateprovide howat these steps inleast the stakeholderfollowing engagement process were or will be carried out during the Project lifetime. Multiple rounds of stakeholder engagement may take place during a project lifetime, as needed. The Project Proponent may identify other burdens of proof demonstrating that the principles of FPIC have been observed and submit themevidence in the PDD, inand additionmay provide additional evidence. Evidence must relate to steps completed before Validation, orexcept insteadfor of,the thoseplan below,for inongoing consultation with Isometric.engagement:
Verification of stakeholder engagement. At Validation, where FPIC or informed participation is required, the VVB must interview a sample of members of each identified stakeholder group, including women, youth, marginalised subgroups and non-owner users. Interviews must be conducted without the Project designProponent present, using interpreters independent of the Project Proponent where interpretation is needed. The sampling approach and findings must be documented in the Validation report.
At subsequent Verifications, the VVB must conduct such interviews where:
TheIn all other cases, the VVB may conduct random surveysinterviews or interviewssurveys with stakeholder groups, and/or may witness some or allany of the processes described abovein this section.
Where the Indigenous Peoples assessment identifies that project activities may affect the lands, territories or resources of Indigenous Peoples, where the environmental and social risk assessment (Section 6.1) identifies potential negative impacts on local communities, or where displacement is required, the Project must not proceed without the Free, Prior and Informed Consent of the affected Indigenous Peoples or local communities. That consent must be obtained in accordance with the principles and evidence requirements of this section, through the communities’ own representative institutions and decision-making processes.
[/R-1RWR-0]All other stakeholders and local communities withinidentified by the project area.]
Project ProponentsProponent that do not identify Indigenous Peoples that willmust be affectedengaged bythrough informed participation: disclosure of project activitiesinformation arein encouragedan toaccessible considerlanguage ifand otherformat, relevant stakeholders relyconsultation on land or resources located within the project areadesign and risks, and engageaccess them followingto the principlesProject’s ofgrievance FPICmechanism, described above. All stakeholder groups and local communities have valuable and unique perspectives on developmentsdocumented in the project area, which can contribute to project successPDD.
Individual or household agreements with enrolled landowners or other participants do not replace the consent of affected Indigenous Peoples or local communities, and must be consistent with any collective consent decision.
[/G-J8JY-0]The following information from the stakeholder engagement process must be made publicly available, with personal information anonymized or redacted to protect stakeholders, project personnel, and project outcomes. This may include:
Information may be redacted only where it is personal information about individuals, or where the affected community has asked for it to be kept confidential (e.g., the locations of cultural or sacred sites). Any redaction must be noted in the published version, and unredacted versions must be made available to the VVB and Isometric.
Where the Project Proponent enrolls land held by other parties, the Project Proponent must, before any agreement is signed, disclose the following to each enrolled landowner and ensure that they understand it:
[/R-NDRD-0]Copies of the disclosure materials, and a signed acknowledgement or other record of understanding from each enrolled landowner, in a form accessible to them, must be provided in the PDD.
Where project activities were initiated before Free, Prior and Informed Consent was obtained from Indigenous Peoples whose lands, territories or resources are affected by the Project, as identified under the assessment above, the affected Project Areas may only become eligible for crediting where all of the following are met. These must be met before Validation or, for a Project Area added after Validation, before its first Verification:
[/R-92M2-0]If consent is withheld, or harm identified in the assessment cannot be remedied, the affected Project Areas, or the parts of them on the affected lands, territories or resources, are not eligible for crediting. Where the whole Project is affected, the Project is not eligible.
Where consent is obtained, Certificates may only be issued for removals occurring after the date of consent. For the purposes of Section 9.2, the start date of each affected Project Area is the date of consent, and the dynamic baseline (Section 9.5) is assessed from that date.
[/G-PS7G-0]FPIC gaps identified after issuance. Where it is identified after Certificates have been issued that FPIC was required but not obtained, issuance for the affected Project Areas is suspended until the criteria above are met, and crediting only resumes if and when consent is obtained. Certificates already issued are not affected, unless the gap resulted from misrepresentation or a failure to disclose information, in which case the non-conformity provisions of the Isometric Standard apply.
The Project Proponent must identify and develop processes for the protection and promotion of community well-being in the PDD, as follows:
[/R-VANN-0][G-0MNE-01, Projects must provide copies of policies prohibiting discrimination on the grounds listed in the Protocol, describe how they are communicated and applied to staff, contractors and implementation partners and how breaches can be reported, and confirm that any incidents of discrimination or other human rights concerns, and the responses, will be reported at each Verification.]The Project Proponent must have policies and practices that prohibit discrimination on the basis of race, color, ethnicity, Indigenous status, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, age, disability, language, religion or belief, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status. The PDD must include: [/G-0MNE-1]
[G-M9H3-1, Projects must describe how theythe protectgrievance humanmechanism rightsmeets this Protocol's additional criteria: agreed with affected communities; free; accessible in local languages through multiple channels, including policiesanonymously; confidential and practicesnon-retaliatory; upholdingdoes anti-discriminationnot onbar judicial or customary remedies; allows escalation at any time to an independent third party; logs each grievance; and operates for the basiswhole Project Commitment Period; and confirm a summary of genderthe grievance log will be reported at each Verification.]The Project Proponent must establish a grievance mechanism, sexualagreed orientationwith affected communities, etcand describe it in the PDD.]Protection ofThe humanmechanism rightsmust: [/G-0MNEM9H3-01]
The PDD must also describe the role of the independent third party (mediation, adjudication, or both), how it was selected, how its decisions or recommendations will be implemented, and whether it will periodically review or audit the grievance process. At each Verification, the Project Proponent acceptsmust grievances,report feedbacka summary of the grievance log, and complaints.the ThisVVB must alsoreview includea sample of grievances and their handling. The absence of grievances is not by itself evidence that the mediationmechanism is effective. Isometric and resolutionthe process.VVB Project Proponents must consult a third party to address grievances.]Grievances, feedback, and complaints:[/G-M9H3-0]
Employment and resolution process for grievances and complaints.
Safeguarding of children. Where stakeholder engagement, Verification interviews or project activities involve people under 18, the Project Proponent must have safeguarding procedures in place, including:
[G-Y2YT-0, Conditional: Where stakeholder engagement, Verification interviews or project activities involve people under 18, projects must describe child safeguarding procedures, including parent or guardian consent and child assent, appropriate settings with a trusted adult present, and child safeguarding training for staff and contractors.]These procedures must be described in the PDD.[/G-Y2YT-0]
As previously mentioned, community buy-in is critical to the success of a reforestation project 21,1317,22. Community buy-in may be established when stakeholders are properly informed about the benefits they can expect from the reforestation project. Equally important in maintaining buy-in is for the positive impacts resulting from the Project to match the (perception of) potential benefits presented to community stakeholders at the Project onset. A mismatch in benefits expected and benefits realized may similarly hinder project success.
While this Protocol will not prescribe requirements for community impacts, the Project Proponent is strongly encouraged to consider establishing the following programs and activities:
Positive impacts should be felt by all stakeholder groups identified in Section 6.5.1. Project Proponents should consider which groups may face the brunt of negative community impacts, and how positive community benefits may be shared equitably with these and other marginalized groups.
It is recommended that the Project Proponent provide support to the local communities and ecosystems to establish region specific mitigation strategies to adapt to changing climates.
The Project must not cause significant harm to the quantity or quality of local water resources. Even in ecosystems that previously held forest cover, restoration of forest ecosystems can alter the hydrological balance in ways that can be detrimental to surrounding communities if there are pre-existing strains on water resources. For the purposes of this Protocol, a significant risk of harm exists where the assessments below identify a risk to water quantity or water quality. Where they do, the Project Proponent must provide a plan to limit and monitor the impacts, as set out below.
[/R-EZHA-0]Project Proponents must assess whether the Project is occurring in an area that already has existing risks to its water supply as a result of the combination of water supply and demand.
WithinFor the purposes of this Protocol, we define these areas of elevated water risk to beare basins which have been categorized as “High” or “Extremely High” Baseline Annual Physical Risk for Water Quantity by the Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas.
If the Project is occurring in an area with existing elevated water risk per the above criteria, the Project Proponent must assess whether reforestation in the project area is projected to have a negative impact on water supply. The Project Proponent must identify if the project area lies in areas at risk of >1% decrease in water availability due to reforestation as described by Hoek van DiejkeDijke et al. (2022)2527. In regards to these analyses and for the purposes of this Protocol, reforestation presents a risk to water supplies if it is projected to decrease annual water yield by more than 1%, inclusive of any evaporative recycling effects.
If the Project is occurring in an area with both elevated water risk and where reforestation is anticipated to decrease local water yields per the above definitions, Project Proponents must describe in the PDD how their project implementation and management plans are designed to limit hydrological impacts and include provisions for monitoring any adverse effects on local water resources.
These plans could include, but are not limited to:
[/G-The Project Proponent must identify any risks to water quality arising from project activities, including site preparation, the use of chemical amendments (see Section 6.7), and any drainage of land (see Section 4.1). The Project Proponent must describe in the PDD the measures used to manage these risks, such as buffers along watercourses, erosion and sediment control, and best management practices for chemical use. Where a significant risk to water quality is identified, the Project Proponent must include provisions for monitoring water quality in the plan.
[/G-5CP4-0]Projects must identify risks to water quality from project activities, including site preparation, chemical use and drainage, describe the measures used to manage them, and include monitoring provisions where a significant risk is identified.
Project
Any use of synthetic herbicides or fertilizers must be reported to Isometric and adhere to best management practices (BMPs) as well as all local, state/provincial, and national laws and regulations regarding their use. Any planned use for project establishment at project initiation or project operations must be reported in the PDD.
[/Projects should not use synthetic pesticides except for the control of non-native pests and/or invasive insect outbreaks.
Any such use of synthetic pesticides must be targeted and limited in scope towards the targeted pest(s) or insect(s), and be thoroughly justified and reported immediately to Isometric.
Further, any such use must adhere to BMPs as well as all local, state/provincial, and national laws and regulations regarding their use. Any planned use for project establishment at project initiation must be reported in the PDD.
[/G-Additionally, Project Proponents must adherenot touse any chemical pesticide listed as prohibited on the Forest Stewardship Council’s Lists of Highly Hazardous Pesticides (FSC-POL-30-001a). Compliance with the wider FSC Pesticides Policy is recommended.
TheHerbicides, pesticides and fertilizers may be used where they follow best management practices and all associated emissions associated with any use of synthetic herbicides, fertilizers, and pesticides must beare accounted for in line with the emissions accounting requirements of(see Section 9.56). Fertilizer products and application practices disclosed in the PDD may continue to be used in subsequent planting cycles, provided their use is reported consistently at each Verification.
The following topics are covered briefly in this Protocol due to their inclusion in the Isometric Standard, which governs all Isometric Protocols. See in-text references to the Isometric Standard for further guidance.
For each specific Project to be evaluated under this Protocol, the Project Proponent must document project characteristics in a Project Design Document (PDD) as outlined in the Isometric Standard. The PDD will form the basis for project Validation and evaluation in accordance with this Protocol.
Projects must be validated and net CO2e removals verified by an independent third party, consistent with the requirements described in this Protocol, as well as in the Isometric Standard.
The Validation and Verification Body (VVB) must consider the following requisite components:
As part of this evaluation, the VVB must also review the characterization and quantification of all individual uncertainty sources within the listed components that contribute to the calculation of net CO2e removal.
The threshold for Materiality, considering the totality of all omissions, errors and misstatements, is 5%, in accordance with the Isometric Standard.
Verifiers should also verify the documentation of uncertainty of the GHG Statement as required by the Isometric Standard. Qualitative Materiality issues may also be identified and documented, such as:
Project Validation and Verification must incorporate site visits to project facilities, namely in situ field plots, in accordance with the requirements of ISO 14064-3, 6.1.4.2. This is to include, at a minimum, site visits to the Project site during Validation and initial Verification. Validators should, whenever possible, observe project operations to ensure full documentation of process inputs and outputs through visual observation (see the Isometric Standard).
Additional site visits may be required if there are substantial changes to field operations over the course of Validation, or if deemed necessary by Isometric or the VVB. Site visit plans are to be determined according to the VVB’s internal assessment, in consultation with Isometric.
Verifiers and Validators must comply with the requirements defined in the Isometric Standard. In addition, verification teams must maintain and demonstrate expertise associated with the specific technologies of reforestation and forest management, including both forest field measurements and Earth System remote sensing data processing and analysis.
Verification teams must also demonstrate competence in assessing stakeholder engagement processes, including Free, Prior and Informed Consent.
CDR via reforestation is a result of a multi-step process (e.g., seed planting, forest maintenance, monitoring), with activities in each step potentially managed by a different operator, company, or owner. A single Project Proponent must be specified contractually as the sole owner of the Certificates when there are multiple parties involved in the process, and to avoid Double Counting of net CO₂e removals.
For Contractsthe purposes of the ownership requirements in the Isometric Standard, the Project participants with whom ownership must comply with all requirementsbe defined in contracts are:
Contracts with these entities must meet the ownership requirements of the Isometric Standard. The Project Proponent must identify these entities in the PDD, and the VVB must review this at Validation.
[/G-S1HS-0]Where the Project Proponent, or an affiliate of the Project Proponent, holds explicit contractual ownership of all credited removals, contracts with suppliers of goods and services (e.g., nurseries, transport providers) and implementation partners are not required to include these ownership terms. Such entities generally do not have a reasonable claim to the removals. They provide goods or services that serve many purposes beyond the Project, and they hold no rights to the land or the resulting carbon stocks.
The Project Proponent must be able to demonstrate additionality through compliance with the Isometric Standard. The Baseline scenario and Counterfactual utilized to assess additionality must be project-specific and comply with Section 9.45 of this Protocol.
Government subsidies or civil contractual obligations for reforestation, such as organization bylaws, inhibit additionality and fall under the Regulatory criteria in the Isometric Standard. Additionality is assessed each Reporting Period using dynamic baselining as outlined in Section 9.45.
Additionality determinations should also be reviewed and completed at everythe next Verification at a minimum, or whenever project operating conditions change significantly, such as the following:
All financialsprojects indicatemust demonstrate the necessity of Carbon Finance isfor noproject longerviability required to operatefollowing the ProjectIsometric Standard. If revenue will be produced from sources other than Removals, potentiallysuch dueas to,the for example:
If a review indicates the Project has become non-additional, the Project will be ineligible for future Certificates. Current or past Crediting Periods will not be affected.
The Project Proponent must be able to demonstrate additionality through compliance with the Isometric Standard. The Baseline scenario and Counterfactual utilized to assess additionality must be project-specific and comply with Section 9.5 of this Protocol.
Government subsidies or civil contractual obligations for reforestation, such as organization bylaws, inhibit additionality and fall under the Regulatory criteria in the Isometric Standard.
Additionality is assessed as follows:
All projects must demonstrate the necessity of Carbon Finance for project viability following the Isometric Standard. If revenue will be produced from sources other than Removals, such as the sale of non-timber co-products or timber from selective harvesting, additional requirements for demonstrating financial additionality are described in the Isometric Standard.
If a review of regulatory or financial additionality indicates the Project has become non-additional, the Project will not be eligible for further Certificates. Where the dynamic baseline test is not met at a Verification, only that Reporting Period is affected . Certificates already issued are not affected.
The following steps must be taken to demonstrate that without Carbon Finance the project activity is not Common Practice, in accordance with the requirements defined in the Isometric Standard.
Survey-based approach:
Calculate the cumulative market penetration rate (as an areal percentage) of the project activity by landowners who have not received Carbon Finance revenue (e.g., are neither part of a registered Isometric Project, nor registered under other GHG programs) in the sample of adopters.
Data from existing literature: Statistics on ARR activities derived from data collected within the five years ofbefore the Project start date may be used for this demonstration, provided they are relevant to the project area, do not distinguish between activities incentivized by and not incentivized by carbon finance (thus are conservative), and are publicly available as:
In regions where there is established government data on rates of ARR activity (e.g., national forest inventories or official land use statistics), the official data must be used for assessing market penetration rates.
[/G-P36M-0]In accordance with the Isometric Standard, the proposed project activity is considered to demonstrate Common Practice additionality where the market penetration rate is below or equal to 20%.
The uncertainty in the overall estimate of the net CO2e removal as a result of the Project must be accounted for. The total net CO2e removed for a specific Reporting Period, [math: RP], [math: {CO}_{2}^{}e_{Removal, RP}^{}], must be conservatively determined in accordance with the requirements outlined in the Isometric Standard.
Projects must report a list of all key variables used in the net CO2e removal calculation and their individual uncertainties, as well as a description of the uncertainty analysis approach, including:
The uncertainty information should at least include the minimum and maximum values of each individual variable. More detailed uncertainty information should be provided if available, as outlined in the Isometric Standard.
In addition, a sensitivity analysis that demonstrates the impact of each input parameter’s uncertainty on the final net CO2e uncertainty must be provided. Details of the sensitivity analysis method must be provided such that a third party can reproduce the results. Input variables may be omitted from an uncertainty analysis if they contribute to a < 1% change in the net CO2e removal. For all other parameters, information about uncertainty must be specified.
In accordance with the Isometric Standard, all evidence and data related to the underlying quantification of CO₂e removal and environmental and social safeguards monitoring will be available to the public through the Isometric platform. That includes:
The Project Proponent can request certain information to be restricted (only available to authorized Buyers, the Registry, and VVB) where it is subject to confidentiality. This includes emission factors, specific data, and/or proprietary models from licensed databases. However, all other numerical data produced or used as part of the quantification of net CO2e removal will be made available.
Personal information about landowners, stakeholders or other individuals, including names, contact details, identification numbers, tax records and contracts, must not be made public. Geospatial and carbon stock data for the project area must be published without information that links land parcels to identified individuals. Information that affected communities have asked to keep confidential, including the locations of cultural or sacred sites, may be restricted. Restricted and redacted information must remain available to the VVB and Isometric.
The Project Proponent must comply with all applicable data protection laws, including national and local laws in the jurisdiction where the Project is located. Personal data must be collected only with the consent of the individuals concerned, used only for the purposes disclosed to them, and stored securely.
[/R-WQFQ-0]The scope of this Protocol includes GHG sources, sinks and reservoirs (SSRs) associated with a reforestation project.
A cradle-to-grave GHG Statement must be prepared encompassing the GHG emissions relating to the activities outlined within the system boundary.
GHG emissions and removals associated with The Project may be direct emissions from a process, or indirect emissions from combustion of fuels, electricity generation, or other sources. Emissions must include all GHG SSRs within the system boundary, from the construction or manufacturing of each physical site and associated equipment, closure and disposal of each site and associated equipment, and operation of each process, including embodied emissions of equipment and consumables used in the project. The Project Proponent is responsible for identifying all sources of emissions directly or indirectly related to project activities.
Any emissions from sub-processes or process changes that would not have taken place without the Project, and any activity that ultimately leads to the issuance of Certificates, must be considered in the system boundary. This allows for accurate consideration of additional, incremental emissions induced by the Project.
The system boundary must include all SSRs controlled by, and related to, the Project, including but not limited to the SSRs in Table 1.
[/R-2VKW-2]If any GHG SSRs within Table 1 are deemed not appropriate to include in the system boundary, they may be excluded, provided that robust justification and appropriate evidence is included in the PDD.
[/G-CPDE-0]Table 1. Scope of activities and GHG SSRs to be included in the system boundary.
Activity | GHG Source, sink or Reservoir | GHG | Scope | Timescale of emissions and accounting allocation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Project Establishment | Equipment and materials | All GHGs | Embodied emissions associated with equipment and materials manufacture related to project establishment (lifecycle Modules A1-326). This must include product manufacture emissions for:
| Before project operations start - must be accounted for in the first Reporting Period or amortized in line with allocation rules (see Section 9. |
Equipment and materials transport to site | All GHGs | Transport emissions associated with transporting materials, equipment and seedlings to the Project site(s) (lifecycle Module A426). | ||
Planting and installation | All GHGs | Emissions
Projects should limit soil | ||
Misc. | All GHGs | Any SSRs not captured by categories above (e.g., staff travel). | ||
Operations | Fertilizer use (Direct) | N2O | Direct emissions related to the use of nitrogen-based fertilizers. | Over each Reporting Period - must be accounted for in the relevant Reporting Period (see Section 9. |
Forest management | All GHGs | Emissions related to forest management activities (e.g., pruning, weeding, pest control, biomass burning and watering). This must include embodied emissions of equipment, as well as consumables such as water, fertilizers and pesticides. | ||
Maintenance | All GHGs | Maintenance of the project area, including any repair or replacement of equipment, vehicles, buildings and infrastructure. | ||
All GHGs | Emissions related to MRV activities (e.g., measurements, sampling, or commissioning LiDAR flights). | |||
CO2 stored | CO2 | The gross amount of CO2 removed and durably stored in living aboveground woody biomass and belowground woody biomass, and in soil organic carbon and deadwood where the Project includes these optional pools (see Section 9.3). | ||
Leakage mitigation emissions | All GHGs | Emissions associated with leakage mitigation in Leakage Mitigation Site(s) (see Section 8.3.4). Where a Leakage Mitigation Site is shared, emissions are allocated as set out in Section 8.3.3.3. | ||
Misc. | All GHGs | Any SSRs not captured by categories above (e.g., staff travel). | ||
CO₂ stored in deadwood (optional) | CO₂ | The net change in carbon stored in deadwood, where the Project Proponent elects to quantify this pool, in accordance with the applicable deadwood quantification Module (see Section 9.2). | ||
CO₂ stored in soil organic carbon (optional) | CO₂ | The net change in carbon stored in soil organic carbon, where the Project Proponent elects to quantify this pool, in accordance with the Forest Soil Organic Carbon Quantification Module. Applies to aerobic soils only (see Section 4.1). | ||
End-of-Life | Ongoing Monitoring | All GHGs | Emissions relating to monitoring activities | After |
Ongoing Forest management | All GHGs | Emissions relating to ongoing project management activities | ||
Misc. | All GHGs | Any SSRs not captured by categories above (e.g., ongoing staff travel). |
Miscellaneous GHG emissions are those that cannot be categorized by the GHG SSR categories provided in Table 1. The Project Proponent is responsible for identifying all sources of emissions directly or indirectly related to project activities and must report any outside of the SSR categories identified as miscellaneous emissions.
[/G-0B93-0]Emissions associated with The Project's impact on activities that fall outside of the system boundary of The Project must also be considered. This is covered under Leakage in Section 8.3.
In line with the GHG Accounting Module v1.1, the Project must:
The Baseline scenario for reforestation assumes that the activities associated with the Project do not take place and that any infrastructure associated with the Project is not built.
The Counterfactual is the CO2 stored that would have occurred due to natural regeneration over the Crediting Period in the absence of the Project. This Protocol uses a dynamic baseline approach to quantify the Counterfactual. This is detailed in Section 9.4.45.
Leakage emissions, [math: CO_2e_{Leakage}], occur when project activities lead to emissions that occur outside the system boundary of reforestation projects. They include increases in GHG emissions as a result of reforestation projects displacing emissions or causing a secondary effect that increases emissions elsewhere. Three key types of leakage can occur for reforestation projects:
Project activities that adversely alter the water table, harming ecological integrity within the project area and surrounding landscape and watershed, are not permitted under this Protocol. Section 6.6 requires assessment of whether the Project presents a risk to water resources, and requires mitigation and management plans be put in place if risks are present making adverse hydrological impacts unlikely. Furthermore, this Protocol limits reforestation to landscapes that were historically forests. Therefore, it is unlikely that surrounding landscapes sensitive to hydrological dynamics that were not present at the time the site was historically forested would have been established since deforestation. Assessing wider ecological leakage impacts is complex. For this version of the Protocol, ecological leakage is assumed to be zero. This will be revisited in future updates to the Protocol.
ActivityAssessments of Project Site productivity and associated activity-shifting and market leakage considerations are addressed in this Protocol. Market leakage emissions, [math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}], are quantified with the Market Leakage Module, using the unmitigated Pre-Project Productivity from Equation 2 as displaced productivity (Section 8.3.5). [math: CO_2e_{Leakage,RP}] is the sum of [math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}] and the activity-shifting leakage adjustment from Section 8.3.7 (Equation 17a, Section 9.6.4). The overall process for addressing activity-shifting and market leakage is set out in the flowchart in Figure 2..
[Image: Figure 2 Leakage assessment flow chart]
Figure 2 Flowchart of process for addressing activity-shifting and market leakage.
The flowchart is based on the following principles:
This means that the increase in production should be limited to the same commodity class as defined in Appendix A, but this decision should be informed by the Direct Actors, and production across commodity classes may be permitted, subject to Isometric review, when it can be demonstrated that the new commodity satisfies the same needs of the community as the displaced commodity. This also likely means that the Leakage Mitigation Site should be in the same locality, but again, this should be informed by the Direct Actors. The Project Proponent should engage with Direct Actors associated with the site’s prior productivity to understand how the project activity impacted the previous users of the Project site. Direct Actors include the previous site owners, tenants or other users that engaged with the Project site in a way that produced commodities.
Implementation of the flowchart in Figure 2 requires an understanding of Pre-Project Productivity, [math: PPP], including pre-project information about Direct Actors and how the commodity was used. Direct Actors are defined as site owners, tenants or other users that engaged with the Project site in a way that produced commodities before the project activities commenced.
The information required is set out below:
[math: PPP] is defined as the annual productivity of a commodity type at the Project site in relevanttonnes unitsper (e.g.year for crops, tonnes/on yr).the Thisbasis shouldrequired beby anthe averageMarket Leakage Module and converted using the moisture content of the threecommodity yearsas priorsold, toand thehead projectfor activities startinglivestock. For crops, this shouldmust be reflectivethe average of the last three complete annual crop cycles before project activities started. For livestock, this shouldmust be reflective of the maximum cattleherd inventory over the last three years of production before project activities started. MAP for the same commodity must be expressed in the same metric and units (Section 8.3.3). For all other commodities, this shouldmust be reflectivethe ofaverage annual production over the last three years of production.
The data hierarchy for obtaining information for [math: PPP] is set out below:
The hierarchy must be followed and data choices evidenced. For example, if land registry data is used, sufficient evidence of no available farm records will be required. Sufficient evidence may include, but is not limited to, official government statements, reports, or affidavits and/or written sworn statements or affidavits by Direct Actors regarding the lack of records.
[/G-WT1R-As part of determination of [math: PPP], the Project Proponent must confirm the following:
[/R-KG5W-0]The following considerations and assumptions should be made when determining the type of commodity, [math: c]:
Productivity must be reflective of anthe average of the three years prior to the project activities starting or, for livestock, the maximum herd inventory over those three years.
The following considerations and assumptions should be made when determining productivity:
The Project Proponent must determine the previous use of the commodity and whether it was:
The Project Proponent must determine this using the following information:
[/G-W999-1]If it is not possible to determine whether the commodity was for subsistence or commercial use, then the Project Proponent must assume it was subsistence.
If the Project determines that [math: PPP] is zero, this must be evidenced appropriately. This includes:
Evidence must be provided for three years preceding the Project Proponent’s purchase of the site for reforestation, or the Project start date, whichever is earlier.
[/G-3K0K-0]In addition, Isometric will undertake remote sensing analysis on project sites which claim that [math: PPP] is zero. Remote sensing mapping will be transparently displayed on the registry. Only where remote sensing analysis indicates there are no signs of agricultural production, pasture, or timber harvesting will the Project be eligible for claiming zero [math: PPP].
[math: CO_2e_{Leakage}] is part of the calculation of [math: CO_2e_{Emissions}], as set out in Equation 20 in Section 9.5.
[math: CO_2e_{Leakage}] is quantified with the following equation:
[math: CO_2e_{Leakage}\; =\; CO_2e_{Market\; Leakage}\; +\; CO_2e_{Activity-shifting\;Leakage\:Adjustment}\; +\; CO_2e_{Leakage\; Mitigation\; Emissions}]
(Equation 1)
Where:
[math: CO_2e_{Leakage}] is quantified for every Reporting Period, however the following should be noted:
The aim of leakage mitigation activities is to reduce the amount of leakage by increasing production of the commodity elsewhere. Leakage mitigation must take place in areas called Leakage Mitigation Sites. These must be separate to the Project site, but may be directly adjacent.
[/G-Q7W8-0]Leakage mitigation activities should be equal to or greater than the expected displacement of production. The efficacy of mitigation will be assessed and appropriate deductions applied in the event that mitigation activities do not match the level of displacement (see Equation 2).
The following equation is used to calculate the effectiveness of leakage mitigation:
[math: uPPP_c = max(PPP_c - MAP_c, 0)]
(Equation 2)
Where:
When [math: PPPPPP_c] is 0 for all commodities, c, the Project had zero productivity.
When [math: PPPPPP_c] is >> 0 and [math: uPPPuPPP_c] is 0, the Project has achieved full leakage mitigation and does not take a market leakage emissions deduction.
When [math: PPPPPP_c] is >> 0 and [math: uPPPuPPP_c] is >> 0, the Project takes a market leakage emissions deduction.
[math: MAP] (mitigation area productivity) must be quantified ex-post at each Verification and must reflect a sustained increase in productive capacity at the Leakage Mitigation Site.
[/R-CCF9-0]Annual productivity at the [math: LMS] must be recorded for every complete year since the [math: LMS] contract started, and the annual increase above the baseline must be calculated with Equation 3. [math: MAP] is the lower of the average annual increase over the most recent five complete years and the average over the most recent two complete years (Equation 5), counting only contract years that end within the five-year window after the Displacement Event (Section 8.3.3). Where fewer complete years are available, all available years are used. [math: MAP] is floored at zero, so a fall in productivity at the [math: LMS] below its grown baseline does not increase displaced productivity above [math: PPP_c].
For livestock, annual productivity is the herd inventory at the same census date each year. Increases from higher offtake, culling or herd liquidation must not count towards [math: MAP]. The baseline, [math: P_{LMS,base}], is the three-year average productivity of the [math: LMS] before the [math: LMS] contract started. It is grown at the regional growth rate, g, which is calculated once at the [math: LMS] contract start using Equation 4 and held fixed. g must use regional commodity-specific yield data where available, otherwise national commodity-specific data (e.g., FAOSTAT).
[/G-2KKC-0]Where the [math: LMS] had no production before the contract, [math: P_{LMS,base}] is zero. [math: MAP] must be expressed in the same metric and units as [math: PPP_c] for the displaced commodity.
[math: \Delta P_{LMS,y} = P_{LMS,y} - P_{LMS,base} \times (1+g)^{y}]
(Equation 3)
[math: g = \max\left( \left( \frac{Y_{c,t}}{Y_{c,t-x}} \right)^{1/x} - 1,\ 0 \right)]
(Equation 4)
[math: MAP_{LMS,RP} = \max\left( \min\left( \frac{1}{n} \sum_{y=N-n+1}^{N} \Delta P_{LMS,y},\ \frac{1}{m} \sum_{y=N-m+1}^{N} \Delta P_{LMS,y} \right),\ 0 \right), \quad n = \min(N,5),\ m = \min(N,2)]
(Equation 5)
Where:
Leakage mitigation requirements are different depending on whether mitigation is to address market leakage (see Section 8.3.3.2) or activity-shifting leakage (see Section 8.3.3.1). Activity-shifting leakage will also by nature address market leakage, however market leakage alone will not address activity-shifting leakage.
In addition to the leakage type specific requirements, all leakage mitigation activities must meet the following requirements:
[math: MAP] from a Leakage Mitigation Site may only be used to mitigate leakage from a Project, or from an instance of a Project under project expansion, for a maximum of five years after that Project's or instance's Displacement Event. [math: MAP] delivered after this five-year window must not be counted towards [math: MAP_c] in Equation 2 for that Project or instance.
[/R-29N7-0]Leakage mitigation is effective only when increased production at the Leakage Mitigation Site occurs close in time to the forgone production at the Project site. As the gap widens, the market adjusts to the displacement through prices, imports or land conversion elsewhere, and additional production no longer replaces what was lost. Five years is a maximum, and future versions of this Protocol may adjust this window based on further evidence on the timing of supply responses. The same five-year window applies whether mitigation comes before the Displacement Event (Section 8.3.3.3) or after it (Section 8.3.3.4).
If, at any Verification after [math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}] has been assessed and within the five-year window, MAP quantified with Equation 5 is lower than the [math: MAP_c] used in that assessment, the Project Proponent must recalculate [math: uPPP_c] and [math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}] with the lower MAP. The increase must be reported in that Reporting Period and is included as set out in the Market Leakage Module for increases in displaced productivity. [math: MAP_c] must not be revised upwards.
[/R-NYGW-0]For mitigation of activity-shifting leakage, the Project Proponent must have a full understanding of the information set out in Section 8.3.2.1: Determining Pre-Project Productivity.
The mitigation must be informed by the Direct Actors and be undertaken in agreement with Direct Actors.
[/G-D526-Mitigation activities must lead to new productivity or productivity increases that directly benefit the Direct Actors.
[/G-0SXV-0]This likely means that the increase in production should be limited to the same commodity typeclass as defined in Appendix A, but this decision should be informed by the Direct Actors.
This also likely means that the Leakage Mitigation Site should be in the same locality, but again, this should be informed by the Direct Actors.
The Project Proponent should engage with Direct Actors associated with the site’s prior productivity to understand how the project activity impacted the previous users of the Project site. Direct Actors include the previous site owners, tenants or other users that engaged with the Project site in a way that produced commodities.
The Project Proponent must receive an affidavit from the identified Direct Actors confirming the following:
[/G-FDCF-0]Full records of correspondence, including meeting notes, and signed agreements must be made available as part of the PDD.
[/G-PQ3S-0]If information from Direct Actors is unavailable, the Project Proponent will be unable to undertake activity-shifting leakage mitigation.
For mitigation of market leakage, the following must be true in addition to the requirements set out in Section 8.3.3:
A single Leakage Mitigation Site (LMS) may be used to mitigate leakage from more than one Project, or from more than one instance of a Project under project expansion, including instances with staggered start dates. Where an LMS is shared, it must meet the requirements in Section 8.3.3 and the requirements below. Where an LMS is shared, leakage mitigation emissions do not need to be allocated in full to the first Project or instance to be verified.
An LMS may be shared across instances of a Project under project expansion and across multiple Projects, provided all of them have the same Project Proponent. An LMS must not be shared between different Project Proponents. Each Project or instance drawing on the LMS must identify the LMS, and the other Projects and instances that use it, in its PDD.
[/R-52QZ-0]At the first Verification of the first Project or instance to draw on the LMS, the Project Proponent must conservatively estimate the total leakage mitigation emissions expected over the full term of the LMS contract. These include infrastructure, fuel, fertilizer and all other emissions sources listed in Section 8.3.4. The Project Proponent must then set a fixed allocation rate using Equation 6. The total LMS emissions and the allocation rate must be held fixed after the first Verification and must not be revised in later Reporting Periods, even if realized MAP differs from the estimate.
[/G-9XAP-0][math: EF_{LMS} = \frac{CO_2e_{LMS,total}}{MAP_{LMS,expected}}]
(Equation 6)
Where:
Leakage mitigation emissions must be allocated to each Project or instance in proportion to the MAP it draws from the LMS in each Reporting Period, using Equation 7 and the fixed allocation rate from Equation 6. The total MAP drawn by all Projects and instances in a Reporting Period must not exceed [math: MAP_{LMS,RP}]. Allocated emissions count towards that Project's or instance's [math: CO_2e_{Leakage Mitigation Emissions}] for the Reporting Period.
[math: CO_2e_{LMS,i,RP} = EF_{LMS} \times MAP_{i,RP} \times T_{RP}]
(Equation 7)
Where:
Each Project or instance must draw MAP from the shared LMS only within the five-year window set out in Section 8.3.3, measured from its own Displacement Event. A Project or instance may only start drawing on the LMS if its Displacement Event falls within five years of the LMS contract start date, and it must be added to the tracking record kept for the shared LMS at its first Verification. MAP must not be drawn from a shared LMS after the end of the LMS contract term.
[/G-XJ6B-0]On the earlier of the end of the LMS contract term and the close of the last five-year window of any Project or instance drawing on the LMS, the Project Proponent must compare the LMS emissions allocated to date with [math: CO_2e_{LMS, total}]. If any emissions remain unallocated, for example because realized MAP fell short of [math: MAP_{LMS,expected}], they must be reallocated across all Projects and instances that drew MAP from the LMS, using the recalculated rate in Equation 8a. The reallocated emissions must be added to each Project's or instance's next Reporting Period after the true-up. If a Project or instance stops drawing on the LMS before the true-up, its share of any unallocated emissions must be calculated with Equation 8a and 8b at that point and added to its next Reporting Period.
[math: EF_{TU} = \frac{CO_2e_{LMS,total} - \sum_{i}\sum_{RP} CO_2e_{LMS,i,RP}}{\sum_{i} MAP_{i,cum}}]
(Equation 8a)
[math: CO_2e_{TU,i} = EF_{TU} \times MAP_{i,cum}]
(Equation 8b)
Where:
The written landowner agreement and the landowner support required for all leakage mitigation activities (Section 8.3.3) apply in full to a shared LMS. For a shared LMS, the agreement must cover every year in which any Project or instance draws MAP from the LMS, and at least five years, and the Project Proponent must support the landowner for at least five years.
[/G-H720-0]The Project Proponent must keep a tracking record for each shared LMS covering all Projects and instances that draw on it. At minimum, the record must contain: [math: CO_2e_{LMS,total}], [math: EF_{LMS}], [math: MAP_{LMS,RP}] for each Reporting Period, MAP drawn and emissions allocated by each Project and instance, unallocated emissions, and the years elapsed since the LMS contract start and since each Displacement Event. The record must be submitted at each Verification.
Leakage mitigation may come before the Displacement Event, through a shared Leakage Mitigation Site (Section 8.3.3.3), or after it. This section sets out how market leakage is assessed when mitigation is still being established at the first Verification.
MAP realized after the Displacement Event counts towards MAPc only if it is realized within the five-year window after the Displacement Event set out in Section 8.3.3. The five-year window is the period to reach the mitigated level of productivity, not to begin mitigation activities.
Where market leakage mitigation will not be fully in place by the first Verification, the Project Proponent may defer the assessment of [math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}]. To defer, the PDD must include: each Leakage Mitigation Site; a signed written agreement with the landowner allowing the Project Proponent to uniquely claim the increases in productivity as leakage mitigation (Section 8.3.3), or a binding commitment to one; the planned mitigation activities; and a timeline showing the target MAP will be reached within five years of the Displacement Event. The VVB must assess the plan as credible at validation.
[/R-X886-0]Where the assessment is deferred, [math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}] must be quantified as set out in Section 8.3.5 at the earlier of: (a) a Verification nominated by the Project Proponent, and (b) the first Verification on or after five years from the Displacement Event. [math: MAP_c] is the MAP quantified with Equation 5 at that Verification. [math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}] is allocated to that Reporting Period. Where activity-shifting leakage adjustments were reported during the deferral, the [math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}] allocated at the deferred assessment is reduced by the sum of those adjustments, but not below zero.
Until the deferred assessment, [math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}] is zero in each Reporting Period, and activity-shifting leakage monitoring must be undertaken as set out in Section 8.3.7. The Project Proponent must report the deferral, the MAP realized to date and the assessment deadline at each Verification.
[/G-4VXN-0]If the Project stops undergoing Verification, or Project failure occurs, before the deferred assessment, [math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}] must be calculated with the MAP realized to date and treated as a Reversal. It is compensated through the Buffer Pool Compensation Process (Section 10.3.3).
Deferral applies to market leakage mitigation only. Where the displaced commodity was used for subsistence, activity-shifting leakage mitigation must be in place by the Displacement Event, unless Isometric approves a later date with the written agreement of the Direct Actors.
[/R-BVPT-0]The emissions impact of leakage mitigation activities, [math: CO_2e_{Leakage\;Mitigation\;Emissions}] must be considered. Where a Leakage Mitigation Site is shared across Projects or instances, [math: CO_2e_{Leakage\;Mitigation\;Emissions}] must be allocated according to Section 8.3.3.3.
The same system boundaries set out in Table 1 must be considered, notingand that[math: itCO_2e_{Leakage\ isMitigation\ likelyEmissions}] onlyshall certaincount GHGtowards SSRs[math: willCO_2e_{Operations,RP}] (Section 9.5.2). They must be includedattributed to the Reporting Period in which they occur, except where they are allocated under Section 8.
3.3.3. At minimum, the following emissions sources must be considered:
[/G-5AJD-1]Only activities that are additional as a result of the leakage mitigation activity should be considered as part of [math: CO_2e_{Leakage\;Mitigation\;Emissions}]. Activities that were already occurring and would continue to occur without the leakage mitigation activity may be omitted from the emissions accounting, if evidence that the activity was already occurring and would have continued to occur in the absence of the leakage mitigation activity is provided.
Lower emissions associated with the leakage mitigation activities relative to emissions associated with the displaced productivity may count against [math: CO_2e_{Leakage\;Mitigation\;Emissions}] (e.g., crop production with lower fertilizer input, lower emissions-intensity cattle production, including lower enteric methane). The reduction must not take [math: CO_2e_{Leakage\;Mitigation\;Emissions}] below zero.
[math: CO_2e_{Market\;LeakageMarketLeakage}] considersis the emissions associated withfrom land conversion aselsewhere acaused result ofby market leakage.
It is noted that other emissions may result from market leakage, such as fertilizer use as part of intensification to produce an increase in commodity supply. These emissions sources have been excluded at this time given a lack of globally appropriate data availability. These emissions are also expected to be negligible compared to land conversion emissions.
If [math: PPP] includes multiple commodity types, [math: CO_2e_{Market\;Leakage}] must be quantified with the Market Leakage Module for displacement of productivity using [math: uPPP_c] (Equation 2) as the displaced productivity for each commodity type.
Market leakage emissions are quantified using the following equations:
[math: CO_2e_{Market\;Leakage} = \sum\limits_{c=1}^n CO_2e_{Market\;Leakage,c}]
(Equation 3)
Where:
The isProject Proponent must report the following:
the commodity type c.
and:
[math: CO_2e_{Market\;Leakage,c} = ha_{LC, c} \times EF_{Carbon\;Stock}]
(Equation 4)
Where:
Project Proponents are required to estimate the amount of new land brought into production, [math: ha_{LC}]. This estimate must be informed by:
The new land brought into production must be calculated separately for each commodity type being displaced as a result of the Project.
Land conversion for production is quantified using the following equation:
[math: ha_{LC, c} = \frac{aPPP_{c} \ \times \:IS_{c}\ \times \:NL_{c}}{Y_{NL, c}}]
(Equation 5)
Where:
Adjusted unmitigated Pre-Project Productivity, [math: aPPP], must be calculated using the following equation:
[math: aPPP_c = uPPP_c \times (1+GR_c)]
(Equation 6)
Where:
The annual growth rate in productivity of the commodity type and region must be assigned as part of Equation 6. This is a requirement to ensure that any likely future increases in productivity are accounted for as part of the assessment.
Growth rate must be calculated based on the following hierarchy:
Growth rate must be calculated using the following equation:
[math: GR_c =(\frac{yield_{c,t}}{yield_{c,t-x}})^{1/x}-1]
(Equation 7)
Where:
Average growth rate is determined by taking the difference between yield in the most recent year of recorded data ([math: t]) and a historic year ([math: t-x]). Where possible [math: t-x] should represent 25 years prior to [math: t]. Where this is not possible, a minimum of 10 years prior to [math: t] is allowable.
If a recent negative shock leads to a negative growth estimate of yield growth, a value of zero should be used.
Increased Supply is the proportion of foregone productivity that will be replaced by increased supply elsewhere. This is underpinned by the premise that foregone production will not necessarily be replaced in totality by increased supply elsewhere as a result of elasticities of supply and demand. Global markets for commodities have been assumed for the purposes of the leakage assessment.
Estimates for [math: IS] are determined using the following equation:
[math: IS = \frac{ε_{s,c}}{ε_{s,c} + |ε_{d,c}|}]
(Equation 8)
Where:
Isometric has carried out a literature review of [math: ε_s] and [math: ε_d] values for certain regions. Values for [math: ε_s] and [math: ε_d] for these regions are provided in Appendix A. Where the Project falls into these regions, the default values provided must be used, unless suitable alternative values are approved by Isometric. This is because understanding which values to use from literature is challenging as academic papers are typically not written with this purpose or audience in mind. Isometric has completed this work for certain regions to lessen this complexity and provide consistency across projects.
The default values also serve as an example of appropriate values to select from the literature for other regions; however, it should be noted that the quality of research differs across regions. For all other regions, values for [math: ε_s] and [math: ε_d] must be sourced from literature. The procedure and requirements for sourcing default values for [math: ε_s] and [math: ε_d] are set out in Appendix A.
[math: NL] considers the percentage of increased supply that will result in new land brought into production for the commodity type. This is underpinned by the premise that not all increased supply will result in new lands being brought into production. Some increased supply may be made up of intensification of activities and increased yields on existing production lands.
Isometric have carried out a literature review of [math: NL] values for certain regions. Values for [math: NL] for these regions are provided in Appendix A. Where the Project falls into these regions, the default values provided must be used, unless suitable alternative values are approved by Isometric. The procedure and requirements for sourcing default values for [math: NL] are set out in Appendix A.
The default values also serve as an example of appropriate values to select, however it should be noted that the quality of research differs across regions.
[math: Y_{NL}] considers the yield on new land brought into production for commodity c. To determine yield on new land, follow the regional and national approach set out in the assessment of [math: Y_c]pasture (Section 8.3.2.1.2).;
the country and sub-national region of the Project site.
[math: EF_CO_2e_{Carbon\;StockMarketLeakage}] mustis quantified once, at the first Verification or at the deferred assessment set out in Section 8.3.3.4, and is allocated to that Reporting Period. It may only be derivedincreased fromafterwards. Where [math: PPP_c] is zero for all commodities, [math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}] is zero and the IPCCMarket averageLeakage nationalModule abovegrounddoes biomassnot contentapply.
[math: toCO_2e_{Leakage, massRP}] is part of C,the andcalculation carbon fraction,of [math: CFCO_2e_{Emissions, RP}], as set out in SectionEquation 9.3.1. Belowground biomass stocks should be estimated using the same process as set out17 in Section 9.6.
[math: CO_2e_{Leakage,RP}] is calculated with Equation 17a (Section 9.6.4) from two terms:
Leakage mitigation emissions are not part of [math: CO_2e_{Leakage,RP}] (Section 8.3.4).
Where activity-shifting mitigation is in place, activity-shifting leakage monitoring is not required. Where only market leakage mitigation is in place, activity-shifting leakage monitoring must be undertaken for the Project. This is because market leakage mitigation does not necessarily mitigate activity-shifting leakage and Direct Actors may still be implicated. Where only partial or no leakage mitigation is in place, activity-shifting leakage monitoring must be undertaken in addition to a full or partial market leakage emissions deduction or, where the assessment is deferred, until that assessment (Section 8.3.3.4).
Activity-shifting leakage monitoring requires satellite imagery of a buffer or boundary zone along the Project perimeter, called the Leakage Monitoring Zone. The Leakage Monitoring Zone will form a consistent buffer zone along the perimeter of the Project site. The distance between the exterior perimeters of the Project site and Leakage Monitoring Zone (i.e., the buffer width) will be determined by the smaller of the following:
The Leakage Monitoring Zone sizing is based on the likelihood that most of the displacements from the project area will not go beyond a five-kilometer radius, as well as to reflect the relative impact of variations in project size.
Isometric will undertake monitoring of the Leakage Monitoring Zone. The satellite imagery will be monitored at every Verification and will account for seasonal differences in vegetation cover. The satellite imagery will compare the deforestation rate of the Leakage Monitoring Zone with the average deforestation rate in the region. Whenever the deforestation rate in the Leakage Monitoring Zone is higher than the average for the region, the Project Proponent must provide additional information. The additional information must include:
[/R-GCBC-0]If the Project Proponent is able to provide justification that the above-average rates of deforestation observed are unrelated to the Project and not as a result of actions relating to the Direct Actors, then no further action is required. Acceptable evidence includes documentation from government authorities or other local records that show the observed deforestation was unrelated to the Project and the Direct Actors. This can be further supplemented with remote sensing observations and notarized statements. Both Isometric and the VVB must independently review the evidence and determine whether the Direct Actors were responsible. If either Isometric or the VVB determine the evidence is insufficient, then the above-average area of deforestation must be considered as part of the leakage calculation.
Consider two forest conservationreforestation projects with different areas:
Example 1: Small Project
The small reforestation project has a project area of 1 km2. Using the first approach, a 5 km buffer width would create a Leakage Monitoring Zone of 120 km2 (calculated as an 11 km x 11 km total area minus the 1 km2 project area). Using the second approach, the Leakage Monitoring Zone would only need to be 5 km2 (five times the project area). In this case, the second approach would be used as it results in the smaller Leakage Monitoring Zone.
Example 2: Large Project
The large reforestation project has a project area of 100 km2. Using the first approach, a 5 km buffer width would create a Leakage Monitoring Zone of 300 km2 (calculated as a 20 km x 20 km total area minus the 100 km2 project area). Using the second approach, the Leakage Monitoring Zone would need to be 500 km2 (five times the Project Area). In this case, the first approach would be used as it results in the smaller Leakage Monitoring Zone.
The amount of above-average deforestation that should be attributed to the Project as activity-shifting leakage is determined by the total amount of possible activity-shifting leakage. The difference between market leakage and identified activity-shifting leakage is included in the calculation of [math: CO_2e_{Leakage, RP}] in(Section Equation 98.3.6). [math: CO_2e_{Activity-shiftingAS\;Leakage\:AdjustmentAdj,RP}] is calculated with the following equation:
[math: CO_2e_{Activity-shiftingAS\;Leakage\:AdjustmentAdj,RP} = \max\;left(ha_{ASL} \times EF_{Carbon\;Stock} - CO_2e_{MarketMarketLeakage} - \:Leakagesum_{k<RP} CO_2e_{AS\:;Adj,k},\ 0\right)]
(Equation 9)
Where:
[math: EF_{Carbon\;Stock}] and [math: Y_{NL,c}] are taken from Sections 5.2.5 and 5.2.6 of the Market Leakage Module for every displaced commodity, including commodities whose market leakage is quantified with its CORSIA-based approach (Section 5.2.1).
The amount of above-average deforestation that should be attributed to the Project as activity-shifting leakage, [math: ha_{ASL}], is determined by the total amount of possible activity-shifting leakage. This is represented in the following equation:
[math: ha_{ASL} = \min\:left(\frac{ha_{Monitored\:;LC}}{ha_{Max,\:LC}},1) \timesha_{Max\;LC}\right)]
(Equation 10)
Where:
[math: ha_{Max\:LC}] is calculated using the following calculation:
(Equation 11) Where::;LC} = \sum_{c} \frac{aPPPPPP_c}{Y_{NL,c}}]aPPPPPP_c] is the adjusted unmitigated Pre-Project Productivity of commodity c, in appropriatethe units, e.g.,set tonnesout perfor yearEquation 2 (see Section 8.3.5.12.1). Leakage mitigation is not deducted: market leakage mitigation does not replace the Direct Actors’ production, so it does not reduce the land they may convert.appropriate productionthe units, e.g.,of tonnes[math: PPP_c] per yearhectare (seefor livestock, the regional mean stocking rate in head per hectare), as set out in Section 8.3.5.1.5)4 of the Market Leakage Module.
The Reporting Period for reforestation projects represents an interval of time over which removals are calculated and reported for Verification. The minimum duration of a Reporting Period is one year and the maximum duration of a Reporting Period is five years (see Section 5.3).
Total net CO2e removal is calculated for each Reporting Period and is written hereafter as [math: CO_2e_{Removal, RP}]. This is calculated using a cumulative framework, which evaluates removals from project initiation to the end of the current Reporting period, and then issues new Certificates for the current Reporting Period corresponding to the increase in net removals relative to what was previously awarded. The net CO2e removal quantification must be conservatively determined, giving high confidence that at a minimum, the credited amount of CO2e was removed and stored.
GHG emission calculations must include all emissions related to the project activities that occur within the Reporting Period (see Table 1). This includes:
In line with the Isometric Standard, this Protocol requires that Removal Certificates are issued ex-post. Certificates may be issued once CO2 has been removed from the atmosphere and is stored in living trees.
Net CO2e removal for a reforestation project for each Reporting Period (RP), is calculated with the following equation:
[math: CO_2e_{Removal,\RPRP_n} = CO_2e_{Stored,\RPcum} - CO_2e_{Counterfactual,\RPcum} - CO_2e_{Emissions,\RPRP_n} + CO_2e_{HWPDW,\RPnet,\ cum} + CO_2e_{SOC,\ net,\ cum} + CO_2e_{L,\ net,\ cum} - \sum_{i=1}^{n-1} CO_2e_{Removal,\ RP_i} - \sum_{i=1}^{n-1} CO_2e_{Emissions,\ RP_i}]
(Equation 12)
Where:
The total amount of CO2 stored from a reforestation project is calculated as
[math: CO_2e_{Stored,RP}=CO_2e_{AGB,\ RP}+CO_2e_{BGB,\ RP}]
(Equation 13)
Where:
The This carbon poolspool is optional and its inclusion subject to the guidance and requirements within an available Module the scopeProject Proponent is crediting against. For Projects where this is not being quantified, Project Proponents must set this value to 0.
For Projects under project expansion, Equation 12 is applied separately to each Project Area, with each term calculated from that Project Area’s own start date and [math: \sum CO_2e_{Removal,RP}] including only Certificates previously issued for that Project Area.
Soil Organic Carbon (SOC) and deadwood are optional pools. The inclusion of HWPsSOC and deadwood as a poolpools for Projects crediting under this Protocol is subject to the guidance and requirements of the applicable Module(s) the Project Proponent is crediting against, and the details of how to calculatequantify [math:these CO_2e_{HWP,RP}]pools are described in the applicablefollowing Modules:
Requirements for quantification of carbon storage as soil organic carbon in forest settings.
Requirements for quantification of carbon storage in deadwood in forest settings.
The uncertainty in the overall estimate of the net CO2e removal as a result of the Project must be accounted for. Uncertainty in the cumulative CO2e stored in all credited carbon pools and in the dynamic baseline (see Section 9.5.5) must be propagated jointly to produce a single probability distribution of cumulative net carbon storage. This must use Monte Carlo simulation or variance propagation, as described in the Isometric Standard. Conservative estimates of input parameters may not be used in place of propagation under this Protocol.
[/G-RGSA-0]The Project Proponent may use its own uncertainty model, provided it meets the requirements of this Section and is validated by Isometric before inclusion in the project design.
[/G-C5MZ-0]The conservative estimate of cumulative net carbon poolsstorage areis excludedthe 30th percentile of this distribution. This Protocol-specific requirement applies in place of the ≤16th percentile set out in the Isometric Standard, including where an applicable Module refers to the Standard’s approaches.
Because crediting under this Protocol is cumulative, the conservative estimate is recalculated over the full Crediting Period at each Verification. Project Proponents must report the input distributions and outputs required for the joint propagation.
In addition, a sensitivity analysis that demonstrates the impact of each input parameter’s uncertainty on the final net CO2e removal must be provided. Details of the sensitivity analysis method must be provided such that a third party can reproduce the results.
Emission sources. In accordance with Appendix B of the Isometric Standard, input parameters for a GHG SSR may be omitted from the calculationsensitivity analysis if a contribution analysis demonstrates that the individual GHG SSR contributes to < 1% of net CO2e Removal and that all omitted GHG SSRs collectively contribute to < 1% of net CO2e Removal.
Removal parameters. Input parameters used to quantify carbon stocks (e.g., allometric equation parameters, root-to-shoot ratios, carbon fractions) may be omitted from the uncertainty assessment used to determine the conservative estimate of net CO2e removal only where both:
The combined result must be reported. All parameters that do not meet both conditions must be included in the uncertainty assessment.
[/G-ZTGM-0]The total cumulative amount of CO2 stored in a reforestation project as living woody biomass at time [math: t] is calculated as:
[math: CO_2e_{Stored,\ cum}=CO_2e_{AGB}(t)+CO_2e_{BGB}(t) - CO_2e_{AGB}(0) - CO_2e_{BGB}(0)]
(Equation 13)
Where:
The primary carbon pools within the scope of this Protocol are aboveground and belowground woody biomass (see Table 1), as they are the major carbon pools within a reforestation context. For the remainder of the Protocol, the use of AGB and BGB refers to only the living aboveground and belowground woody biomass, respectively, unless otherwise noted. Details of how to calculate [math: CO_2e_{AGB, RP}] and [math: CO_2e_{BGB, RP}] are described below.
The total carbon stored in aboveground biomass over a Reporting Period is calculated by taking the difference between the start and end of the Reporting Period:
[math: CO_2e_{AGB, RP} = CO_2e_{AGB}(t_2) - CO_2e_{AGB}(t_1)]
(Equation 14)
Where:
Reporting Periods are consecutive, so that [math: t_2] then becomes the start of the next RP.
The aboveground biomass carbon stock at a point in time, [math: t], is further calculated as:
[math: CO_2e_{AGB}(t) = \frac{44}{12} \times CF \times M_{AGB}(t)]
(Equation 15)
Where:
The carbon fraction, [math: CF], must be chosen from the following hierarchy:
This Protocol currently supports the following three Capture and Conversion Modules for quantifying the total[math: CO_2e_{AGB}] and [math: CO_2e_{BGB}] over the project area at a point in time, [math: M_{AGB}(t)]:
Uses field-based measurements of vegetation species and size taken within sample plots along with allometric equations to quantify biomass.
Uses LiDAR data collected over the project area and trained models to quantify biomass.
Uses eligible Earth Observation Mapsbased ofAGB aboveground biomassmaps developed by third parties to quantify biomass over the project area.
Requirements for each approach are described in the corresponding Modules. Project Proponents must describe in the PDD which option is used, and adhere to the requirements of that approach. Note that Projects using LiDAR andor Earth Observation Mapsbased AGB maps for quantification still require field plots as the source of truth for benchmarking the maps. This list of acceptable approaches may be expanded upon in future versions of the Protocol.
The total carbon stored in belowground biomass over a Reporting Period is calculated as:
[math: CO_2e_{BGB,\ RP} = RS \times CO_2e_{AGB,\ RP}]
(Equation 16)
Where:
Appropriate root-to-shoot ratios should be selected by regional and species-specific factors that are justified based on scientific literature (e.g., USFS's Component Ratio Method or similar national-level species-specific ratios). This is the preferred approach to have the most accurate estimate and avoid overestimation. If sufficient evidence is provided to demonstrate that no suitable project-specific factor can be obtained, matching to the ecological zone and continent of the project area, based on the IPCC 2019 Table 4.428, must be used. In this case, sufficient evidence documenting the unsuccessful search for project specific factors must also be supplied. Acceptable evidence must show (1) a list of search terms used within a research database (e.g., Web of Science, Google Scholar) that encapsulate the region and species relevant to the Project, and (2) the relevant species are not included in the list of species for which root-to-shoot ratio data are available on the TRY Plant Trait Database30.
The uncertainty in selected [math: RS] factors must be reported from the same source dataset. For example, the IPCC 2019 Chapter on Forest Land28 provides an uncertainty in the root-to-shoot ratio.
This Protocol uses a dynamic baseline approach to quantify the counterfactual impact on forest carbon stocks if the project activity had not occurred. In this approach, the counterfactual is determined by observing changes in forest carbon stocks for a collection of areas outside of the project area (control pixels) that are representative of the project area except for the project activity. By using observations of matched controls, dynamic baselines are able to reflect changes in market trends, policies, environmental changes, etc., that can affect counterfactual carbon storage and which would be difficult to capture in static approaches. As such, the use of real-time remote sensing and robust matching procedures in the dynamic baseline procedure leads to the most plausible baseline scenario that can be clearly quantified and compared to the project activities. Further, the pixel matching procedure matches every pixel within the project area to multiple pixels in the control area, generating an ensemble of samples representing multiple baseline scenarios. This ensemble approach inherently characterizes uncertainty probabilistically through the variation in control pixels. This uncertainty is then included in carbon calculations (see Section 9.45.5). Because of this, the use of dynamic baseline approaches that leverage remote sensing to compare project activities to matched controls has been noted as a rigorous and conservative approach in the scientific literature28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35. Dynamic baselines will be independently determined and transparently reported by Isometric at each Verification to determine any deduction in Certificate issuance based on the Baseline scenario. Certificate issuance will only occur for carbon removal that is determined to be additional via the following procedure, inclusive of uncertainty. The following section outlines the standardized workflow that Isometric will take; the Project Proponent is not responsible for carrying out the steps in this section. Project Proponents may suggest areas that could constitute suitable control pixels or features for matching based on their expert knowledge of their unique system. However, the ultimate determination of control pixels will be done by Isometric following the procedure and criteria below. Although dynamic baseline approaches are reliant on the suitability of the matched areas to act as controls, the standardized approach includes provisions for using several criteria for matching, matching to multiple pixels, assessing match quality, expanding the number of potential matches, and regularly reassessing control pixel suitability to minimize the associated uncertainty.
Additionally, Isometric will make a pre-project estimation of the Baseline scenario at project validation using historical data as described in Section 9.45.6.
The zone from which control pixels will be selected, termed the Donor Zone, must meet the following eligibility criteria:
If possible, other features should also be matched between the Donor Zone and project area, such as:
Initially, the potential area for the Donor Zone should be limited to a 100 km band around the project area. However, if suitable matches (see Section 9.45.3 for matching step) are not found in this zone, additional step-outs in 10 km increments may occur to find appropriate control pixels, assuming they meet the criteria above. For projects consisting of multiple discrete planting areas spread across a region, multiple planting areas can share an initial single 100km radius Donor Zone which encapsulates the planting areas. Depending on the geographic spread of the planting areas, multiple Donor Zones may be defined.
In some scenarios, constraining the zone for eligible control pixels based on the criteria above may severely limit the size of the Donor Zone. Although further control pixels can be selected by expanding the potential Donor Zone area in 10-kilometer increments, doing so may only marginally increase the area of the Donor Zone or improve the performance benchmark accuracy.
Environmental criteria such as bioclimatic variables, productivity, and biogeography used for control pixel matching tend to exhibit spatial autocorrelation — especially in areas of high topographic relief. Therefore, control pixels selected even short distances from the project area can have fundamentally different ecological conditions that can lead to biased control pixel selection and forest carbon stocks and/or proxies. Land use history can similarly constrain the Donor Zone. To ensure accurate matching, the Donor Zone should account for legacy effects—such as prior management regimes, levels of degradation, and priority effects—that influence long-term carbon storage capacity. However, controlling for land use history does further limit eligible Donor Zone pixels due to the asynchronous timing of land-use changes across the landscape. In any given year, areas with similar land use may vary in the time elapsed since active management (e.g., harvesting, cultivation, grazing, or disturbance), potentially biasing control pixel selection and forest carbon stocks and/or proxies.
One consequence of a small Donor Zone is small control pixel sample sizes, which can reduce performance benchmark accuracy through sampling bias. In this situation, Isometric may temporally expand the pool of potential control pixels using a time-for-space substitution (TFSS) sampling strategy. TFSS relaxes the requirement to match the Donor Zone and project area from identical calendar years, thereby expanding the n-dimensional area available for valid control pixel selection. Instead of aligning control pixel and project forest carbon stocks and/or proxies by the same calendar year, TFSS compares changes in forest carbon stocks and/or proxies relative to the time elapsed since pre-project conditions, enabling more robust estimates of additionality.
In this approach, historical data for control pixels can be matched to current data for the Project. The same criteria as listed above must apply across the time points (i.e., current regulations which apply to the Project must have also been applicable at the historical time point for the control pixel). This approach will only be used when there is demonstrated necessity for its application to yield a sufficiently sized Donor Zone. If TFSS is implemented, Isometric will include the justification for the approach as well as the specific methodological approach and data included in the TFSS in its documentation of the baseline procedure.
When the TFSS is used, the temporal range considered for eligible control pixels will be expanded in 5-year increments, up to 15 years maximum. In addition to the features and criteria above, eligibility for the use of time substituted control pixels also includes:
When temporal substitution is used for control pixels, their eligibility will be re-evaluated at each Reporting Period according to the guidance set out in Section 9.45.4.
Once the boundaries of the Donor Zone are determined, Isometric will generate high-resolution (≤30 m) pixel maps representing forest carbon stocks or a suitable proxy for forest carbon stocks. TheseAt project initiation, layers must cover the entire project area and Donor Zone at the same resolution for at least five historical time points relative to the start of the Project. Each historical time point must be separated by at least 1 year.
The Project Proponent may propose the forest carbon proxy (stocking index) to be used, which Isometric will validate before inclusion in the project design. Where no proxy is proposed, Isometric will select a suitable proxy. thatIn meetseither case, the proxy must meet the following criteria:
Project pixels are matched to control plot pixels based on the historical time series of the selected forest carbon proxy, [math: C_{proxy}], of each pixel, using k-nearest neighbors with replacement (or an alternative justified algorithm). This matching will use, at a minimum, five historical time points capturing at least the five years prior to project initiation. Each project pixel must be matched to a minimum of 10 different control pixels, and the mean forest carbon proxy over the group of control pixels is calculated from the map product created using the procedure described in Section 9.45.2. Multiple project pixels may be matched to the same control pixels.
For each project pixel, the change in carbon stock oversince theproject Reporting Periodinitiation is calculated both for the project pixel and for the collection of corresponding control pixels (taking the mean across the group) using the values from the carbon proxy map:
[math: \Delta C_{proxy,t} = C_{proxy}(t_2t) - C_{proxy}(t_10)]
(Equation 1714)
Where:
The carbon removal of the counterfactual scenario is found by scaling the quantified carbon removal in the project area by the ratio of the mean differencesproxy ofchange in the matched control pixels and the mean proxy change betweenin the project and control pixels:
[math: CO_2e_{Counterfactual,RP\ cum} = CO_2e_{Stored,RP\ cum} \times \frac{max(0,\mu_frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}\frac{1}{k_i}\sum_{j=1}^{k_i}\Delta C_{proxy,project\ control,\ ij}(t))}-{\mu_frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}\Delta C_{proxy,difference\ project,\ i}}}{\mu_{\Delta C_{proxy,project}}(t)}]
(Equation 1815)
Where:
In \DeltaEquation C_{proxy15, project,the i}]mean is theproxy change in forestthe carbonensemble proxyof overcontrol pixels for the Reporting Period, [math: RP], in project pixelis [math:floored i]at 0.
To meet the additionality condition, theper-pixel change in proxy value in the project area,differences [math: \Delta C_{proxy,\ project,\ i}(t) - \Delta C_{proxy,\ control,\ i}(t)], must be statistically greater than zero across all project pixels. This must be demonstrated using a paired, one-sided t test (p < 0.05, inclusive of uncertainty) than the mean change in proxy value for the matched control pixels, [math: \Delta C_{proxy, control}]. If the meancondition proxyis changenot inmet, no Certificates are issued for that Reporting Period, but previously issued Certificates are not affected and the controlProject pixelsremains iseligible negativefor suchCertificates thatat thesubsequent resulting product of Equation 18 is negative, the counterfactual carbon storage, [math: CO_2e_{Counterfactual,RP}], will be assumed to be 0 in order to ensure the accounting of carbon storage is limited to removalsVerifications.
The counterfactual carbon storage is then used to calculate a performance benchmark for the project area, [math: PB_{RPcum}]:
[math: PB_{RPcum} = \frac{CO_2e_{Stored,\RPcum}}{CO_2e_{Counterfactual,\RPcum}}]
(Equation 1916)
If the additionality requirement is met, the performance benchmark will be greater than 1, with larger magnitudes indicating a greater difference between storage in the Project and control areas.
At
The baseline assessment at project initiation ([math: t]=0) must be done after site preparation but before planting, including capturing any pre-existing biomass that will remain in the project area.
[/G-7N0D-0]If the site preparation includes any removal of woody biomass (e.g., invasives), this must be captured in the GHG emissions from project establishment as described in Section 8.1.
[/G-V9W2-0]If the planting plan of the Project does not allow for adequate temporal separation of site preparation and planting to allow for baseline establishment (e.g., site preparation and planting done simultaneously), Project Proponents must provide justification for the necessity of their timeline and approach for project establishment. In this scenario, Isometric will assess the initial baseline prior to any site preparation. Project Proponents must still report all GHG emissions associated with project establishment as above, including explicitly reporting all removals of woody biomass for site preparation. Isometric will review the reported data and, if appropriate, remove the cleared woody biomass component from the GHG emission analysis if this carbon pool is already accounted for in the baseline set before removals occurred as part of site preparation.
In scenarios where there is removal of woody biomass as part of site preparation, the performance baselinebenchmark may be less than one in the early period of the Project, and therefore ineligible for crediting, until growth of the reforested area results in greater biomass than what was removed as part of project establishment. However, this would not be considered a reversal as long as i) the Project Proponent has provided documentation that biomass was removed as part of site preparation and ii) there is not a continued decrease in biomass once site preparation is complete.
Isometric will account forcharacterize uncertainty in the dynamic baseline, which is propagated jointly with uncertainty in the Project’s carbon stocks to obtaindetermine athe conservative estimate of [math:net CO_{2}e_{Counterfactual,\CO2e RP}]removal in(see EquationSection 189.3). At minimum, this will include an evaluation of the following sources of uncertainty in [math: CO_2e_{Counterfactual,cum}] (Equation 15):
At validation, Isometric will use the historical data across the control pixels used in the matching procedure (Section 9.45.3) to produce an ex-ante projection of counterfactual biomass. This baseline will be used to evaluate additionality. To be considered additional, the carbon removal in the project area must be statistically significantly greater than this ex-ante baseline. The dynamic baselining procedure described in the preceding subsections of Section 9.45 will be used for all ex-post issuance of Certificates.
To compute the baseline, Isometric will use historical data points over the matched control pixels to calculate the slope of the linear regression representing the expected change in carbon storage over time for the counterfactual scenario. This slope will be assumed to be constant and used to create projections of future counterfactual carbon storage to which the ex-ante carbon curve can be assessed. againstThis assessment applies at Validation only. Additionality at each Verification is assessed using the dynamic baseline (Section 9.5.4).
At each Verification, the control pixels are reviewed to determine continued eligibility with the criteria as outlined in Section 9.5.1. Changes in the status of these criteria which create a divergence between the control pixel and the project pixel indicate that the pixel may no longer be a suitable control for the project area. As an example, if a control area is put under legal protection status, but the project area is not under the same protected status, the control pixel would no longer be considered representative. In the event that control pixel matches are no longer suitable, replacements will be selected for the impacted project pixels.
Control pixels may also be replaced if they experience persistent data quality issues, or if they show a change in the carbon proxy that results from an event or land use that does not represent the counterfactual for the project area (e.g., clearing for infrastructure, mining or urban development, or a land-use change that would not have been possible in the project area). The same criteria apply whether the change is a decrease or an increase. The Project Proponent may request a removal or replacement, with supporting evidence, at any Verification. Isometric decides each request and documents the decision and its justification. The remaining or replacement pixels are then used for the full cumulative counterfactual calculation.
Over the course of the Crediting Period, there may also be updates to the proxy dataset used for the dynamic baseline assessment. Changes must not be independent of the resulting counterfactual calculation, and are limited to scenarios where there is a justified need for changing the carbon proxy, which may include:
Where replacement of the proxy occurs, it must be clearly documented and justified, and the new proxy must show equivalent or better correlation with field-measured aboveground biomass in the project area. The application of the new forest carbon proxy product will follow the below hierarchy:
Across all of the above scenarios, the previously awarded Certificates are not impacted by the change in proxy (i.e., the final summation term in Equation 12).
[math: CO_2e_{Emissions,\ RP}] is the total GHG emissions associated with a Reporting Period, RP. This can be calculated as:
[math: CO_2e_{Emissions,\ RP} = CO_2e_{Establishment,\ RP} + CO_2e_{Operations,\ RP} + CO_2e_{End-Of-Life,\ RP} + CO_2e_{Leakage,\ RP}]
(Equation 2017)
Where:
The following sections set out specific quantification requirements for each term in Equation 2017.
GHG emissions associated with project establishment should include all historic emissions incurred as a result of project establishment, including but not limited to the SSRs set out in Table 1, such as biomass burning for site preparation, temporary structures, and fertilizer and/or herbicide application. An inventory of pre-project vegetation is required to quantify vegetation removed during planting and site preparation.
[/R-QP2P-0]Project establishment emissions occur from the point of project inception to the moment before the first removal activity takes place. GHG emissions associated with project establishment may be amortized over the anticipated project lifetime, or per output of product. Rules on amortization are outlined in Section 7 of the GHG Accounting Module v1.1.
See Section 7 of the GHG Accounting Module
GHG emissions associated with [math: CO_2e_{Operations,\ RP}] should include all emissions associated with operational activities, including but not limited to the SSRs set out in Table 1.
For reforestation projects, the Reporting Period covers a set period of time (e.g., one year), during which the forest was growing and increasing its woody biomass. [math: CO_2e_{Operations,\ RP}] emissions must be attributed to the Reporting Period in which they occur. Allocation outside of the current Reporting Period may be permitted in certain instances, on a case by case basis in agreement with Isometric.
[math: CO_2e_{End-of-Life,\ RP}] includes all emissions associated with activities that are anticipated to occur after the Crediting Period until the end of the Project Commitment Period. This includes activities related to ongoing monitoring for Reversals.
[math: CO_2e_{End-of-Life,\ RP}] must be estimated upfront and allocated in the same way as set out for calculation of [math: CO_2e_{Establishment}].
Given the uncertain nature of [math: CO_2e_{End-of-Life,\ RP}] emissions, assumptions must be revisited at each Reporting Period and any necessary adjustments made.
[/R-BAYB-0][math: CO_2e_{Leakage, RP}] includes emissions associated with a Project's impact on activities that fall outside of the system boundary of the Project. It includes increases in GHG emissions as a result of the Project displacing emissions or causing a secondary effect that increases emissions elsewhere.
TheProjects must calculate [math: CO_2e_{Leakage,\ RP}] calculationwith:
[math:approachCO_2e_{Leakage,\ RP} = CO_2e_{MarketLeakage,\ RP} + CO_2e_{AS\;Adj, RP}]
(Equation 17a)
Where:
Ecological leakage is assumed to be zero in this version of the Protocol (Section 8.3.1).
[math: CO_2e_{MarketLeakage}] is quantified with the Market Leakage Module for displacement of productivity, as set out in full in Section 8.3.25.4 [math: CO_2e_{Leakage,RP}] is the sum of the market leakage allocated to the Reporting Period and isthe notactivity-shifting repeatedleakage hereadjustment (Equation 9), as set out in Equation 17a.
GHG emissions accounting must be undertaken in alignment with the GHG Accounting Module v1.1, which ensures a consistently rigorous standard in how GHG emissions are quantified and reported between different CDR Projects and approaches. This includes:
Refer to GHG Accounting Module for guidance on GHG accounting rules.
The Energy Use Accounting Module v1.3 provides requirements on how energy-related emissions must be calculated for The Project so that they can be subtracted in the net CO₂e removal calculation. It sets out the calculation approach to be followed for intensive facilities and non-intensive facilities and acceptable emission factors.
Energy emissions are those related to electricity or fuel usage. They may include, but are not limited to:
Refer to Energy Use Accounting Module for guidance on fuel and energy calculation requirements.
The GHG Accounting Module v1.1 provides requirements on how transportation and embodied emissions must be calculated for The Project so that they can be subtracted in the net CO₂e removal calculation.
Embodied emissions are those related to the life cycle impact of equipment and consumables. They may include, but are not limited to:
Transportation emissions are those related to transportation of products and equipment. They may include, but are not limited to:
Refer to Section 4.1 and Section 4.2 of the GHG Accounting Module for guidance on embodied and transportation emissions calculations
Any models used under this Protocol must be well-validated and skillful for the purpose that they were used for. Proof of model validation can be achieved through either:
The storage reservoir of the CO2 removed through reforestation is live aboveground and belowground woody biomass, and soil organic carbon and deadwood where those pools are included in quantification. The durability of a CDR process refers to the length of time for which CO2 is removed from the Earth’s atmosphere and cannot contribute to further climate change. This Section details the durability, risks of Reversals and requirements for storage of removed atmospheric CO2 as live woody biomass and, where credited, other carbon pools.
The durability of a Certificate is equal to the length of the Ongoing Monitoring Period as outlined in Section 5.4. The minimum duration of the Ongoing Monitoring Period, and therefore minimum durability of Certificates issued under this Protocol, is 40 years.
The duration of the Ongoing Monitoring Period must not exceed any of the following:
Reversal risks which may threaten the durability of forest carbon and project-level risk assessment and mitigation requirements are discussed in Section 10.2 and Section 10.3, respectively.
A forestry-wide Buffer Pool managed by Isometric is used to insure Certificates against Reversals. Throughout the Ongoing Monitoring Period, Isometric will monitor for Reversals to ensure Certificates achieve their stated durability. Upon detection and quantification of carbon losses, Certificates issued to the Buffer Pool will be canceled in equal proportion to the loss (see Sections 10.4: Buffer Pool and 10.5: Ongoing Monitoring for Reversals).
A long-term durability plan to continue maintenance of forest carbon beyond the Project Commitment Period is needed to mitigate risk of timber harvest or Reversal after the Project ends (see Section 5.5: Post-Project Commitment Period). The long term durability plan may consist of evidence of the following, and ideally a combination of factors:
Reversals are defined as reductions in forest biomass that may result in emissions of CO2 to the atmosphere. Reversal risk is quantified by assessing the likelihood of a disturbance event occurring over a period of time and estimating the severity of the disturbance in terms of biomass loss. Disturbance events may be natural or anthropogenic, such as fire, drought/heat, insect and disease, deforestation, and timber harvesting. A disturbance event which results in a reduction in forest biomass is considered a loss event. The duration of disturbance events may be over multiple years (e.g., drought) or for a very limited duration (e.g., windstorm).
The likelihood and severity of disturbances are influenced by external and project-related factors.
External factors:
Project-related factors:
Furthermore, the risk profile of the Project may change over the Project Commitment Period due to:
The Reforestation Risk Assessment is used to determine the risk profile of the Project, including risks to Certificate delivery and storage. Aspects of the Project which have higher risk exposure must be accompanied by an appropriate risk mitigation plan.
[/G-KFC9-0]To safeguard against high risk projects, the Project must score below the indicated thresholds to be eligible for crediting under this Protocol. The Reforestation Risk Assessment must be updated at each Verification and whenever a Project Area is added. Buffer Pool contributions set at Verifications within a Reporting Period byare provisional and are trued up at the end of the Reporting Period (see Project Proponent and increased risk scores will result in additional mitigation activitiesExpansion).
Projects must complete Isometric’s Reforestation Risk Assessment in Appendix E, which is independently evaluated by a third-party VVB.
Mandatory Safeguards
The following safeguards are required for all reforestation projects and must be in place at the start of the Project and maintained throughout the Project Commitment Period.
[/R-9DBT-The Project Proponent must:
[G-7JWP-0, Projects must report a fire management plan which reduces the risk of unintended fires.]Reduce risk of unintended fires through a fire management plan (e.g., removing fuel, fire breaks or fire towers, fire-fighting equipment and training). [/G-7JWP-0]
[G-V7RB-0, Projects must report a water management plan which reduces the risk posed by drought.]Reduce risk of drought through a water management plan (e.g., securing water supply, water infrastructure, ensuring water resources are not strained for neighboring areas). This plan addresses drought risk to the Project; impacts of the Project on local water resources are addressed in Section 6.6.[/G-V7RB-0]
As outlined in the Isometric Standard, the Buffer Pool is a mechanism used to insure against risks of Reversals that may be observable and attributable to the Project through monitoring.
Currently, there is insufficient published scientific evidence to quantitatively account for climate change, management activities, or forest age and translate this into a highly accurate Buffer Pool contribution. As a result, we apply either a flat contribution requirement on the Project or a model to translate the Reforestation Risk Assessment into a Buffer Pool contribution. As actuarial data improve and more research is published, the Protocol requirements will be updated accordingly.
To be eligible under this Protocol, the Project must either:
[/G-747Y-0]The Buffer Pool contribution will be held in a forestry-wide Buffer Pool managed by Isometric. Pooling of a diversified portfolio of forestry projects across geographic regions, spatial scales and temporal scales can reduce the exposure to systemic risks stemming from forestry projects constrained to a geographic area or ecological type3936,4037,3128. The forestry-wide Buffer Pool composition will be transparently reported on the Isometric Registry.
The Buffer Pool Compensation Process is governed by the Isometric Standard. The following procedures apply upon detection and quantification of a loss event. The characterization procedure for a Reversal varies, depending on when the Reversal occurs:
The cause of the Reversal has further implications for whether or not the Project Proponent is responsible for compensation. The Isometric Standard distinguishes between Avoidable and Unavoidable Reversals:
For more details on Reversals, including the distinctions between Avoidable and Unavoidable Reversals, refer to the Isometric Standard.
All Projects eligible under this Protocol may elect to participate in Isometric’s insurance pilot for Reversal risk, as set out in the Isometric Standard. A participating Project must hold an insurance policy, approved by Isometric, from an insurer on Isometric’s Approved Provider List. It follows the requirements of Isometric’s Insurance Framework for the policy, its Buffer Pool contributions and the treatment of Reversals. In particular, the participating Project must:
Participation in the pilot does not change the Project’s obligations to monitor, report and compensate Reversals under Section 10.4 and the Isometric Standard.
Isometric will independently conduct continuous monitoring for Reversals for the full length of the Project Commitment Period. Monitoring will consist of:
Upon detection of a Reversal, Project Proponents must thoroughly investigate, initiate adaptive management to minimize losses, and implement mitigation actions to reduce future risks of Reversal.
Loss events representing a reduction of carbon stored in live woody biomass, or any credited optional carbon pools greater than 1% of the cumulative tonnes of CO2e removed by the Project (based on total number of Certificates issued) must be reported, investigated, and compensated for.
[/G-EDZ8-0]Upon detection of a loss event by Isometric or other third party, the following procedures will commence:
Where a Reversal is detected and the Project Proponent is unable to access the project area to verify it on the ground and complete a full Reversal report, the entire affected area is treated as a full Reversal and compensated from the Buffer Pool as an avoidable Reversal (see Section 10.3.3).
Quantification of Reversals are calculatedquantified by determining the relative change in a proxy aboveground biomass parameter such as forest area cover or vegetation indices. Since only carbon stored in live woody biomass is considered in the quantification of carbon removal, thisThis Protocol conservatively assumes that all carbon stored in live woody biomass is immediately released to the atmosphere upon mortality as a result of a disturbance event. Belowground biomass is conservatively assumed to be lost proportionally to aboveground biomass. Where the Project credits any other optional carbon pools the credited stock of each of these pools in the affected area is also assumed to be lost in proportion to aboveground biomass, unless the Project Proponent quantifies the loss in that pool with the applicable Module.
The method for quantifying Reversals is subject to the following limitations, and will be updated with developing science:
Projects which experience a Reversal on the scale of 20% of the cumulative tonnes of CO2e removed by the Project (based on total number of Certificates issued) must conduct field sampling to quantify the remaining stocks of forest carbon stored in live woody biomass and any credited optional pools.
All pre-deployment requirements must be described in the PDD, as outlined in Section 7.1. The requirements are summarized across the following categories.
Description of the Project site, including:
[G-HB5Y-0, Projects must describe the environmental context of the site, with a summary description of heterogeneities of environmental factors across the full project area]Environmental context of the site, including heterogeneities of environmental factors across the full project area;[/G-HB5Y-0]
Description of project timeline, including:
Description of planned reforestation activities, including:
[/Documentation of any pre-Validation activities, including:
Description of leakage assessment and leakage mitigation plan, including:
A shapefile indicating activity displacement areas;
Description of monitoring activities, including:
Risk of Reversal plan, including:
This Protocol requires a combination of in situ and remotely-sensed monitoring for the following purposes:
This section summarizes the Monitoring requirements that are discussed throughout this Protocol.
Project monitoring responsibilities are split between the Project Proponent and Isometric as follows:
Isometric owns:
Project Proponent owns and provides in monitoring reports:
This Protocol refers to monitoring at multiple different locations, which are illustrated in an example in Figure 3.
Maps of monitoring locations that the Project Proponent is responsible for (i.e., everything inside the project area) must be described and submitted with the PDD. Isometric will transparently disclose locations of control pixels and Leakage Monitoring Zone.
[Image: Figure 3 Monitoring locations]
Figure 3. Schematic of the various monitoring locations referred to throughout this Protocol.
The entire project area in Figure 3 must be monitored for the duration of the Project Commitment Period (see Section 5.1).
During the Crediting Period, monitored parameters from an AGB proxy map (e.g., canopy height) in the project area is used in conjunction with control pixels to establish a dynamic baseline for determining the additionality of carbon storage in the project area. Isometric will handle all aspects of the dynamic baseline assessment. Project Proponents are responsible for monitoring conducted within the Project Area that is required for the selected AGB quantification method (see Section 9.3.2).
After the Crediting Period, ongoing monitoring of forest biomass (e.g., forest cover or saturation index) must continue annually until the end of the Project Commitment Period for detection of Reversals (see Section 10.54). Isometric will ensure independent ongoing monitoring for Reversals until the end of the Project Commitment Period.
Control pixels are used to assess natural regeneration in similar land areas outside the project area to determine the additional carbon storage of a reforestation project beyond the counterfactual scenario. Control pixels are selected by matching each project area pixel to a number of pixels outside the project area that historically behaved similarly (see Section 9.45.3).
An AGB proxy map (e.g., canopy height) is used to determine the relative difference in forest carbon between the Project and Counterfactual scenario for each Reporting Period. Isometric is responsible for the selection of control pixels and the calculation of the dynamic baseline (see Section 9.45).
For projects without sufficient activity-shifting leakage mitigation, the Leakage Monitoring Zone must be monitored using satellite imagery for the duration of the Crediting Period to detect deforestation near the project area. Annual monitoring of forest cover over time is used to calculate deforestation rates over time. See Section 8.3.67 for more details on how leakage monitoring is used. Isometric is responsible for conducting any required leakage monitoring.
Airborne laser scanning measurements are only applicable for projects that wish to use regional LiDAR models to estimate AGB (details described in corresponding Module). ALS data collection should occur throughout the Crediting Period, at the end of each Reporting Period.
In situ field measurements are required for all projects throughout the Crediting Period. Field plots may be used as the primary method for calculating aboveground biomass, or are used for benchmarking regional LiDAR-based or globalEarth Observation based AGB maps. Details of the application of these methodologies for AGB quantification are described in the corresponding Modules. For projects selecting the quantification approach where AGB is derived directly from field measurements, then in situ field plots must be sampled at the beginning and end of each Reporting Period. Otherwise, for both LiDAR approaches and globalEarth Observation based AGB maps, field measurements must be taken at a minimum of every 5 years for benchmarking purposes. At minimum, species identification and DBH must be measured for all trees with DBH >> 10 cm within the in situ field plot.
During the first few years after planting seedlings, there may not be many trees with DBH >> 10 cm. However, it is still important to monitor field plots during this time as young forests are particularly vulnerable to disease, ecological hazards, and may experience high rates of mortality. In addition, techniques to quantify forest biomass tend to overestimate in young forests. Between project initiation and first Verification (see Section 5), it is recommended to monitor for early tree mortality every 6 months to better constrain early stage growth as well as inform any mortality mitigation activities (e.g., replanting trees).
Table 2 Summary of the required and recommended monitoring parameters.
Frequency | Location | Parameter | Methods | Justification | Recommended or Required | Responsible party |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
From initial planting to first Verification, recommended every 6 months | In-situ field plots | Tree mortality | Mortality survey, or high resolution drone imagery | Estimations of forest biomass may be highly uncertain during the initial years after tree planting due to high rates of tree mortality and biases in young forests. Surveys for early tree mortality can better constrain early stage biomass growth, and enable mortality mitigation activities | Recommended | Project Proponent |
At the start and end of each Reporting Period for Area-Based AGB Quantification (see Module for details). Otherwise, at least every 5 years. | In situ field plots | DBH for all trees larger than 10 cm diameter | Tape measure | Fundamental measurement estimating AGB using allometric equations | Required | Project Proponent |
At the start and end of each Reporting Period for Area-Based AGB Quantification (see Module for details). Otherwise, at least every 5 years. | In situ field plots | Tree species | Ecologist identification | Necessary for selecting species-specific allometric equations and parameters | Required | Project Proponent |
As set out in the applicable Module | In situ field plots | Soil organic carbon and/or deadwood stocks | As set out in the Forest Soil Organic Carbon Quantification Module or the Deadwood Quantification Module | To quantify the optional pools in Equation 12 | Required where the pool is quantified, otherwise not applicable | Project Proponent |
At the start and end of each Reporting Period, e.g., once a year in the same season | Laser scanning plots | 3D Point clouds and derived metrics (e.g., canopy height) | Laser scanning instruments mounted on aerial platforms | To derive estimates of forest aboveground biomass | Required when LiDAR quantification Module selected, otherwise not applicable | Project Proponent |
At the start and end of each Reporting Period, e.g., once a year in the same season | Project area | AGB Map | Satellite data or third-party mapped product | To derive estimates of forest aboveground biomass | Required when | Isometric or a third party |
At the start and end of each Reporting Period, e.g., once a year in the same season | Control pixels & project area | Forest carbon proxy (e.g, canopy height, biomass saturation index) | Satellite data or third-party mapped product | To quantify relative change in forest carbon sequestration between control pixels and project area (Equation | Required | Isometric or a third party |
At the start and end of each Reporting Period, e.g., once a year in the same season | Leakage buffer zone | Indicators of deforestation | Satellite | To identify any activity-shifting leakage that should be taken into account for the net carbon removal calculation (Equation 9) | Required | Isometric or a third party |
Annually, for every complete year from the start of the Leakage Mitigation Site contract (for livestock, at the same census date each year) | Leakage Mitigation Site(s) | Productivity of the mitigated commodity (for livestock, herd inventory) | Production records (e.g., farm records, sales records, herd census) | To calculate MAP (Equations 3–5) and, for a shared Leakage Mitigation Site, the allocation of leakage mitigation emissions (Equations 6–8b). Records cannot be recreated after the fact. | Required where leakage mitigation is undertaken, otherwise not applicable | Project Proponent |
At each Verification | Project area | Area and planting date (or assisted natural regeneration start date) of each planting area | Planting records and shapefiles | To allocate Certificates to calendar-year vintages (Equation 1) | Required where Certificates are allocated by linear apportionment, otherwise not applicable | Project Proponent |
Each harvest event; forest management plan updated at each Verification | Project area | Harvest location, intensity and interval, and trees removed | Operational harvest records and forest management plan | To confirm harvesting does not reduce carbon stocks below those quantified at the most recent Verification, and to account for harvesting emissions (Section 4.2) | Required where harvesting of woody biomass takes place, otherwise not applicable | Project Proponent |
Each burn; reported at each Verification | Project area | Date, location and extent of each prescribed burn | Burn records under the fire management plan | To determine whether a burn reduced the carbon stock of a quantified pool (Section 10.2) | Required where prescribed fire is used, otherwise not applicable | Project Proponent |
From the end of the Crediting Period to the end of the Project Commitment Period, annually | Project area | Indicators of deforestation | Satellite | To identify Reversals and appropriately remediate through the Buffer Pool | Required | Isometric or a third party |
Isometric haswould carriedlike to thank the following external reviewers of this Protocol/Module:
Theserecognized defaultinsurance valuesmechanism alsoamong serveRegistries asallowing an example of appropriate values to select, however it should be noted that the quality of research differs across regions.
The following sections set out the procedureCertificates to be followedset aside (in this case by Isometric) to obtain [math: IS] and [math: NL] values and set out the default values to be usedcompensate for theReversals regionswhich studied.
The regions consideredoccur in the literaturefuture.
Thesebiogeochemical regionsand/or werephysical selectedinteractions followingwhich aoccur reviewduring ofthe projectedremoval projectprocess demandthat decrease the CO₂ removal .
IS represents the amountprocess of production that is diverted to other locations. The IS value does not provide any information on where or in what manner that production is produced.
Procedure for determining [math: IS] values:
Where
This Appendix defines the commodity classes used in Sections 8.3.3.1 and 8.3.3.2. Classes 1–9 follow the FAO (2010) World Programme for the Census of Agriculture crop classification, which groups crops by aagricultural reputableuse. A organizationcommodity compilingis aclassified meta-analysisby what is sold or parameterizing a partial equilibrium model for policy analysis (CARBconsumed, EUnot by the land cover it grows on. For example, FAObeef from cattle on pasture is Livestock, etcnot "grasses and fodder crops".) Classes 10 and 11 cover livestock and dairy, which the FAO crop classification does not.
Table A1.[math: IS] default values.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Leafy or stem vegetables (cabbage, lettuce); fruit- |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Oilseed | Soybeans, groundnuts, rapeseed, sunflower, safflower, sesame, mustard, linseed, castor, coconuts, olives, oil palms | |||
5 | Root and tuber crops | Potatoes, sweet potatoes, cassava, yams | |||
6 | Beverage and spice crops | Coffee, tea, maté, cocoa; spices such as chillies, pepper, cinnamon, cloves, ginger, vanilla | |||
7 | Leguminous crops | Beans, broad beans, chickpeas, cowpeas, lentils, lupins, peas, pigeon peas | |||
8 | Sugar crops | Sugar beet, sugar cane, sweet sorghum | |||
9 | Other crops | Grasses and fodder crops sold as a commodity; fibre crops (cotton, jute, flax, hemp); medicinal and aromatic crops; rubber; flowers; tobacco | |||
10 | Livestock |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Procedure for determining [mathSource: NL]FAO values:
In an ideal world(2010), thereA would be estimatesSystem of theIntegrated specificAgricultural types of land use that were convertedCensuses and their locations. However, this data is not available. Instead, the Project Proponent should focus on the most important elements of potential land use change from a carbon emissions perspective. NL values proposed aim to capture the net effect of a one unit removal of crop area on forestland conversion. These NL values will be smaller in magnitude than NL values that incorporate the possibility of conversion of grazing land or the conversion of lower-value crops to higher-value crops. Focusing on forests is more tractable and likely provides a large share of the relevant land use change emissions, since forest conversion is relatively permanent in a way that livestock to cropland conversion is not. In general, the NL values are more speculative than the IS values and often rely on assumptions about the yield-price elasticity that have not been empirically confirmed.
There are possible methodologies for obtaining [mathSurveys: NL]World values, which are set out here. Method B is in most cases the preferred approach. This is because the necessary conditions to implement Method A (limited trade/ disconnected markets and demand driven quantity increase) are rarely met in practice. Method A should only be used in special cases and justified appropriately. Both methods are set out below:
[math: NL = \frac{{Gross\: new\: production\:}_x}{{Gross\: new\: production\:}_x +\ {\Delta \ Average\: yield \:}_x\: +\ Total\: land \:area}]
(Equation A1)
Where:
[math: x] is variable under the assumption that changes to supply are predominantly channeled through price changes483.
By dividing the numerator and denominator, the above equation can be reformulated as:
[math: NL = \frac{{\Delta \ Area\:}_x}{{\Delta \ Area\:}_x +\ {\Delta \ Yield \:}_x\:}]
(Equation A2)
Where:
The following default values have been gathered using Method B.
Table A2.[math: NL] default values.
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
When assessing the net climate impact (NCI) within the Project Area using the data from Hasler et al. (2024)9, the threshold for determining whether an area is net climate negative should use the biome-specific uncertainty values shown in Table B1 which are derived from Table S2 of the study. The uncertainty value for a given biome is taken from the range of values yielded from different parameterizations used in the study. Areas will be considered to be net climate negative, and therefore ineligible for planting, when their NCI Density value plus biome specific uncertainty is less than zero. For example, for temperate broadleaf and mixed forests, any areas with NCI densities less than -31 Mg [math: CO_{2}e] ha[math: ^{-1}] will be considered net climate negative.
Table B1. Net Climate Impact (NCI) Density [Mg [math: CO_{2}e] ha[math: ^{-1}]] Biome-Specific Uncertainty.
Biome | Mean NCI Density | Min NCI Density | Max NCI Density | Uncertainty (+/-) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Tundra | -110 | -190 | -41 | 74.5 |
Boreal Forests/Taiga | 42 | 0 | 85 | 42.5 |
Temperate Grasslands, Savannas & Shrublands | -98 | -138 | -56 | 41 |
Mediterranean Forests, Woodlands & Scrub | -92 | -135 | -65 | 35 |
Temperate Conifer Forests | 156 | 110 | 196 | 43 |
Temperate Broadleaf & Mixed Forests | 182 | 147 | 209 | 31 |
Tropical & Subtropical Grasslands, Savannas, & Shrublands | 39 | -15 | 70 | 42.5 |
Tropical & Subtropical Coniferous Forests | 250 | 235 | 260 | 12.5 |
Tropical & Subtropical Dry Broadleaf Forests | 203 | 179 | 216 | 18.5 |
Tropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | 598 | 588 | 605 | 8.5 |
Mangroves | 527 | 519 | 532 | 6.5 |
Flooded Grasslands & Savannas | 91 | 65 | 108 | 21.5 |
Montane Grasslands and Shrublands | -233 | -315 | -188 | 63.5 |
Deserts & Xeric Shrublands | -205 | -250 | -171 | 39.5 |
Globally | 120 | 80 | 150 | 35 |
It is recommended to make use of root-to-shoot ratios that are developed in tandem with the allometry used. Allometric equations and root-to-shoot ratios should be selected based on the following hierarchy:
For example in the United States, the National Scale Volume Biomass (NSVB) equations can be used, and these equations come with root allometry. The framework is explained in A national-scale tree volume, biomass, and carbon modeling system for the United States5438 and the coefficients are given in the supplementary materials.
Furthermore, Allometric is an R package that curates allometric equations and facilitates their usage.
Datasets with the following characteristics will generally provide stronger evidence: peer-reviewed with publicly available data and code; classification accuracy > 90% with reported uncertainty; spatial resolution ≤ 30 m; and annual data for at least the 10 years prior to project initiation.
Additionality
Approved Resources and Third-Party Datasets
Albedo
Baseline
Buffer Pool Contribution
Insurance
Quantification with LiDAR
Leakage
Leakage Mitigation
Stakeholder Engagement
Uncertainty
Emergency Response
The Reforestation Risk Assessment is used to assess the overall delivery and storage risk associated with reforestation and may inform the Buffer Pool contribution during Certificate delivery (see Section 10.43). The assessment must first be filled in by the Project Proponent and must be validated by a VVB. During project Validation, discrepancies between the Project Proponent’s self reported score and VVB may result in monitoring or risk mitigation activities, or project ineligibility. Eligible projects must have an initial risk score ≤≤ 20 and initial risk category scores at or below the following thresholds:
All risk categories shall have a minimum score of 0, regardless of the outcome of the Reforestation Risk Assessment.
For projects with discrete planting areas, the risk assessment must include all geographic areas relevant to the Project. For risk indicators that are geographically explicit (e.g., disturbance risks), the score may be calculated via an area-weighted average and rounded up to the nearest whole number.
The Covered under insurance pilot column in Table E1 identifies the indicators whose peril may be covered by an approved policy under the insurance pilot (Section 10.3.4). Core and enhanced cover are defined in Isometric’s Insurance Framework. Eligibility is always assessed on the full Reforestation Risk Assessment against the cutoffs above.
If Project Proponents choose to forgo a flat 20% Buffer Pool contribution (see Section 10.43.1), the Reforestation Risk Assessment will inform Buffer Pool contributions for the Project according to the process outlined in Appendix G for each Reporting Period and in accordance with the requirements in Section 10.32.
Table E1. Reforestation Risk Assessment, with the score to be filled out for each question. Where a scoring guideline lists lettered options, select the single option that applies.
Risk Category | Risk Indicator | Evidence | Scoring Guidelines | Covered under insurance pilot | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Project Proponent Capacity Risk | Does the Project Proponent maintain staff with domain expertise relevant for forest carbon projects? (e.g., forest ecology, forest measurement, carbon accounting) | Project’s team structure | If no, describe how gaps in relevant expertise will be filled, +1. | No | |
Does the Project Proponent maintain a staff presence in the local vicinity (within one day of travel) of the Project site? | Project’s team structure | If no, +2. | No | ||
Was the Project Proponent established more than 12 months ago? | Project Proponent declaration | If no, +1. | No | ||
Does the Project Proponent have prior experience in ecosystem restoration, carbon projects or planting? | Review of Project Proponent provided evidence and independent research | If yes, -1. | No | ||
Has the Project Proponent abandoned or failed previous projects? | Review of projects on other registries | If yes, +3. | No | ||
What proportion of the project area requires active enforcement against external threats (e.g., illegal logging, agricultural encroachment, unauthorized grazing) to protect carbon stocks? | Peer-reviewed publications, local or national government databases, NGO reports and assessments, site security assessment, satellite data, data on enforcement from other reforestation projects in the same region, local or national reports on environmental crimes or violations |
| Enhanced cover only | ||
Financial Viability Risk | Has the Project secured funding to cover all activities required before carbon revenue accrues? | Project financial plan |
| No | |
What is the projected time to reach financial breakeven? | Project financial plan |
| No | ||
Is the budget reasonable given the proposed project activities and ex-ante estimates for forest growth? Budget should at minimum include: personnel, equipment and supplies, infrastructure, travel and certification fees. | Project financial plan | If no, +2. | No | ||
Does the Project financial plan demonstrate sufficient cash flow throughout the Ongoing Monitoring Period to maintain forest carbon stocks? | Project financial plan | If continued financial incentive is low compared to likely opportunity cost of harvest, +2. | No | ||
Does the Project financial plan rely on future increases in market price for Carbon Certificates? | Project financial plan | If yes, +1. | No | ||
Social Governance Risk | Are there currently or have there been disputes over land ownership over the last 20 years? | Jurisdictional history | If yes, +2. | No | |
Does the government have a history within the past 50 years of revoking legal agreements regarding land ownership, access, and usage? | Jurisdictional history | If yes, +2. | No | ||
Does the Project host country have a 10-year average score below | If yes, +2. | No | |||
Does the government have an NDC in place that addresses corresponding adjustments/prevents double-counting of project Credits and NDC contributions? | National registries | If no, +1. | No | ||
Does the Project have a detailed benefit-sharing plan that includes: clear distribution mechanisms, transparent criteria for beneficiary selection, a grievance resolution process, monitoring and reporting procedures? (See the note below Table E1.) | Project financial plan, benefit-sharing agreements, and stakeholder engagement records (see Section 6.5.1) |
| No | ||
Does the Project Proponent have a presence on human rights, environmental or labor infraction lists? | National registries | If yes, fail. | No | ||
Does the Project Proponent have ongoing legal disputes? | National registries | If yes, +1. | No | ||
Does the Project Proponent have a presence in negative press content? | Online search | If yes, +1. | No | ||
|
| If no, fail. | No | ||
Are baseline activities primarily subsistence-driven? | Land use documentation, Socioeconomic surveys |
| No | ||
(a) Are there anticipated or demonstrated net positive community impacts? | Community impact assessment, project financial plan, socio-economic surveys | If no, +2. | No | ||
(b) What is the net present value (NPV) of alternative land use compared to project NPV? | NPV analysis comparing alternative uses to project activities over Crediting Period, price forecasts, discount rate justification |
| No | ||
Are opportunity cost risk mitigations in place? | Legal agreements protecting carbon stocks, Non-profit status documentation, grant/funding agreements |
E. Both B and D, -2. F. Both C and D, -3. | No | ||
Disturbance Risk | Fire risk | Mean daily Global Fire Weather Index over the prior two years |
| Core and enhanced cover | |
Pest and disease outbreak risk | Regional third-party maps, if available. |
| Core and enhanced cover | ||
Extreme weather (temperature - heat and cold) | IPCC AR6 |
| Core and enhanced cover | ||
Extreme weather (hydrologic - flood and drought) | IPCC AR6 |
| Core and enhanced cover | ||
Coastal risks (sea level rise, storm surge, tropical cyclones, salinity intrusion) | Regional third-party maps, if available. |
| Core and enhanced cover | ||
Geologic risks (earthquakes, tsunami, volcanoes) | If historical hazards in area, +1. | Core and enhanced cover | |||
Illegal timber risk |
| Enhanced cover only | |||
Surrounding anthropogenic activities pose environmental risk (e.g., toxic pollution, industrial farming, new developments etc.) | Satellite imagery, site visit | If yes, +1. | Enhanced cover only | ||
Ecological Resilience | Project Design Document |
| Core and enhanced cover | ||
Flood plain hazards | Project area overlap with identified floodplain based on Nardi et al., 2019 44 or regional/local equivalent |
| Core and enhanced cover |
Benefit-sharing plan. For the benefit-sharing indicator in Table E1, benefits may take any form, including monetary payments, goods, services, employment, infrastructure, training, or access to or a share of non-timber forest products. A benefit counts towards this indicator where:
Worldwide Governance Indicators. Scores refer to the World Bank's Worldwide Governance Indicators governance scores on the absolute 0–100 scale introduced in the 2025 revision. For each of the six indicators, the score is averaged over the 10 most recent years of published data at the time of the assessment. The indicator scores +2 where three or more of the six indicators have a 10-year average below 40.
The following section outlines how Isometric calculates the indicator scores for climate-related extreme weather disturbance risks to carbon permanence within a project’s region (Figure F1). Project Proponents should use Table F1 to lookup the Isometric-calculated values for their project's region and include those scores in their Reforestation Risk Assessment (see Appendix E).
Extreme weather risks are assessed via two indicators: a temperature indicator (extreme heat and/or cold) and a hydrologic indicator (flooding and/or drought). Each indicator includes both historical data (1961-2015) and projected future extreme events. Historical data indicate the likelihood of extreme events based on past climate patterns, e.g., projects in regions with extended dry periods are expected to experience increased water stress as part of their typical climate. Climate model projections describe how changing climate conditions, relative to historical patterns, might present an increased risk of disturbances. Areas where there is a larger shift towards extreme conditions under future climate relative to their historical baseline have a greater disturbance risk (e.g., drier conditions relative to historical averages increases risk for drought-driven mortality).
To calculate the scores in Table F1, Isometric uses values from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change AR6 report5943. The temperature indicator is calculated using data describing the annual number of frost days ([math: FD], minimum temperature below 0°C) and annual number of days with a maximum temperature above 40°C ([math: TX_{40}]) to capture extreme cold and extreme heat risks, respectively. The hydrologic indicator is calculated using data describing the maximum 5-day precipitation ([math: RX_{5Day}]) and annual maximum number of consecutive dry days ([math: CDD]) to capture risks of flooding and drought, respectively. All values come from the CMIP6 climate models. Future projections use the SSP2-4.5 medium term (2041-2060) scenario and are assessed as the change in value relative to a historical baseline (1961-1990).
For each indicator subcomponent, the region’s terrestrial median value is compared with the global terrestrial distribution of the same variable (Table F2). To convert the regional value into a subscore, regional values below the global 50th percentile are considered Low Risk, regional values equal to or greater than the global 50th percentile but below the 75th percentile are Medium Risk, and any regional values equal to or greater than the global 75th percentile are High Risk. Low Risks are given a subscore of 0, Medium Risks are 0.25, and High Risks are 0.5. The overall score for each of the indicators is calculated by summing the corresponding subscores, as described below:
[math: Indicator_{Temperature} = Historical_{TX_{40}} + Future_{TX_{40}} + Historical_{FD}]
[math: Indicator_{Hydrological} = Historical_{CDD} + Future_{CDD} + Historical_{RX_{5Day}} + Future_{RX_{5Day}}]
Projected change in the number of frost days is not included as a subcomponent since it is projected that they will decline under future climate across the globe, representing a low risk of future extreme cold events.
[Image: Map of IPCC regional codes]
Figure F1. Map and lookup table for IPCC regional codes
Table F1. Regional Lookup Table of Disturbance Risk
Region | Indicator | Variable | Time | Value | Risk | Score | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
NW North America (NWN) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 224.2 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 23.5 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -1.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 54.4 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 11.9 | High | 0.5 | ||||
NE North America (NEN) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 242.9 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 25.1 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -2.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 50.6 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 11.8 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Western North America (WNA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 128.4 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.9 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 2 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 40.6 | Low | 0 | 0 | |
Change (Days) | -0.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 67.3 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 5.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
Central North America (CNA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 104.9 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 4.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 8.9 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 23.7 | Low | 0 | 0.25 | |
Change (Days) | -0.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 84.3 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (%) | 6.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Eastern North America (ENA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 116 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.6 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 15.5 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | -0.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 89.4 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 9 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Northern Central America (NCA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 15.9 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 4.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 8.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 51.6 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -0.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 92.9 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 6 | Low | 0 | ||||
Southern Central America (SCA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 1.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 39.7 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -1.6 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 134.3 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 4.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
Caribbean (CAR) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 24.3 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | 0.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 99.9 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 0.8 | Low | 0 | ||||
NW South America (NWS) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0.6 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.8 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 28.6 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -0.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 133 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 7.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
Northern South America (NSA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 9.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 46.7 | Low | 0 | 1 | |
Change (Days) | 9.7 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 111.6 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 5.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
NE South America (NES) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.3 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 4.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 95 | High | 0.5 | 1.5 | |
Change (Days) | 6.3 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 144.3 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 5.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
South America-Monsoon (SAM) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 7.5 | Low | 0 | 0.25 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 2.2 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 11.5 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 64.8 | Medium | 0.25 | 1.25 | |
Change (Days) | 13.7 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 133.7 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 6 | Low | 0 | ||||
SW South America (SWS) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 35.8 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 65.9 | Medium | 0.25 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -4.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 83 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (%) | -0.9 | Low | 0 | ||||
SE South America (SES) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 16.6 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 2.8 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 5.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 36.3 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | 0.4 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 105.1 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 8.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
Southern South America (SSA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 75.4 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 20.5 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | 1.6 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 57.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 3.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
Northern Europe (NEU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 150.3 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 18.5 | Low | 0 | 0.25 | |
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 52.8 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 10 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Western & Central Europe (WCE) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 109.7 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 22.8 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | 1.3 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 55 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 8.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
Eastern Europe (EEU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 171.4 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 2.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 27.6 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | 1.1 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 42.9 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 10 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Mediterranean (MED) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 27.6 | Low | 0 | 0.25 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 6 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 11.8 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 75 | High | 0.5 | 1 | |
Change (Days) | 6.7 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 49.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 3.9 | Low | 0 | ||||
Western Africa (WAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 1 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 24 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (Days) | 26.4 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 83.5 | High | 0.5 | 1.25 | |
Change (Days) | -0.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 85.2 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (%) | 19.6 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Central Africa (CAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0.25 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 11.1 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (Days) | 9.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 61.8 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | -0.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 84.4 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (%) | 14.9 | High | 0.5 | ||||
North Eastern Africa (NEAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 1 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 16.1 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (Days) | 15.4 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 80.4 | High | 0.5 | 1 | |
Change (Days) | -2.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 64.6 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 15.4 | High | 0.5 | ||||
South Eastern Africa (SEAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 78.5 | High | 0.5 | 1.5 | |
Change (Days) | 0.4 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 91.9 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 9.7 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
West Southern Africa (WSAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 1.2 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 3 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 108.7 | High | 0.5 | 1.5 | |
Change (Days) | 10.5 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 87.6 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 2 | Low | 0 | ||||
East Southern Africa (ESAF) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 2.7 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 2.8 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 68.7 | Medium | 0.25 | 1.25 | |
Change (Days) | 4.3 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 127.5 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 6 | Low | 0 | ||||
Madagascar (MDG) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 46.7 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -1.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 175.7 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 5.8 | Low | 0 | ||||
Russian-Arctic (RAR) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 271.3 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 31.5 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -4.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 39.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 16.7 | High | 0.5 | ||||
West Siberia (WSB) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 203.1 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 2 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 31.4 | Low | 0 | 0.25 | |
Change (Days) | -0.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 37.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 10.8 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
East Siberia (ESB) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 233.9 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 34.1 | Low | 0 | 0.25 | |
Change (Days) | -3.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 54.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 11.5 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
Russian-Far-East (RFE) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 238.1 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 28.8 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -3.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 65.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 14.4 | High | 0.5 | ||||
West Central Asia (WCA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 95.8 | High | 0.5 | 1.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 22 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (Days) | 17.5 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 113.6 | High | 0.5 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | -0.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 42.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 10 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
East Central Asia (ECA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 195.6 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 2.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 75.1 | High | 0.5 | 1 | |
Change (Days) | -6.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 30.5 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 12.9 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Tibetan-Plateau (TIB) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 258.6 | High | 0.5 | 0.5 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 1.6 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.4 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 42.3 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | -2.6 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 80.9 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (%) | 11.6 | High | 0.5 | ||||
East Asia (EAS) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 91.7 | Medium | 0.25 | 0.25 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.3 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 29.1 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | 0.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 132 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 9.6 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
South Asia (SAS) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 7.9 | Low | 0 | 1 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 33.1 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (Days) | 14.5 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 93.9 | High | 0.5 | 1.5 | |
Change (Days) | -3.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 132.2 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 12 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Southeast Asia (SEA) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0.3 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 1.1 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 26.8 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | 0.8 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 168.4 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 7.3 | Low | 0 | ||||
Northern Australia (NAU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0.75 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 11.8 | Medium | 0.25 | |||
Change (Days) | 20.4 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 95.7 | High | 0.5 | 1.25 | |
Change (Days) | 0.7 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 163.7 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 7.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Central Australia (CAU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0.1 | Low | 0 | 1 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 27.8 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (Days) | 75.8 | High | 0.5 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 27.3 | Low | 0 | 1 | |
Change (Days) | 3.5 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 86.5 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 4.7 | Low | 0 | ||||
Eastern Australia (AU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 1.4 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 2.7 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 4.2 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 35.8 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -0.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 120.6 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 5.6 | Low | 0 | ||||
Southern Australia (SAU) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 1.3 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 7.1 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 6.9 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 40.2 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | 2 | High | 0.5 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 60.3 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (%) | 2.8 | Low | 0 | ||||
New Zealand (NZ) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 5.9 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 13.8 | Low | 0 | 0.75 | |
Change (Days) | 0.5 | Medium | 0.25 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 92.3 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 5.6 | Low | 0 | ||||
South Pacific Ocean (SPO) | Temperature | Frost Days | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | 0 |
Days > 40°C | Historical | 0 | Low | 0 | |||
Change (Days) | 0 | Low | 0 | ||||
Hydrological | CDD | Historical | 19.4 | Low | 0 | 0.5 | |
Change (Days) | -0.5 | Low | 0 | ||||
5-Day Precip | Historical | 183.3 | High | 0.5 | |||
Change (%) | 3.8 | Low | 0 |
Table F2. Global Benchmark Values for Extreme Weather Risks.
Time Frame | Variable | Median | 75th % | 90th % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Historical | Frost Days | 89.8 | 94.1 | 97.5 |
Days Max Temp > 40°C | 9.9 | 15.1 | 21.9 | |
Consecutive Dry Days | 63.7 | 71 | 76.2 | |
Maximum 5-day Precipitation (mm) | 79.5 | 86 | 90.4 | |
Projected Future | Frost Days | |||
Days Max Temp > 40°C | 9.9 | 11.8 | 14.6 | |
Consecutive Dry Days | 0.3 | 1.1 | 1.8 | |
Maximum 5-day Precipitation (%) | 8.9 | 11.5 | 14.1 |
By default, Projects are subject to a flat 20% Buffer Pool contribution as outlined in Section 10.43.1. Project Proponents may opt to calculate a project-specific Buffer Pool contribution based on the outputs of their Reforestation Risk Assessment for each Reporting Period.
The following steps are used to convert the outputs of the Reforestation Risk Assessment into a Buffer Pool contribution:
Table G1. Risk score to Buffer Pool contribution conversion for each risk category.
Risk Category | Cumulative Risk Score | Buffer Pool Contribution |
|---|---|---|
Project Proponent Capacity Risk | 0 | 2.5% |
1 | 2.6% | |
2 | 3.1% | |
3 | 4.8% | |
4 | 7.7% | |
5 | 9.4% | |
6 | 9.9% | |
7 | 10.0% | |
Financial Viability Risk | 0 | 2.5% |
1 | 2.6% | |
2 | 2.9% | |
3 | 3.9% | |
4 | 6.3% | |
5 | 8.6% | |
6 | 9.6% | |
7 | 9.9% | |
8 | 10.0% | |
Social Governance Risk | 0 | 2.5% |
1 | 2.6% | |
2 | 2.7% | |
3 | 3.1% | |
4 | 3.9% | |
5 | 5.3% | |
6 | 7.2% | |
7 | 8.6% | |
8 | 9.4% | |
9 | 9.8% | |
10 | 9.9% | |
11 | 10.0% | |
Disturbance Risk | 0 | 2.5% |
0.25 | 2.5% | |
0.5 | 2.6% | |
0.75 | 2.6% | |
1 | 2.6% | |
1.25 | 2.6% | |
1.5 | 2.6% | |
1.75 | 2. | |
2 | 2.7% | |
2.25 | 2.7% | |
2.5 | 2.8% | |
2.75 | 2.8% | |
3 | 2.9% | |
3.25 | 3.0% | |
3. | 3.1% | |
3. | 3.2% | |
|
| |
4 | 3. | |
4.25 | 3.5% | |
4.5 |
| |
4.75 |
| |
5 | 4. | |
5.25 | 4.5 | |
5.5 |
| |
5.75 | 5. | |
6 | 5.5% | |
6.25 | 5.9% | |
6.5 | 6.3% | |
6. | 6. | |
6 |
| |
|
| |
7 | 7. | |
7.25 |
| |
7.5 |
| |
7.75 | 8. | |
8 |
| |
8.25 |
| |
8.5 |
| |
8.75 | 9. | |
9 | 9. | |
9.25 | 9. | |
9.5 | 9. | |
9.75 | 9. | |
10 | 9. | |
10.25 | 9. | |
10.5 | 9. | |
10.75 | 9. | |
11 | 9. | |
11.25 | 9.9% | |
11.5 | 9.9% | |
11.75 | 9.9% | |
12 | 9.9% | |
12.25 | 9.9% | |
12.5 | 9.9% | |
12.75 | 10.0% | |
| 10.0% |
Insurance pilot. For a Project participating in the insurance pilot, Isometric also calculates the Buffer Pool contribution with the line items covered by the Project’s approved policy (see the Covered under insurance pilot column of Table E1) scored N/A. A risk category with no scored line items remaining contributes 0%. The Insurance Framework sets out how this result, and the contribution calculated under the steps above, determine the Project’s contribution in each Reporting Period. Both are recalculated whenever the Reforestation Risk Assessment is updated.
The Buffer Pool contribution for each risk category is determined using a sigmoid function described by Equation G1. The Buffer Pool contribution for each risk category ranges from 2.5% to 10%.
[math: BP_{risk} = \frac{L}{1 + e^{-k(x - x_0)}} + 2.5]
(Equation G1)
Where:
The sigmoid function, Equation G1, applied to each risk category can also be visualized in Figure G1.
[Image: Figure G1 Buffer Pool contribution based on risk score for each risk category.]
Figure G1. Buffer Pool contribution based on risk score for each risk category.
The Project has completed the Reforestation Risk Assessment and obtained the following risk scores in a Reporting Period:
Mapping these risk scores to Table G1, the total Buffer Pool contribution for theThe Project is:
43.1% + 6.2% + 4.03% + 3.1% + 2.9% = 1815.24%
Isometric would like to thank following contributors to this Protocol:
Isometric would like to thank following reviewers of this Protocol:
van Diemen, R., Matthews, J. B. R., Möller, V., Fuglestvedt, J. S., Masson-Delmotte, V., Méndez, C., Reisinger, A., & Semenov, S. (Eds.). (2022). Annex I: Glossary. In P. R. Shukla, J. Skea, R. Slade, A. Al Khourdajie, R. van Diemen, D. McCollum, M. Pathak, S. Some, P. Vyas, R. Fradera, M. Belkacemi, A. Hasija, G. Lisboa, S. Luz, & J. Malley (Eds.), Climate Change 2022: Mitigation of Climate Change. Contribution of Working Group III to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009157926.020↩
Pan, Y., Birdsey, R. A., Fang, J., Houghton, R., Kauppi, P. E., Kurz, W. A., ... & Hayes, D. (2011). A large and persistent carbon sink in the world’s forests. Science, 333(6045), 988-993. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1201609↩
Harris, N. L., Gibbs, D. A., Baccini, A., Birdsey, R. A., De Bruin, S., Farina, M., ... & Tyukavina, A. (2021). Global maps of twenty-first century forest carbon fluxes. Nature Climate Change, 11(3), 234-240. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41558-020-00976-6↩
Bastin, J. F., Finegold, Y., Garcia, C., Mollicone, D., Rezende, M., Routh, D., ... & Crowther, T. W. (2019). The global tree restoration potential. Science, 365(6448), 76-79. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aax0848↩
Tierney, G. L., Faber-Langendoen, D., Mitchell, B. R., Shriver, W. G., & Gibbs, J. P. (2009). Monitoring and evaluating the ecological integrity of forest ecosystems. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 7(6), 308-316. https://doi.org/10.1890/070176↩
FAO (2000). On Definitions of Forest and Forest Change. Forest Resources Assessment Programme, Working Paper 33, Rome. ↩
Walker, W. S., Gorelik, S. R., Cook-Patton, S. C., Baccini, A., Farina, M. K., Solvik, K. K., Ellis, P.W., Sanderman, J., Houghton, R.A., Leavitt, S.M., Schwalm, C.R., & Griscom, B. W. (2022). The global potential for increased storage of carbon on land. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 119(23), e2111312119. ↩
Roebroek, C. T., Caporaso, L., Duveiller, G., Davin, E. L., Seneviratne, S. I., & Cescatti, A. (2025). Potential tree cover under current and future climate scenarios. Scientific Data, 12(1), 564. ↩
Hasler, N., Williams, C. A., Denney, V. C., Ellis, P. W., Shrestha, S., Terasaki Hart, D. E., ... & Cook-Patton, S. C. (2024). Accounting for albedo change to identify climate-positive tree cover restoration. Nature Communications, 15(1), 2275. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-46577-1↩↩2
Dinerstein, E., Olson, D., Joshi, A., Vynne, C., Burgess, N. D., Wikramanayake, E., ... & Saleem, M. (2017). An ecoregion-based approach to protecting half the terrestrial realm. BioScience, 67(6), 534-545. https://doi.org/10.1093/biosci/bix014↩↩2
Zhang, Y., Chen, H. Y., & Reich, P. B. (2012). Forest productivity increases with evenness, species richness and trait variation: a global meta‐analysis. Journal of Ecology, 100(3), 742-749. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2745.2011.01944.x↩
Pagad, S., Bisset, S., Genovesi, P., Groom, Q., Hirsch, T., Jetz, W., ... & McGeoch, M. A. (2022). Country compendium of the global register of introduced and invasive species. Scientific Data, 9(1), 391. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-022-01514-z↩
van Kleunen, M., Pyšek, P., Dawson, W., Essl, F., Kreft, H., Pergl, J., ... & Winter, M. (2019). The global naturalized alien Flora (Glo NAF) database. ↩
Convention on Biological Diversity. (2002). Decision VI/23: Biodiversity and climate change. Retrieved from https://www.cbd.int/decision/cop/default.shtml?id=7197↩
Besnard, S., Koirala, S., Santoro, M., Weber, U., Nelson, J., Gütter, J., ... & Carvalhais, N. (2021). Mapping global forest age from forest inventories, biomass and climate data. Earth System Science Data Discussions, 2021, 1-22. https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-13-4881-2021↩
Searle, E. B., & Chen, H. Y. (2017). Tree size thresholds produce biased estimates of forest biomass dynamics. Forest Ecology and Management, 400, 468-474. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foreco.2017.06.042↩
Di Sacco, A., Hardwick, K. A., Blakesley, D., Brancalion, P. H., Breman, E., Cecilio Rebola, L., ... & Antonelli, A. (2021). Ten golden rules for reforestation to optimize carbon sequestration, biodiversity recovery and livelihood benefits. Global Change Biology, 27(7), 1328-1348. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.15498↩↩2↩3
Ewers, R. M., Orme, C. D. L., Pearse, W. D., Zulkifli, N., Yvon-Durocher, G., Yusah, K. M., ... & Banks-Leite, C. (2024). Thresholds for adding degraded tropical forest to the conservation estate. Nature, 631(8022), 808-813. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-07657-w↩
Lindenmayer, D. B., & Luck, G. (2005). Synthesis: thresholds in conservation and management. Biological Conservation, 124(3), 351-354. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2005.01.041↩
IUCN. 2024. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2024-1. https://www.iucnredlist.org. Accessed on 16 Oct. 2024. ↩
Zhang, Y., Chen, H. Y., & Reich, P. B. (2012). Forest productivity increases with evenness, species richness and trait variation: a global meta‐analysis. Journal of Ecology, 100(3), 742-749. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2745.2011.01944.x↩
Pagad, S., Bisset, S., Genovesi, P., Groom, Q., Hirsch, T., Jetz, W., ... & McGeoch, M. A. (2022). Country compendium of the global register of introduced and invasive species. Scientific Data, 9(1), 391. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-022-01514-z↩
van Kleunen, M., Pyšek, P., Dawson, W., Essl, F., Kreft, H., Pergl, J., ... & Winter, M. (2019). The global naturalized alien Flora (Glo NAF) database. ↩
Convention on Biological Diversity. (2002). Decision VI/23: Biodiversity and climate change. Retrieved from https://www.cbd.int/decision/cop/default.shtml?id=7197↩
Gann, G. D., McDonald, T., Walder, B., Aronson, J., Nelson, C. R., Jonson, J., ... & Dixon, K. (2019). International principles and standards for the practice of ecological restoration. Restoration ecology, 27(S1), S1-S46. https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13035↩↩2
Höhl, M., Ahimbisibwe, V., Stanturf, J. A., Elsasser, P., Kleine, M., & Bolte, A. (2020). Forest landscape restoration—what generates failure and success?. Forests, 11(9), 938. https://doi.org/10.3390/f11090938↩↩2
International Finance Corporation (2012). Performance Standard 7: Indigenous Peoples. IFC Performance Standards on Environmental and Social Sustainability. Washington, DC: International Finance Corporation. https://www.ifc.org/content/dam/ifc/doc/2010/2012-ifc-performance-standard-7-en.pdf↩
International Labour Organization (1989). Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention, 1989 (No. 169). Adopted at the 76th Session of the International Labour Conference, Geneva, 27 June 1989; entered into force 5 September 1991. https://normlex.ilo.org/dyn/nrmlx_en/f?p=NORMLEXPUB:12100:0::NO::P12100_INSTRUMENT_ID:312314↩
United Nations General Assembly. (2007). United Nations declaration on the rights of indigenous peoples (A/RES/61/295). Retrieved from https://www.un.org/development/desa/indigenouspeoples/wp-content/uploads/sites/19/2018/11/UNDRIP_E_web.pdf↩
United Nations. (2016). Free, prior, and informed consent: An indigenous peoples’ right and a good practice for local communities. Retrieved from https://www.un.org/development/desa/indigenouspeoples/publications/2016/10/free-prior-and-informed-consent-an-indigenous-peoples-right-and-a-good-practice-for-local-communities-fao/↩
Hoek van Dijke, A. J., Herold, M., Mallick, K., Benedict, I., Machwitz, M., Schlerf, M., Pranindita, A., Theeuwen, J.J.E., Bastin, J.F., & Teuling, A. J. (2022). Shifts in regional water availability due to global tree restoration. Nature Geoscience, 15(5), 363-368. ↩
IPCC (2003) Good Practice Guidance for Land Use, Land-Use Change and Forestry. Available at: https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/2018/03/GPG_LULUCF_FULLEN.pdf↩
Doraisami, M., Kish, R., Paroshy, N. J., Domke, G. M., Thomas, S. C., & Martin, A. R. (2022). A global database of woody tissue carbon concentrations. Scientific Data, 9(1), 284. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-022-01396-1↩
Aalde, Harald. vol. 4, Institute for Global Environmental Strategies (IGES), 2006. IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories: Agriculture, Forestry and Other Land Use. https://www.osti.gov/etdeweb/biblio/20880391↩↩2↩3
McGroddy, M. E., Daufresne, T., & Hedin, L. O. (2004). Scaling of C: N: P stoichiometry in forests worldwide: Implications of terrestrial redfield‐type ratios. Ecology, 85(9), 2390-2401. https://doi.org/10.1890/03-0351↩
Kattge, J., Bönisch, G., Díaz, S., Lavorel, S., Prentice, I. C., Leadley, P., ... & Cuntz, M. (2020). TRY plant trait database–enhanced coverage and open access. Global change biology, 26(1), 119-188. ↩
Haya, B. K., Evans, S., Brown, L., Bukoski, J., Butsic, V., Cabiyo, B., ... & Sanchez, D. L. (2023). Comprehensive review of carbon quantification by improved forest management offset protocols. Frontiers in Forests and Global Change, 6, 958879. https://doi.org/10.3389/ffgc.2023.958879↩↩2
Sanders‐DeMott, R., Hutyra, L. R., Hurteau, M. D., Keeton, W. S., Fallon, K. S., Anderegg, W. R. L., ... & Walker, W. S. (2025). Ground‐Truth: Can Forest Carbon Protocols Ensure High‐Quality Credits?. Earth's Future, 13(5), e2024EF005414. ↩
Coffield, S. R., Vo, C. D., Wang, J. A., Badgley, G., Goulden, M. L., Cullenward, D., ... & Randerson, J. T. (2022). Using remote sensing to quantify the additional climate benefits of California forest carbon offset projects. Global Change Biology, 28(22), 6789-6806. ↩
Andam, K. S., Ferraro, P. J., Pfaff, A., Sanchez-Azofeifa, G. A., & Robalino, J. A. (2008). Measuring the effectiveness of protected area networks in reducing deforestation. Proceedings of the national academy of sciences, 105(42), 16089-16094. ↩
Ferraro, P. J., & Hanauer, M. M. (2014). Quantifying causal mechanisms to determine how protected areas affect poverty through changes in ecosystem services and infrastructure. Proceedings of the national academy of sciences, 111(11), 4332-4337. ↩
Gao, S., Zhong, R., Yan, K., Ma, X., Chen, X., Pu, J., ... & Myneni, R. B. (2023). Evaluating the saturation effect of vegetation indices in forests using 3D radiative transfer simulations and satellite observations. Remote Sensing of Environment, 295, 113665. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2023.113665↩
An initial evaluation of carbon proxies for dynamic reforestation baselines. Pachama. Retrieved October 16, 2024, from https://pachama.com/blog/dynamic-reforestation-baselines/↩
Wilkinson, M. D., Dumontier, M., Aalbersberg, I. J., Appleton, G., Axton, M., Baak, A., ... & Mons, B. (2016). The FAIR Guiding Principles for scientific data management and stewardship. Scientific data, 3(1), 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1038/sdata.2016.18↩
Schwartzman, S., Lubowski, R. N., Pacala, S. W., Keohane, N. O., Kerr, S., Oppenheimer, M., & Hamburg, S. P. (2021). Environmental integrity of emissions reductions depends on scale and systemic changes, not sector of origin. Environ. Res. Lett, 16(9), 091001. https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ac18e8↩
Galik, C. S., Murray, B. C., Mitchell, S., & Cottle, P. (2016). Alternative approaches for addressing non-permanence in carbon projects: an application to afforestation and reforestation under the Clean Development Mechanism. Mitigation and adaptation strategies for global change, 21, 101-118. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11027-014-9573-4↩
Roberts, M. J., & Schlenker, W. (2013). Identifying supply and demand elasticities of agricultural commodities: Implications for the US ethanol mandate. American Economic Review, 103(6), 2265-2295. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.103.6.2265↩
Akiyama, T., & Varangis, P. N. (1990). The impact of the International Coffee Agreement on producing countries. The World Bank Economic Review, 4(2), 157-173. https://doi.org/10.1093/wber/4.2.157↩
Askari, H., & Cummings, J. T. (1977). Estimating Agricultural Supply Response with the Nerlove Model: A Survey. International Economic Review, 18(2), 257. https://doi.org/10.2307/2525749↩
Jere Richard Behrman, 1965. "Cocoa: A Study of Demand Elasticities in the Five Leading Consuming Countries, 1950–1961," American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Agricultural and Applied Economics Association, 47(2), 410-417. https://ideas.repec.org/a/oup/ajagec/v47y1965i2p410-417..html↩
Fragoso, R. M. D. S., Marques, C., Lucas, M. R., Martins, M. D. B., & Jorge, R. (2011). The economic effects of common agricultural policy on Mediterranean montado/dehesa ecosystem. Journal of Policy Modeling, 33(2), 311-327. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpolmod.2010.12.007. ↩
Mintert, J. R., Tonsor, G. T., & Schroeder, T. C. (2009). US beef demand drivers and enhancement opportunities: a research summary. https://beef.unl.edu/beefreports/symp-2009-14-xxi.shtml↩
Jeong, S. (2019). The change in price elasticities in the US beef cattle industry and the impact of futures prices in estimating the price elasticities. Proceedings of the NCCC-134 Conference on Applied Commodity Price Analysis, Forecasting, and Market Risk Management. Minneapolis, MN. http://www.farmdoc.illinois.edu/nccc134↩
UN-REDD: Defintion of market leakage [Accessed October 2024]. Available at: https://www.un-redd.org/glossary/market-leakage#:~:text=Definition,actors%20to%20shift%20their%20activities↩
Pendrill, F., Persson, U. M., Godar, J., & Kastner, T. (2019). Deforestation displaced: trade in forest-risk commodities and the prospects for a global forest transition. Environmental Research Letters, 14(5), 055003. https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ab0d41↩
Lark, T. J., Hendricks, N. P., Smith, A., Pates, N., Spawn-Lee, S. A., Bougie, M., Booth, E. G., Kucharik, C. J., & Gibbs, H. K. (2022). Environmental outcomes of the US Renewable Fuel Standard. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 119(9). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2101084119↩
Bowman, M. S., Soares-Filho, B. S., Merry, F. D., Nepstad, D. C., Rodrigues, H., & Almeida, O. T. (2012). Persistence of cattle ranching in the Brazilian Amazon: A spatial analysis of the rationale for beef production. Land use policy, 29(3), 558-568. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2011.09.009. ↩
Wu, Z., Satter, L., & Sojo, R. (2000). Milk production, reproductive performance, and fecal excretion of phosphorus by dairy cows fed three amounts of phosphorus. Journal of Dairy Science, 83(5), 1028–1041. https://doi.org/10.3168/jds.s0022-0302(00)74967-8↩
Coffee Barometer. In Coffee Barometer (pp. 1–36). https://hivos.org/assets/2018/06/Coffee-Barometer-2018.pdf↩
Westfall, J. A., Coulston, J. W., Gray, A. N., Shaw, J. D., Radtke, P. J., Walker, D. M., Weiskittel, A. R., MacFarlane, D. W., Affleck, D. L., Zhao, D., Temesgen, H., Poudel, K. P., Frank, J. M., Prisley, S. P., Wang, Y., Meador, A. J. S., Auty, D., & Domke, G. M. (2023). A national-scale tree volume, biomass, and carbon modeling system for the United States. https://doi.org/10.2737/wo-gtr-104↩
Masiliūnas, D., Tsendbazar, N. E., Herold, M., Lesiv, M., Buchhorn, M., & Verbesselt, J. (2021). Global land characterisation using land cover fractions at 100 m resolution. Remote Sensing of Environment, 259, 112409. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2021.112409. ↩
Captain, N., Xu, P., Herold, M., Lesiv, M., Duerauer, M., Ruben Van De Kerchove, VITO, & Olivier Arino. (2022). Product Validation report. https://worldcover2021.esa.int/data/docs/WorldCover_PVR_V2.0.pdf↩
Brown, C. F., Brumby, S. P., Guzder-Williams, B., Birch, T., Hyde, S. B., Mazzariello, J., Czerwinski, W., Pasquarella, V. J., Haertel, R., Ilyushchenko, S., Schwehr, K., Weisse, M., Stolle, F., Hanson, C., Guinan, O., Moore, R., & Tait, A. M. (2022). Dynamic World, Near real-time global 10 m land use land cover mapping. Scientific Data, 9(1). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-022-01307-4↩
Venter, Z. S., Barton, D. N., Chakraborty, T., Simensen, T., & Singh, G. (2022). Global 10 m land use land cover datasets: A comparison of dynamic world, world cover and esri land cover. Remote Sensing, 14(16), 4101. https://doi.org/10.3390/rs14164101↩
IPCC, 2023: Climate Change 2023: Synthesis Report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Core Writing Team, H. Lee and J. Romero (eds.)]. IPCC, Geneva, Switzerland, pp. 35-115. https://doi.org/10.59327/IPCC/AR6-9789291691647↩↩2↩3
Nardi, F., Annis, A., Di Baldassarre, G., Vivoni, E. R., & Grimaldi, S. (2019). GFPLAIN250m, a global high-resolution dataset of Earth’s floodplains. Scientific data, 6(1), 1-6. ↩